15 ms·
The nationalization of news and politics in a country of 330 million people is toxic. We’re one country but we don’t share a single set of values. Even the noti
by rayiner 4y ago
The nationalization of news and politics in a country of 330 million people is toxic. We’re one country but we don’t share a single set of values. Even the notion of “blue America” and “red America” is misleading. What would be unremarkable in San Francisco would raise eyebrows in Baltimore.
I noticed this acutely living in Atlanta for the better part of a decade. Politics was not a big deal when I lived there. Atlanta was “blue” and the rest of the state was “red” but politics was forward looking and productive. The mayor when I was there, Shirley Franklin, was truly put the city above partisanship. A Democrat, she endorsed Mary Norwood, an independent, in 2017, because the Democratic candidate was a protege of a mayor she believed to have been corrupt: https://www.wabe.org/former-atlanta-mayor-shirley-franklin-endorses-mary-norwood https://www.wabe.org/former-atlanta-mayor-shirley-franklin-e.... She waved aside criticism suggesting that she (a Black woman) should have endorsed the Black Democratic candidate instead of Norwood, a white woman.
Then in 2018 all hell broke loose when Georgia’s governor’s race became the subject of national attention. The state became a battleground in a proxy war between New York and Mississippi. Racialist rhetoric reached a fever pitch in the New York Times and Washington Post (but notably, the Atlanta Journal Constitution was far more prudent). They made Georgia out to be an unreformed Confederate backwater, instead of a state that’s the destination for huge numbers of Black residents leaving California, Illinois, and New York, attracted by plentiful jobs, low taxes, and an excellent public university system. The national media completely misrepresented Georgia and the people in it to the rest of the country.
- yojo 4y agoAs a citizen of Portland, OR, I can verify that national news outlets heavily distort reality to draw eyeballs. I’m not sure local news is a whole lot better, but at least you can count on readers to call bullshit.
- michaelchisari 4y agoI'm tired of people saying Chicago is like John Wick and Mad Max had a violence baby. Can't count how many times the people saying this live in rural areas that have, per capita, higher violent crime rates than Chicago. The city has its problems, as all American cities do, but it is a wonderful place with amazing people and a ton to offer. Except for the winters. Those are awful.
- KerrAvon 4y agoI’ve visited Chicago a few times (not in winter, though), and I loved it. Maybe my favorite American big city. Great people, fascinating architecture, middle finger to TFG tower along the river. Also, I never got crimed.
- phil21 4y agoBest summer city in the world, in my not so humble opinion on the matter. Fall is pretty fun too. Winter is a definite meh.
- bcrosby95 4y agoA while back I had some of my relatives ask me if we were doing OK with all the rapes happening in California. I had no clue what the hell they were talking about.
- alisonatwork 4y agoThis has happened to me numerous times based on prejudices people have about other countries or regions. But the funniest thing is that it even happens when you travel from one small town to the next small town, as has been parodied in comedies from The Simpsons to Corner Gas. I think it's a fairly basic fear to see places you don't visit often as threatening. For some reason it doesn't seem to be quelled by the easily verifiable fact that plenty of people live perfectly adequate lives in the other place.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- drewcoo 4y ago"Oh, that? We just turn the radio up and it doesn't bother us."
- swader999 4y agoUnfortunately this didn't age well.
- sbf501 4y agoYep. I've been in PDX for 22 years. Back during the BLM protests, my FOX-loving family back east would call me and see if I was OK whenever FOX ran some bullshit story about the city burning. Once you step outside Portland, it is terrifyingly red. Jefferson Secessionists are the scariest. I've been harassed in small towns outside PDX when I go camping and they see the PSU parking stickers on my car. Heck, I met a guy at a bar in Plush, Ore., who was telling me how he and his buddies made sure no black people ever set foot in his town. And this was in 2018. Also, KATU news is owned by Sinclair Media. Even OregonLive is dubious. Willamette Week, The Mercury, and OPB are reasonable, IMHO.
