4 ms·
I went to McDonald's the other day to buy a McBurger using their kiosk. I didn't count, but it seemed like it took 20 clicks to just by a burger, with screen a
by WalterBright 4y ago
I went to McDonald's the other day to buy a McBurger using their kiosk.
I didn't count, but it seemed like it took 20 clicks to just by a burger, with screen after screen after screen. I'm sure McDonald's play-tested this a lot, but I'm baffled as to how they managed to converge on this monstrosity.
It's also unclear which button to pick to pay. There's no "check out", "pay", "shopping cart", button.
- gruez 4y ago20 seems to be on the high side for me. I used the machines before, and based on what I remember it should be: 1. start 2. burgers section 3. scroll down to hamburger (if it already isn't there already) 4. choose the burger you want 5. no, I want just the burger 6. add to order 7. view order 8. pay 9. credit card maybe add a few more if there's more upsell screens near the end, but nowhere near 20.
- xgkickt 4y agoI suspect there's a minimum time to order so that people are waiting to order rather than waiting for their food, so the kitchen doesn't get overrun.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoThat doesn't make sense IMO. The only benefit it would have is smoothing out spikes, but I think you'd rather have people wait for food they've already paid for than turn around because the queue for even ordering is too long.
- blendergeek 4y agoIn a fast food establishment such as McDonald's customers are very sensitive to wait times. This may lead you to the conclusion that we then want to quickly rush all customers through ordering and then take as long as necessary to make the food. Unfortunately, customers hate waiting after ordering more than they hate waiting before ordering. If a customer walks in and sees either no line or a very short line to order, the customer will think, "oh it will be no more then five minutes, I'll be in and out". If there is actually a 45 minute wait after ordering, then yes you just scored on sale. However, the customer will now feel tricked, having been let down on the promise of quick; the customer is now late back from lunch and has a bad feeling as they leave. This does not convert to more future sales. Smoothing out the spikes is exactly what you want to be doing. The drive-thru has this built in. Customers come through in a queue and can easily see how long they will have to wait by counting cars. It makes a lot of sense to implement something similar with the self-serve kiosks. I work at a fast food establishment with self-serve kiosks. When we are understaffed (as we often are nowadays) and we are busy, we will turn off some of the kiosks rather than let orders build up. We would much rather lose a few customers today than lose these customers forever as they have to wait 45 minutes for their food because we rushed them through ordering without proper queue management.
- SoftTalker 4y agoWaiting 45 minutes for food at a "fast food" restaurant? You're doing something very, very wrong.
- matsemann 4y agoWhat grinds my gears is the slow transitions between each step. Like, it takes a couple of seconds to do anything. But you also forgot all the upsells. Choose burger -> wait for screen -> choose unmodified -> wait for screen -> choose just burger, no menu -> wait for screen -> no, I don't also want to add a doughnut -> wait for screen to go back to main screen -> start checkout -> no, I don't want to add X to my order -> wait -> confirm order -> select pay now -> try to beep my card but it doesn't work -> look at screen and see I have to select "card" (but it's the only option wtf make me choose?)
- aldrich 4y agoAgree with this, I happened to get to experience this today again as well. The transitions really seem to take their time. Combined with the number of "pages" you need to get through as well, makes it an experience that feels a bit slow. I get the sense that these visual page transitions are becoming quite a thing, also with modern self checkout counters in supermarkets. But who knows, perhaps they are trying to hide some kind of background loading action.
- SoftTalker 4y agoThe top 10 sellers should be available with one click/tap. Would they need to license that from Amazon? Then do it. THey can afford it. Big Mac, fries, and Coke should take me no longer to order on the screen than to say it verbally.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y ago> I'm sure McDonald's play-tested this a lot, I'm not. At the point someone stands in front of the device, they've already made a decision and they're unlikely to bail just due to bad UX, and I can totally see someone who isn't aware of UX as a concept simply not optimizing. They want a digital ordering system, this is a digital ordering system, it seems to do the job (fewer cashiers)... the fact that people actively avoid going back to McD because they don't want to deal with that abomination doesn't show up on that person's stats. In case anyone from McD reads this: Since those machines popped up I avoid going specifically because I hate dealing with them. Before the machines, I walked in, stood in a relatively short queue, "one cheeseburger please", receive a burger, pay (often cash) and go. Now, I first spend a ridiculous amount of time dealing with the crappy machine, then wait forever for my food.
- jokethrowaway 4y agoSame. Went to some fast food, tried to order with a crappy machine and left for something else. I like the idea of using a machine over talking with someone and my ideal experience would be a restaurant full of robots; but the machine should be well designed
- SoftTalker 4y agoI refuse to use them. If there is not a human working to take orders, I leave.
- toyg 4y agoTbh it's the opposite for me. No more dealing with barely-understandable ghetto-slang from bored teenagers, no more saying "no" to umpteen attempts to "go large" or "do you want fries with that", no more queueing behind someone who wants a burger without a burger - tap tap tap and it's done. Let's be honest - some retail jobs need the human element, but ordering a burger is not one of them. The one complaint I have about the machines is that they run out of paper waaay too often, and they don't tell you in advance, so you often end up in a situation where you've paid but you technically have no way to prove it. The best approach at this point is to order through the app.
- makeitdouble 4y ago> I'm sure McDonald's play-tested this a lot They must have made some serious effort, but it is also a pretty complex problem (they’re trying to address literally everyone in reading age) and McDonald is not known for pouring money into solid customer interfaces. I haven’t tried in a while but their mobile app was even more of a sluggish, hostile at every corner, trash experience. I kinda feel like they went in from a “we replace the cashier” mindset, and not a return to first principles of why the customer came to that place, and how to satisfy that goal. PS: also people just adapt. I had coworkers just remember step by step the screen sequence to their usual orders, and they basically blindly tapped the screen only registering the page changes. If McDonald was to change the menu tree now I’d imagine them getting pissed in reaction.
- rajman187 4y agoThe more important question here is why anyone eats at McDonald’s
- nicbou 4y agoIt's everywhere, it's predictable, it opens late. Great for long drives.