8 ms·
On the use of a life (2020)
- schoen 4y ago(2020)
- metadat 4y agoThanks, title updated!
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI can relate (long story, lots of tears. Get your hanky); except for the "able to buy a house with the proceeds" part. The stuff that I'm most satisfied with, has never earned me a cent. In fact, it has cost me thousands. I know that the software that I've written has actually helped save lives, so maybe it's not really a "waste"?
- mandmandam 4y agoIt seems to be common knowledge that the systems behind publishing papers and getting grants are nearly completely broken. It feels like a weird hazing ritual, where the people who get through it fiercely defend their abuse. > Is entrepreneurship a trap? No; right now, it's one of the only ways to avoid being trapped. ... Realistically, you need to be rather well off to have even one good shot at starting a company. Get sick at the wrong time and forget about it. Get less than very lucky, and forget about it. Get your ideas stolen by a megacorp; forget about it. I'm so tired of seeing truly extraordinary people forced to do menial labour to survive, and starting a company in the hopes of getting lucky isn't all that much better.
- nonrandomstring 4y ago> I'm so tired of seeing truly extraordinary people forced to do menial labour to survive This * 10. The teacher/mentor part of me relishes seeing success for others. Meeting many talented, creative and hard working people in my life had been a privilege. But I do feel a sense of injustice and awful waste. To see people who could change the world and solve real problems settle for less, that hurts. When graduation time comes around I sometimes feel a dark sense of helplessness, and maybe something of a hypocrite/imposter because the one thing I cannot teach or offer is opportunity. > and starting a company in the hopes of getting lucky isn't all that much better. Maybe not, but I encourage all of them to give it a shot once in life. At least failure is yours to own and not feeling thwarted by some manager prick whose decision to obstruct your dream was just a way to get by for one more day in a firm they couldn't care less for.
- scottyah 4y ago> I'm so tired of seeing truly extraordinary people forced to do menial labour to survive On the bright side, it's probably never been easier for genius type people to become societally useful (and rewarded for it) than now! I was just reading Two Years Before The Mast (1835-ish), where the Harvard educated protagonist met a savant type person working on a ship, but that person was doomed to not rise above his position without a lifetime of struggle. It's not foolproof by any means, but our education system at least found @cperciva and gave him ample status just for his applied intellect to where he could pursue almost anything he wished.
- jl6 4y agoUntil a man is twenty-five he still thinks, every so often, that under the right circumstances he could be the baddest motherfucking programmer in the world. If I moved to an APT in North Korea and studied real hard for ten years. If my family was wiped out by Colombian drug dealers and I swore myself to revenge. If I got a fatal disease, had one year to live, devoted it to wiping out side channels. If I just dropped out and devoted my life to wizardry. I used to feel that way, too, but then I ran into cperciva. In a way, this is liberating. I no longer have to worry about being the baddest motherfucking programmer in the world. The position is taken.
- ge96 4y ago> studied real hard for ten years Somewhat related thought. I wonder about this with regard to AGI, I have this fantasy of a symbiote/friend thing. But it is not easy to make that. I don't know if I have the real/actual drive to do it. I'm also a mediocre programmer/developer. That kind of passion where you do it every free moment of your time/not monetary based. It is not for me. I tinker on CRUD stuff/low-end robotics on my free time. So yeah not sure of effort vs. talent/genius.
- Swizec 4y ago> That kind of passion where you do it every free moment of your time/not monetary based I used to have that passion. Every waking moment devoted to figuring out cool things. Or at least what seemed cool to me. Then one day I joined a rocketship company and all my side projects and ideas started to feel small, boring, and insignificant. The grandest idea I could come up with couldn’t hold a light to even the most mundane problems a real business in the hockeystick part of the curve comes up with. Sometimes I miss the motivation to tinker. Sometimes I cherish my newfound ability to relax. Perhaps one day I will tinker once more.
