6 ms·
"And nothing of value was lost." This was one of the top voted posts in the Austin subreddit recently: https://old.reddit.com/r/Austin/comments/vmtmul/finally_s
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
"And nothing of value was lost." This was one of the top voted posts in the Austin subreddit recently: https://old.reddit.com/r/Austin/comments/vmtmul/finally_some_good_news/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Austin/comments/vmtmul/finally_some...
Seriously, during other crashes, I remember thinking of the real negative externalities that happened during the crash, e.g. many economists have drawn lines to the current housing supply crunch due to underinvestment after the Great Recession.
I don't feel any of that now. I primarily feel that a bunch of grifter scams are finally getting washed away, and then what you're left with are products that are searching for use cases where they aren't worse in every way than currently available products.
- silasdavis 4y agoThat's good then. Good to not be causing a housing crunch.
- abirch 4y agoOMG nothing of value was lost. Now I can even invite my crypto nephew to Thanksgiving this year.
- Retric 4y agoWhat’s interesting about this crash is prices are still so high. Bitcoin is close to 20,000$ right now. So there are still huge paper losses, but I doubt that many bought in at just 20+k. It’s odd to look prices dropping to 1/3 and think thing things could get a lot worse or it could turn into just another blip on a larger upwards trajectory.
- Victerius 4y agoOne bitcoin could be worth $20 or $200 000 in one year. Which is just one of the reasons why it's a bad store of value or medium of exchange.
- jquery 4y agoTo be fair, that property made it great for people selling get-rich-quick scams and the people falling for them. A few people did get rich, pay no attention to the vast majority who lost money.
- pavlov 4y agoA ton of people bought Bitcoin at >$20k. It reached that milestone even before Elon Musk started promoting it about 18 months ago, and that's when the hype really started. I suspect that most retail Bitcoin holders bought it last year and are down 30-70%. The people who post on HN are very much outliers, having known about Bitcoin for a decade. The real retail volume in 2021 came from relatively uninformed people buying their first crypto. Also, there are the publicly listed corporate whales. Tesla has 42,000 Bitcoins bought at an average price of $31,620. MicroStrategy has over 130,000 Bitcoins bought at an average price around $30k as well. Public company accounting standards require these companies to mark down their crypto holdings regularly, so it seems that Tesla will be booking a roughly $420M loss for the past quarter, and MSTR has lost a whopping $1.3 billion. (I'm sure Musk appreciates that the loss is close to 420 though, even if Tesla shareholders don't.)
- mdm12 4y agoApparently, the average investor's position for BTC in Coinbase is around 21k, per some Mizuho survey: https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/survey-showed-average-bitcoin-buy-price-is-21k--mizuho-432SI-2828082 https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/survey-show.... So, many folks are underwater on their so-called 'investment'.
- Retric 4y agoAverage is generally a poor way of approximating monetary distributions. If 6 people buy in at 15k and 1 person buys in at 60k they average to 21.5k. That said, clearly a lot of people are underwater.
- mdm12 4y agoIt was the only data point I could find, but fair point. I amended my comment for pedantic's sake :)
- rsynnott 4y ago> So there are still huge paper losses, but I doubt that many bought in at just 20+k. I mean, ~everyone who believed the crypto ads that the article is about did, for a start. I would assume it's far from done unravelling yet, though. Another dubious crypto HYIP seems to go under every few days at the moment.
- jjfoooo4 4y agoIt’s a demonstration of the societal value of bad businesses going under. There are certain ideas that people just cannot be swayed against by evidence, especially if they have skin in the game. The real destructiveness of crypto is the other ideas that have been starved for oxygen during this bubble. I am glad it looks like we are beginning to move on.
- cortesoft 4y ago> It’s a demonstration of the societal value of bad businesses going under. I always think about this when I see people rail against short sellers, as if the whole idea of betting against a company is morally wrong. Short sellers are one of the only checks against overly inflated equity prices. If the only people allowed to participate in a market are the believers, you are going to get a very distorted view of the actual value of assets. For the market to do its thing, you need failure.
- jrkrk8jdjf 4y agoNow consider all the ideas starved for attention coddling old wealth, salary feudalism, military industrial complex, and consumption of resources ostensibly to send future humans who don’t exist yet into space, at the expense of people living now. Basically anyone who comes along is joining an in progress game of Monopoly. The real destructiveness of business as usual. “When a man’s salary…” is how the saying starts.
- huijzer 4y ago> Seriously, during other crashes, I remember thinking of the real negative externalities that happened during the crash, e.g. many economists have drawn lines to the current housing supply crunch due to underinvestment after the Great Recession. Don’t underestimate what can come still. Based on the high price to equity ratios in the stock market, it is likely that the "correction" will correct more. This is also in line with the recent rounds of layoffs. Crypto going down first makes sense due to the amount of speculation. I‘m really curious whether we‘ll get a Lehman Brothers moment in 2022.
- ddjsn111 4y agoIf you do not recognise that there is value in decentralised, self-sovereign, permissionless, censorship resistant, anonymous, Internet native money then you are retarded.
- dang 4y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the site guidelines. You can't do that on HN, regardless of how wrong others are or you feel they are. Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ditonal 4y agoHacker News has gotten overwhelmingly anti-crypto to an extent it’s as bad an echo chamber as many pro-crypto echo chambers. People have such a hatred for crypto they are overjoyed to celebrate a crypto crash. They were annoyed people they disliked were getting rich and now feel “vindicated” the bubble is popping. But…have people actually looked around? Airbnb stock is down 80% in the last 6 months. Netflix, Twilio, DoorDash, and many many other companies have taken a similar beating. Bitcoin has actually done much better then most of the tech stocks, especially if you look at a 2 year chart. Amazing to see all this gravedancing when the crypto crash isn’t a crypto crash at all but a speculative asset crash and most of our jobs fall into that category. Another funny dynamic is many pro-crypto subreddits hate NFTs but similarly we’re seeing gravedancing over monkey JPEGs even though the bored apes have held up better then many “serious” crypto projects. My point is that people want confirmation bias for their narrative. And they are overjoyed to celebrate crypto crashing to extent it confirms their narrative it’s a big Ponzi scam that was due for a crash. But they seem less eager to be intellectually honest and work in the rest of what’s going on into that narrative. If bitcoin falling 60% proves it was a scam what does Airbnb falling 80% say about Airbnb. And I know your answer will be they have a business model with cash flow. But these are all “a priori” assumptions. The crash is viewed in a different lens based not on evidence but on what we believe to be true beforehand. Tech bros celebrating the death of crypto bros are knee deep in the icey waters of the Titanic sinking celebrating the guy whose shoulder deep as they both continue to sink, but due to preconceived notions refuse to realize they’re all about to drown from the same iceberg crash.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoThe difference, as always, is leverage. I don’t think there is as much leverage built on top of Airbnb stock as there is on Bitcoin. Airbnb crashing 80% didn’t take any funds out of business.
- Deletionk 4y agoIt's different and connected: Different because shares still give you a part of a real business and equal because it showed that money was too cheap. I'm not anti crypto just because, I have plenty of good reasons. And no real cryptobro was able to convince me with good argument s otherwise. Of course the share prices General looked weird that's why I didn't invest last time I wanted to.