2 ms·
I don't understand how a term which almost perfectly describes the group it describes can be offensive to that group. What specifically is offensive about bein
by tsimionescu 4y ago
I don't understand how a term which almost perfectly describes the group it describes can be offensive to that group.
What specifically is offensive about being called a "Trans-exclusionary radical feminist"? The idea that they are radical feminists? Or the idea that they are seeking to exclude trans women from female discourse (and often forcibly seeking to include trans men)?
Now sure, if I used this term to refer to someone like Donald Trump, I would understand why he would be offended at being called a radical feminist, but the people who are seeking to label this "a slur" are exactly radical feminists like JK Rowling who happen to also hate trans identities.
This reminds me of the billionaire who was claiming "billionaire" has become a slur since people use it with a negative connotation. If you're a billionaire and people happen to not like billionaires, they're not being offensive when they're calling you that.
It doesn't even have the mocking grandiose tone of the "Warrior" in SJW used to describe people who are commenting online...
Note: this is not the same as slurs like the infamous n-word, since those were designed as insults, often referring to a hated/perceived as inferior natural characteristic or a mocking comparison. They were not descriptive terms referring to beliefs of a group that the speaker disagreed with.
- thrown_22 4y ago
- tsimionescu 4y agoI explained at the end why this is not remotely the same. The color of your skin is not a charcateristic that describes your deeply held beliefs, and it is not something that you could change about yourself. Not to mention, the n-word has a long history of being used explicitly to demean and de-humanize and oppress the people it describes. Few are demeaning, dehumanizing, and definitely not oppressing TERFs. There are not, and have never been, laws that declare a TERF to value 3/5 of a man or be forbidden from drinking water from the same water fountain. Please don't compare a word describing someone's explicit beliefs to the n-word.
- thrown_22 4y ago
- dang 4y agoWould you please stop posting flamewar comments? You've been doing it quite a bit lately, unfortunately, and if you keep doing it we're going to have to ban you. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- thrown_22 4y ago
- dang 4y ago> If you don't want flame war comments ban flame war topics better. This thread is the definition of Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, The article seems obviously intellectually interesting and therefore on topic for HN. Banning all articles with political aspects is not an option here. I've written about this many times: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=political%20overlap%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so.... If you read some of the past explanations and still have a question that isn't answered there, I'd like to know what it is. In the meantime, if you want to keep commenting here, we need you to stick to the site guidelines, regardless of how political or flameprone a topic is. Note these ones: "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." "Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- thrown_22 4y ago>In the meantime, if you want to keep commenting here, we need you to stick to the site guidelines, regardless of how political or flameprone a topic is. Note these ones: I can't post here anyway because powerusers keep flagging comments regardless of quality or length. If you want your site to have anyone more interesting than Emily from HR posting you need to figure out a way to keep PG's posts from getting flagged. The last time he made a politically hot post it kept getting flagged every few minutes for hours. If your founder can't have a politically divisive take stay up without you flipping a the "do not report" bit what chance do the rest of us have?
- notahacker 4y agoWhilst it's generally applied to self-identified feminists whose concept of feminism excludes transpeople as a matter of fact, and even the "radical" bit is more a nod to how second-wave feminists approached politics rather than mockery, if a term is pretty much exclusively applied to an outgroup by people who really don't like that outgroup (and the acronym itself is pretty much exclusively pejorative) there's a pretty good case for it being offensive. Especially in a debate over identity. Don't see any reason to use euphemistic terms they'd prefer like "pro-women" over the more accurate "trans-exclusionary" or "anti-trans" to refer to their politics, but when a position gets converted into a four letter noun to shout at people it's definitely intended to offend. There are variants of the neutral/positive descriptor "trans" which are unambiguously insults too.
- tsimionescu 4y ago> when a position gets converted into a four letter noun to shout at people it's definitely intended to offend Would you say that Bernie Sanders should feel offended when he is called a socialist by Ron Paul? Ron Paul definitely means it as an insult - to him socialism is abhorrent. But Bernie Sanders is, in fact, a socialist (well, a social democrat would probably be a better description, but it's close enough), and he has no reason to feel offended that he is being called something that Ron Paul finds offensive. > if a term is pretty much exclusively applied to an outgroup by people who really don't like that outgroup (and the acronym itself is pretty much exclusively pejorative) there's a pretty good case for it being offensive I can agree with this to some extent, but only if there is a better common word to describe that group, and one that is not self aggrandizing or overly obscure. How would you call TERFs, or what would you say describes, say, JK Rowling's position on trans rights in one word? I have heard "gender critical" thrown around, but that seems just a way to obscure their beliefs, it's a meaningless combination of words in itself. At face value, it could easily describe some postmodernists who believe the whole notion of gender is a fantasy that should be abolished. It could describe non-binary people.
- Chris2048 4y ago> But Bernie Sanders is, in fact, a socialist and calls himself one, making the situation non-comparable. The burden is on you to prove the analogy makes sense. > only if there is a better common word to describe that group what is the alternative to "SJW"? In this case "gander critical" is the alternative. > one that is not self aggrandizing or overly obscure says who? why do you get to decide the criteria for some out-groups' labels? > JK Rowling's position on trans rights in one word "gender critical", disregarding the arbitrary constraint on needing one word. > it's a meaningless combination of words in itself so is TERF, given "exclusion" is as vague as "critical.". > but that seems just a way to obscure their beliefs It doesn't matter, a term needn't be self describing. Also TERF isn't a clear description, much like "anti-trans" isn't either. The clarification, it seems, is b/c users of the term want is to reduce the topic to two sides (trans, anti-trans), and make it clear which side TERFs are on. This fight over control of the context, versus "feminists" vs trans-women framing, seems to be the point of these descriptors - each side want the power to "describe" their opponents.