- ge96 4y agoYeah having a full time job does limit you a lot with what you can do after the day is done. When I was younger (10+ years ago) I had all kinds of crazy ideas/things to make. High traffic websites, get rich, that kind of thing. But they were all dumb... unvalidated, went nowhere. But now that I know how to build things (web) I don't have any ideas. Funny how that works. When you look at indie projects seems like there's so many niches/ways to make money out there. But personally I found it hard to do hence 9-5er.
- Cerium 4y agoBeyond the well reasoned response, I object to the premise that it's "just backups". Quality backups are a big ug lever for ensuring that others work is able to continue and exist to be appreciated.
- kragen 4y agoYeah, but generally the reason people's backups don't work aren't that they're using backup software written by programmers who weren't smart enough to win the Putnam. Generally when people's backups don't work it's because they don't do the backups, or because they set up the backups in a way that can't work (for example, forgetting to back up the files they really care about, or backing up a live database tablespace with a filesystem backup tool without snapshots), or because they're in some kind of a dysfunctional relationship with a vendor like Google that doesn't give them programmatic access to their own files so they can't do backups. So, while I don't think it's bad for cperciva to have spent a lot of time working on Tarsnap, which is clearly a useful piece of software, I also think things like scrypt actually matter more in the end. However, I also think cperciva is a better judge of what to spend his life on than I am.
- balsam 4y agoIn a sense, the difference between entrepreneurs and (idealized) academics is in making what people want right now versus making what they think people (in the future, might) want. So, trusting other people’s judgement over your own, including how to spend your life. Modulo Steve Jobs and lots of unearned capital.
- cperciva 4y agoPreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24537865 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24537865
- ghoward 4y agoRandom question: would you be willing to do an paid audit of new cryptographic code?
- cperciva 4y agoYes, if it's in my (fairly narrow) area of expertise. About 90% of the time when someone approaches me with audit work the answer ends up being "I'm not the right person to hire for this".
- ghoward 4y agoWhat is your narrow area of expertise? Passwords and memory-hard functions? I figure scrypt is, but I'm not using that. I'm implementing OPAQUE with Argon2.
- stopachka 4y agoThere's a big truth here that screams out to me. If you want to do great work, you need freedom first.
- hprotagonist 4y agoIf you pay a man a salary for doing research, he and you will want to have something to point to at the end of the year to show that the money has not been wasted. In promising work of the highest class, however, results do not come in this regular fashion, in fact years may pass without any tangible result being obtained, and the position of the paid worker would be very embarrassing and he would naturally take to work on a lower, or at any rate a different plane where he could be sure of getting year by year tangible results which would justify his salary. The position is this: You want one kind of research, but, if you pay a man to do it, it will drive him to research of a different kind. The only thing to do is to pay him for doing something else and give him enough leisure to do research for the love of it. -- from the biography of J. J. Thompson
- auggierose 4y agoAmen. It's really a simple thing to understand. But most people involved in academia don't (want to).
- hprotagonist 4y agowe all know. we just can’t figure out how the fuck to get it funded. That sort of blue-sky culture needs a whole lot of disinterested money, and that’s hard to come by. In previous generations, we’ve used monopolists, the gentry, and other ways…always a challenge.
- auggierose 4y agoIf you know, you'll find a way to do the research you want anyway. So, no problem here. But I guess the problem is finding out which research you really want to do. You might find other aspects of life more rewarding / interesting / important.
