7 ms·
> People need lots of things. The principal constraints on real estate are political. (The entire concept of real estate is a social construct.) Not physical sp
by andsoitis 4y ago
> People need lots of things. The principal constraints on real estate are political. (The entire concept of real estate is a social construct.) Not physical space.
Even if (the amount of) physical space isn't one of the main constraints on real estate, any particular location may be more desirable relative to others, e.g. a gorgeous view, away from factories or highways.
- gruez 4y agoNah, it's social constructs all the way down. A location might have gorgeous views, but if it's in a rural area and urbanization intensifies (think pre-pandemic), it will left in the dust as jobs and businesses dry up. Same goes if it's in downtown and it gets hollowed out (eg. white flight).
- motohagiography 4y agoDo animals have social constructs? Because they have dens and territory that they use to survive as well. Property is a pretty universal value.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> they have dens and territory that they use to survive as well A bear's den isn't its property any more than a park bench slept on becomes the slumberer's own. Property, specifically, the system that relates a person to some land via a bundle of use rights, is a deep human construct. It likely goes back to the dawn of agriculture and civilization [1]. [1] https://books.google.com/books?id=f_roIy7ceEsC https://books.google.com/books?id=f_roIy7ceEsC
- yellowapple 4y ago> A bear's den isn't its property any more than a park bench slept on becomes the slumberer's own. A bear, however, will use (and indeed seek to monopolize) violence to defend its den. That makes it property, at least until the bear relinquishes its claim (or something - or someone - else challenges its monopoly on violence).
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> bear, however, will use (and indeed seek to monopolize) violence to defend its den. That makes it property That makes it territory. The simplest definition of property might be use rights one doesn’t need to use violence to defend. (Countries don’t have property.)
- yellowapple 4y ago> The simplest definition of property might be use rights one doesn’t need to use violence to defend. For something to be property entails all of: - usus: the right to use it; - fructus: the right to profit or otherwise benefit from it; and - abusus: the right to destroy it, alter it, or otherwise exclude others from it Abusus is in and of itself violence (specifically, theft) unless consented to by all other members of society. By "use rights" you might be thinking of something like usufruct, which is distinct from property and (as you correctly assess) does not necessarily entail violence or the monopolization thereof. > Countries don’t have property. Of course they do: their sovereign territory. It is indeed that property, enforced via a country's / nation-state's monopoly on violence - from which all land ownership derives (hence: that piece of paper called a "deed" that would be useful only as kindling or sanitary napkins if not for the state enforcing it).
- pessimizer 4y agoA bear's den isn't it's property, it's somewhere the bear lives. If a den were a bear's property, the bear would have paperwork.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> any particular location may be more desirable relative to others, e.g. a gorgeous view, away from factories or highways It's politics, usually, keeping the factories and highways away. More fundamentally, the notion that a piece of paper (the deed) gives you certain rights (but not others) over some land is totally made up.
- cellis 4y agoThis is true. It’s also true that “your body” is just a social construct. The rabbit hole of “property is just an idea” doesn’t end well for humans who seek agency.
- pessimizer 4y agoThat "property" is just a series of laws and agreements that we can change arbitrarily is neither a tricky concept nor a slippery slope. A body is not a series of laws and agreements that we can change arbitrarily, it's a hunk of meat. "Your body" can be a social construct if you want it to be, but that probably means that you're having a disassociative episode.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoChattel slavery wants a word with you.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Chattel slavery wants a word with you Chattel slavery underlines the point. What is and isn’t property is decided, arbitrarily, by people. Because property is a social construct. What is and isn’t someone’s body does not depend on others accepting it has meaning. How it’s treated does. But my body has inherent value to me independent of others’ perceptions of it. This is, at its core, the problem with slavery. If we reject property being a social construct we reject the fact that the government, a social construct itself, could have legalised and then outlawed slavery. Because if property is inherently meaningful, how can the government poof it away?