4 ms·
> It makes me embarrassed to use Linux. All of Linux? Why? There's a bunch of competing desktop environments you can use instead.
by josephcsible 4y ago
> It makes me embarrassed to use Linux.
All of Linux? Why? There's a bunch of competing desktop environments you can use instead.
- smoldesu 4y agoI do use other desktop environments, and making them feel like home feels futile when a significant portion of development effort is focused on building Titanic-like projects such as Wayland or Flatpak. That's mostly the same reason that I can't recommend it to other people, there's no way to tell everyday people all this stuff with a straight face. The year of the Linux Desktop feels like it's been postponed indefinitely while we shave a bunch of redundant yaks. GNOME wants everyone to live in a world where they have two package managers and download multiple gigabytes of redundant runtime dependencies that shouldn't need to exist in the first place. Our overall community focus should be towards delivering robust software that works with live USBs, natively-packaging and Flatpak. I fear that we're heading down a pretty horrible path where people will build fragile software that links against even more esoteric runtime requirements, creating software that's completely unusable unless it's running in digital life support (aka, Flatpak). I despise Windows, but even downloading 10x 100mb C++ redistributables is better than having 5x 1.5-2gb GNOME runtimes. Nobody deserves to live in a world where that's how their software is delivered, it's a travesty. Even Apple doesn't hate their users enough to do this, not on MacOS and not on iOS. They had the dignity to make actually stable APIs that software could target, so they don't have to live in this virtualized hellscape that we've built for ourselves. Everything GNOME tacks on to the desktop Linux experience makes it increasingly feel like that 4chan image macro of the GNU/car (https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CDEORUBWAAENKFC.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CDEORUBWAAENKFC.jpg). At least, that's how it feels when you have to explain to someone that screenshare isn't working right now because you're "logged in to the wrong desktop session"...
- hulitu 4y ago> I despise Windows, but even downloading 10x 100mb C++ redistributables is better than having 5x 1.5-2gb GNOME runtimes. There is fvwm, vtwm even lxde, you know.
- doubled112 4y agoXfce is a pretty complete desktop experience, assuming you think Windows 7 was about where it peaked. You don't need to use the defaults.
- torstenvl 4y agoXfce relies on GTK, so it would seem subject to the whims of the Gnome team in a lot of ways. Do you know of any plans to wrest control of GTK away or fork it?
- smoldesu 4y agoI don't think XFCE intends to switch to GTK4, and if they do then it will probably be towards the end of the update cycle.
- smoldesu 4y agoThat's not the problem. The problem is that any Flatpak I download also comes with several gigabytes of GNOME runtime dependencies, which is absurd and shouldn't be treated as "the new normal" of software distribution. Running to alternative DEs doesn't solve the problem.
- Crysstalis 4y agoThat was already the normal long before flatpak. Installing the same packages with your distro package manager will also install the same several gigabytes. The number you see in flatpak might be an illusion though, the real amount of space taken up on disk is less: https://blogs.gnome.org/wjjt/2021/11/24/on-flatpak-disk-usage-and-deduplication/ https://blogs.gnome.org/wjjt/2021/11/24/on-flatpak-disk-usag... So flatpak may actually be a solution to the problem that you don't realize. It can only cause a big issue if you have a lot of old software that never updates the runtime.
- Crysstalis 4y ago>I fear that we're heading down a pretty horrible path where people will build fragile software that links against even more esoteric runtime requirements, creating software that's completely unusable unless it's running in digital life support (aka, Flatpak). This is an unfounded fear, you have placed the cart before the horse. It was much worse in the past without things like flatpak and docker. Old programs would still have the esoteric runtime requirements, except they would just break when the distro decided to stop supporting them. As for the rest of your comment, it's not compelling to use 4chan trolling to make your case.
- smoldesu 4y ago> This is an unfounded fear, you have placed the cart before the horse. It was much worse in the past without things like flatpak and docker. Not really. "In the past" we could write hermetic packaging for our software so it doesn't break, but GNOME decided not to do that (despite the fact that Hurd and Nix both provide sane jumping-off points). They chose instead to create a world where we coddle our developers with a 1.6gb thick runtime that is apparently required to run a 4mb program. That is insane, and I'm not walking it back. There are real solutions to system breakage, and history has dictated that thick runtimes literally never work out well! I don't really care though. I haven't had software break on APT or Nix in over 5 years of usage. Last night I boot up a Flatpak and it turns out they still haven't fixed the horrible font rendering issues in GTK4. If you still have problems with your software when you're running it with multiple gigabytes of explicit dependencies actively loaded on my system, what are we even doing here? I've had more problems dealing with Flatpak than I have with any other package manager, and I've only ever tried 3 or 4 programs with the damn thing. I can't imagine how useless a system like Silverblue would feel... Thankfully though, much like Wayland, there's no real motivation to switch to Flatpak besides a couple GNOME apps, which I'm pretty sure most people don't really want anyways (a clock app that's more than 1000mb to download? it's more likely than you might think!) > As for the rest of your comment, it's not compelling to use 4chan trolling to make your case. That's fine, I've known that ever since I wondered why there still aren't thumbnails in GNOME's filepicker (whaddya know, looks like stopping people from using their native filepicker is the parent article today). GNOME's developers will ignore me the same as everyone else who makes suggestions for them, so there's no point in filing issues (especially since I don't use their DE anyways). I don't really care about the emotional appeals of my argument here. This is a well-documented shortcoming, and many people on HN seem to agree that GNOME's leadership is on a power-high right now.