- photochemsyn 4y agoAcademics are not the place to go to make useful novel contributions, there are too many confounding factors. First, the university owns whatever IP you come up with, and will happily exclusively license that IP to entities with no interest in developing it. Monopolistic corporate power centers aren't known for fostering novel competition to their established businesses. This is why it took so long - and serious capital - to get something like Tesla going, as the likes of Toyota, Ford, GM etc. were closely tied to Exxon, Chevron etc. via their investors, and had no interest in developing electric cars. Any kind of applied research in the US academic sector these days is best understood as corporate R & D for established interests in pharmaceuticals, technology, industrial chemistry, etc. You're certainly not free to do blue-skies renewable energy research (budgets for that are still miniscule at best, and have been since the 1980s), for example. The job description has become indistinguishable from that of in-house corporate researcher - narrowly defined assigned problems are what you get to work on, and 'academic freedom to pursue the research wherever it leads' is a quaint myth. The obvious fix is to eliminate exclusive licensing of academic IP (i.e. repeal the 1980s Bayh-Dole Act), which would force corporations to spend capital on their own private R & D divisions if the wanted exclusivity, and simply make any university-held patented discovery available to any entrepreneur who wanted to develop it for a small flat fee. Until then the author is 100% correct about entrepreneurship being the only way out of the trap.
- schoen 4y agoHe was specifically going to be an academic mathematician, which would probably have allowed him to publish discoveries without patenting or licensing them.
- abirch 4y agoMIT is an R&D corporation which has a college attached. MIT filed 358 US patents and had 435 issued in the year ending June 30, 2021. https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/23/1044184/5-mit-patents-that-changed-computing/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/23/1044184/5-mit-pa...
- eastbound 4y ago
- elric 4y agoI hadn't heard of spiped, and I was very happy to discover it through this blog post. It's elegant, simple, and solves a problem I was over-engineering my own solution for. So thanks, Colin!
- aidenn0 4y agospiped is amazing. I remember looking for something to use Kivaloo for when TFA came out, but I don't have any need for what it offers
- ChrisArchitect 4y ago(2020) Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24537865 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24537865
- cableshaft 4y agoI've had more of an urge to do some research on CS topics lately (beyond the usual you can find in textbooks), but as someone who was never in academia, and only got an undergraduate degree, I don't really know how to approach it as an outsider, like what sources I should use, how to find something to focus on, etc. Does anyone else have any experience with this and have any recommendations for how to approach it? I imagine I'll probably have more success in areas that are game or recreational mathematics related (like Martin Gardner), at least to get started.
- 70rd 4y agoHard question to answer without specifying topics. The usual way is to find an introductory textbook on the subject, find the papers and authors referenced for results and theorems and work forward through the literature. This will give you both historical perspective and develop your knowledge at a gradual pace.
- sebastian_z 4y agoYou could look for academic conferences in your area of interest and see what people are working on [1]. It is not necessary to have particular degree for submitting your work to a conference. Since most review processes are double-blind no one would know at submission time anyways. Though, knowing the process and how a "typical" paper looks like, on which people in academia have an advantage, certainly helps a lot. [1] E.g., https://www.computer.org/publications/tech-news/events/2022-top-computer-science-conferences https://www.computer.org/publications/tech-news/events/2022-....
- rhines 4y agoWhile I also only completed an undergraduate degree, I did spend a few semesters doing research with a professor and ended up being co-author on a paper with him. Doing a first paper without the guidance of a researcher in the field would be very hard, but doable, and certainly performing research is doable. I'd start with figuring out roughly what you want to investigate. Try to narrow it down as much as you can, but I understand that it'll start broad and probably eventually narrow down after going down a few rabbit holes. Eventually you have a pretty specific field you know you want to do research in. Find the top conferences in the field, look through some of the papers that seem interesting, and look at what they cite. You should be able to compile a list of textbooks and foundational articles that crop up often - read all of these. Maybe even try to replicate the results of some of the foundational papers - a lot of the time new work is extensions of the foundations, and people writing papers started out replicating those initial works anyway. If you're struggling to narrow things down or figure out what's important, focus on papers from one researcher or research group. Maybe even send them an email if you want their advice on what to read. Finally, you have a decent grasp of the underpinnings of this narrow field and have seen some examples of how it's been extended in modern times. You might now have some ideas of what to experiment with in your own research, or if not you can try replicating more modern papers and see if that gives you ideas of what more to investigate.
