3 ms·
Why stop there? Abolish time zones. Everyone should be using UTC directly. This would solve more problems than it causes.
by zdw 15y ago
Why stop there? Abolish time zones. Everyone should be using UTC directly.
This would solve more problems than it causes.
- mixmastamyk 15y agoOne step at a time will lessen the shock.
- majika 15y agoI vehemently disagree. I think the problems that this causes are larger than the current solution. Timezones aren't a human construction. Humans have only offered a series of approximations that are accurate enough. Cognitive dissonance: What time is the business day of Shanghai? What time should I arrive in New York to get there in the morning? What time will my American guildmates be online? People would still have to memorise the major timezone offsets, and this would negate any purported advantages. If we're still going to have to memorise timezone offsets, why bother? Rather than asking "what's the time in New York?," I'll be asking "what part of the day is it in New York?" The latter will be asked in place of the other, but it would also be harder to answer due to no localised New York time. "What's the time in New York?" can be answered by knowing that American EST is GMT-5. My local timezone is GMT+10, and it's currently 1300. Hence, I now know that it's 12 PM in New York, which means it's dark, which means that businesses there are shut and it's a bad time to call friends there. I'll admit that DST makes things harder, but I can still calculate a good approximation on the fly. 11 or 12 PM - it doesn't really matter. If it does, well, I know that the northern hemisphere will be at the end of Autumn, so NY-local DST is probably over. With one global timezone, how do I answer "what part of the day is it in New York?" Well, I still have to remember that New York's "timezone" is -4 GMT, and I still have to remember that my local "timezone" is +10 GMT. I still have to do a calculation, but I have to have a mapping of times to the state of the day in my head to know where New York is in relation. It's so much more complicated. It also makes it hard to know "when" a certain place is. Say I arrive in London, and it's overcast. I'd actually have to calculate what part of the day it is, by working off my home time->day-state mapping. That's so wrong.
- muyuu 15y agoNowadays synchronization matters a lot more than knowing "what part of the day" is it in a given place. Take into consideration that "parts of the day" work within similar ranges of distance to the equator. If we all used UTC, for instance, I'd only have to work approximately what time do people work and have their meals in different parts of the world, and arranging a call, for instance, would always be trivial. When talking about a time all parties would know it they can make it or not straight away. Time zones are a relic from the 20th century as far as I'm concerned, but they might as well stick forever.
- PotatoEngineer 15y agoSynchronizing schedules across many time zones is a problem for a pretty small proportion of the populace. Who needs to regularly worry about people 8 time zones away? Maybe 25% of all people in IT (I'll estimate high because outsourcing is popular), and maybe 5% of all white-collar jobs. And, one more number made up on the spot... call that 2% of the world population. And that's being generous. Time zones work for 98% of the world, the 2% will just have to do a little more thinking.
- muyuu 15y agoAnything would work for the vast majority of the world as long as it was stable. That shouldn't stop us from not artificially making it worse.
- muuh-gnu 15y ago> Rather than asking "what's the time in New York?," I'll be asking "what part of the day is it in New York?" Except that the current time zones dont really tell you that, sice most of them are decided politically, not by mapping to sunrise/sunset as closely as possible. The world time zone map is a irrational mess, including time jumps of 2-3 hours when crossing a land border, or time zones changing backwards becuse of convulted political borders. http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ad/Standard_time_zones_of_the_world.png http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ad/Standard_...
- InclinedPlane 15y agoThis doesn't solve the problem, it just shifts it around. How do you judge whether an airline flight that arrives at X time UTC in Tokyo, Seattle, or Moscow is arriving in the morning or evening? What do you do to plan your arrival? Do you check into a hotel and immediately fall asleep? Do you get breakfast? Do you need to get a friend to pick you up because it's so early in the morning that the local public transit isn't running? Similarly, how do you decide when to schedule a meeting during normal business hours with someone in another part of the world? There are a million more things, of course. The point is that you need to keep track of this sort of thing. Which means you need to have some sort of system to do so. And if you don't have time zones then you need some other method of keeping track of similar data so that people can make use of it and computers can use it to help implement their business logic. In the end you end up duplicating the idea of time zones except in a half-assed, non-standardized, non-straightforward to implement way. Whereas if you just have the idea of time zones and "local time" you can deal with problems that depend on relative time of day.
- cromulent 15y agoI fully agree that time zones are an essential part of determining not just the relative local time of day, but what day it is. A million things, as you say, but that's the killer one for me. If you switched to UTC only, then if it is Monday one meter west of the prime meridian, is it really Tuesday two meters to the East? And what time does Tuesday start in Los Angeles - 4pm? Crikey. A day is based on the period of the Earth's rotation, and for most life forms it's linked to the time the Earth faces the Sun. Time zones are a granular way of knowing what time it is in other longitudes consistently. Changing the granularity from 20-odd to one, or a thousand, makes it much worse, not better. The idea that removing time zones "solves more problems than it causes" - I don't buy it either.