- spekcular 4y agoThe author writes: "Is there a hypothetical world where I would be an academic working on the Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture right now? Sure. It's probably a world where high-flying students are given, upon graduation, some sort of "mini-Genius Grant". If I had been awarded a five-year $62,500/year grant with the sole condition of "do research", I would almost certainly have persevered in academia and — despite working on the more interesting but longer-term questions — have had enough publications after those five years to obtain a continuing academic position. But that's not how granting agencies work; they give out one or two year awards, with the understanding that those who are successful will apply for more funding later." These awards certainly exist; the Miller institute at Berkeley, the Simons fellows in NYC, and the Clay Fellows are a few examples. (Some not quite for 5 years, but more than 2. Also, the pay is more like 90k.) The NSF math postdoc is also close to this (2 years full funding if you elect to not teach those years, plus a third year where you have to teach.) Regular NSF grants and NSF CAREER awards are also longer, IIRC, though perhaps less relevant to fresh PhDs. So, in fact, these "mini-Genius Grants" do exist.
- nl 4y agoIt's worth emphasizing this part of the quote from the author: > But that's not how granting agencies work; they give out one or two year awards, with the understanding that those who are successful will apply for more funding later. I've worked for a funding agency. It's tough to give out five year grants with no deliverables other than "be a genius". When you are funding basic research you have to be prepared for the idea that lots will fail, and many people will decide to leave. How do you know who is a genius when they are finishing their PhD? Everyone finishing a PhD at Oxford/MIT/Stanford/etc has a very impressive resume and the reality is you can't fund them all. Two year grants seems a reasonable compromise here.
- cperciva 4y agoHow do you know who is a genius when they are finishing their PhD? Everyone finishing a PhD at Oxford/MIT/Stanford/etc has a very impressive resume Impressive resumes, sure. But my experience has been that even when students are starting their doctorates there's very clear tiers -- even out of the pool of doctoral students in Oxford. (In case anyone is thinking this is hubris on my part: I would say I was towards the top but not at the top. The most impressive student I met in Oxford was a mathematician by the name of Lillian Pierce -- and she wasn't even doing her doctorate yet.)
- wbharding 4y ago> Sure, I have customers to assist, servers to manage (not that they need much management), and business accounting to do; but professors equally have classes to teach, students to supervise, and committees to attend. When it comes to research, I can follow my interests without regard to the whims of granting agencies and tenure and promotion committees. As a fellow developer/owner, this is the mantra I'm always repeating. Is running a small software biz a great job? Meh. The job has higher highs and lower lows than when I was a dev for other companies. At the end of the day, there's no better way to make sustained progress on groundbreaking, long-term dev projects than to run a company that dedicated to building such projects. If one is fortunate enough to find a stable cash source (like Tarsnap), it serves as a perpetual license to work on the most interesting dev projects one can fathom succeeding at.
- balsam 4y agoMaybe this is the reason people can be so smart and not rich: they trust their own judgement over that of others and fail to make either what NSF want or what VCs think what other people want. At least in academia there is peer review to shorten the feedback loop.
- hyperpallium2 4y agoIn business you follow the market; in academia you follow the grants committee. But in a start-up, you can follow what you think is important - and see if anyone needs it. Raise the flag, and see if anyone salutes. “If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.” - Ford Of course, infrastructure and support etc makes it easier. Industry labs like PARC used to be like this. In addition to the genius part, not everyone has the other qualities needed to run the whole show.
- cratermoon 4y ago"I wanted to succeed in academia I would need to churn out incremental research papers every year — at very least until I had tenure" I sympathize with that track. It's essential the long-term version of "show your work". He would have spent at least 5 years, perhaps many more, writing papers based on small bits of his overall findings on shared caches in multi-threaded CPUs as a cryptographic side channel. Each paper would focus on a tiny bit of the problem, and eventually build up to a full foundation for the real work. All well and good, until some academic with tenure and a raft of papers to his name decides to go ahead and write the actual paper that needs to be written, and takes credit for the important results.
- benreesman 4y agoI have a tattoo on my arm of some (ostensibly) last recorded words of Evaristé Galois. A guy who did more for human progress than some whole nation states. @cperceiva is in the k-equivalence class of people whose ability we lack the granularity to measure. He won the Putnam before making multiple unanticipated contributions to security in general and the security of FreeBSD in particular. @pg has tagged him in particular as notable. If he spends his time making information more durable in a probably secure way as opposed to folding proteins, I’m going to leave it to him to have decided between multiple highly compelling outlets for his genius. In my observation he’s too humble to reply to the ankle-biting haters, but I have no such qualms: this guy is a fucking legend and if you disagree let’s have an argument.
- KronisLV 4y agoI find myself loving how barebones the site is - there are no distractions, only the text of the article itself. While capping the maximum width of the text paragraphs might be a good idea for readability (slightly less horizontal eye movement; though some might also disagree), it's as if I've stumbled into some alternate universe where web development is very minimalistic.
- 0xcb0 4y agoGreat note on why to follow what you love in life. Things may be different from what you and others thought you would do when you "grow up" and be an academic. But follow what you love and create something useful, even though some things don't get the attention they deserve, is the best one can do. We all should do more of this and the world would be a better one!
- langsoul-com 4y agoIt's always weird how people always think your wasting your life, no matter what you do. I've been pondering if there's really any "superior" way to spend one's time. If the concept of wasting time even exists. Especially with hustle porn these days, if you aren't building million dollar project, then you're "wasting time".
- moyix 4y agocperciva, if you're around, I'd be really curious to hear a bit more about the details behind your attempts to get "Cache Missing for Fun and Profit". I'm really surprised that it was so hard to find a home for it! Maybe a more general security venue like USENIX Sec, ACM CCS, or IEEE S&P would have been a better fit for something that was neither fish nor fowl? Just a couple years later in 2008 USENIX Sec published "Reverse-Engineering a Cryptographic RFID Tag" which is a personal favorite and similarly is a mix of low-level hardware architecture and cryptography. There were two other shared CPU cache side channel attacks on cryptography in 2005 (DJB's "Cache-timing attacks on AES" [2] and Osvik/Shamir/Tromer's "Cache Attacks and Countermeasures: the Case of AES" [3]) so in some ways it feels like the time was right for the community to start finding these attacks -- which makes it all the more baffling to me that your work got rejected. I'm also a bit dismayed at the advice not to work on anything too novel. I guess it's true in some ways (our Chaff Bugs [4] paper and an associated grant proposal got rejected for four years straight with comments like "the panel was uniformly skeptical that anyone would ever be willing to use this" [5]), but it feels from the inside that it just takes more work to convince people to take a chance on new ideas, and that the larger issue is just how much inherent randomness there is in the peer review system [6] (my advisor used to say it wasn't worth paying attention to the first rejection, and not to worry until it was rejected a second time -- and I think it's only gotten worse since then). Good work gets rejected all the time, and it sucks :( Anyway, you clearly seem pretty happy with how things ended up, so perhaps I'm just saying that I'm disappointed that we in academic security missed out on the opportunity to have you as a colleague ;) [1] https://www.usenix.org/legacy/event/sec08/tech/full_papers/nohl/nohl_html/ https://www.usenix.org/legacy/event/sec08/tech/full_papers/n... [2] http://cr.yp.to/antiforgery/cachetiming-20050414.pdf http://cr.yp.to/antiforgery/cachetiming-20050414.pdf [3] https://eprint.iacr.org/2005/271.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2005/271.pdf [4] https://arxiv.org/abs/1808.00659 https://arxiv.org/abs/1808.00659 [5] Possibly this is true, I admit. [6] See e.g. the NeurIPS 2014 and 2021 consistency experiments: https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.09774 https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.09774, https://blog.neurips.cc/2021/12/08/the-neurips-2021-consistency-experiment/ https://blog.neurips.cc/2021/12/08/the-neurips-2021-consiste...