- tootie 4y agoMaybe the biggest BLM protest in the country rallied almost daily at the park in my neighborhood in Brooklyn. I'd take my kids to play there in the morning and you'd never know anything had happened the evening before.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoYep. My elderly parents have listened to Rush religiously for decades now. Fox news is on constantly. They repeatedly contacted me in a panic wanting to arrange for a change of locks n my house, security cameras, etc. They honest to god thought BLM protestors were randomly invading homes in Portland because of these trash news outlets. And then the bigger national media outlets do their "both sides means we pretend bullshit is worth taking seriously" nonsense and make the lunatic positions seem less fringe. It's maddening that my own family is convinced they understand what is happening in front of my porch and downtown at protests I literally attended, better than I do. And it's all because of these news outlets selling a cravenly dishonest narrative that BLM protestors demanding police reform are actually some sort of race war against white people.
- louky 4y agoLeaving the extremely uhhh paisley/tie-died Oregon Country Fair and returning to WA on the backroads was wild. Stopped to get gas a says away and got out of the car wearing tie-dye, etc... Was immediately approached by two locals who got into the whole thing - hippies killing people, breaking into people's houses, raping and drugging kids. (This was before Trump, there was still the satanic baby abuse thing. Not that one, the one before!) As a disguise because I live in rural WA which is Red and dangerous I had a complete set of typical "rigging/logging" clothes which I do wear working in the woods. I was talking to them, changing my clothes to logger jeans, ripped stained hickory shirt suspenders, the lot. They were very confused
- vishnugupta 4y ago> The nationalization of news and politics in a country of 330 million people is toxic. This. I read it somewhere a while ago that prior to information revolution of late 90s onwards news travelled very slowly. Which meant people consumed more news of happenings around 50KM-100KM radius of their living place. And this reduced exponentially with increased radius. I could totally related to this as when I was in school (late 80s, early 90s) I read physical news paper that carried mostly my district and state news. Once a week I would be exposed to national news and maybe once a month to international news. But now it's exactly reverse. I get minute by minute update on ongoings of Ukraine war which is half way across the world but have no clue about local politics. The net result being I get more enraged/impacted about happenings on which I have close to zero control but totally oblivious to things that I have control over such as reasons why there are so many broken roads in my vicinity.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Xeoncross 4y agoAgree. With 330 million people I'm pretty sure you can find at least a few bad ones every. single. day. I'm glad we give them air time.
- Tempest1981 4y agoExactly. Let's find a few adults behaving badly, and amplify it. Do we really need to hear about every shooting or robbery, day after day? Can't be good for our mental health. But apparently there is a market for it.
- mandmandam 4y agoI guarantee that corporate news is one of the top factors for Americans mental health crisis. Unfortunately, there's not many people willing to pay to advertise that fact. > apparently there is a market for it There are/were markets for many dangerous and exploitative things that are illegal and/or regulated. Allowing syndicated news-anchors to fuck with Americans en masse is more dangerous and more harmful than is properly acknowledged (at least, I haven't heard that view on the news since they last let Chomsky on).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoIt's not only the media but also the political campaign industry. Some inner city council person somewhere says they hate Jewish people and suddenly their opponent for city council has nationwide fundraising support. Same for some small town mayor saying they don't want "those people" in his town. Now there's money flooding in nationwide for his opponent in the election. In a country of 330 million, there's always a politician somewhere saying something reprehensible. Political parties and their fundraising wings love finding these incidents and then making money off of them.
- 88913527 4y agoIt seems doubtful people are leaving California due to jobs, taxes, and public universities, but I would certainly believe it was due to cost of living. CA is the world's 5th largest economy, the universities are world-class, and most people are unwilling to give up their family, friends and life to establish something new simply to save a few percent on taxes.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI would put taxes in the cost of living column.
- halostatue 4y agoOffset by quality of life represented by the spending of the tax dollars.
- inglor_cz 4y agoDoes quality of life, at least among the 50 U.S. states, really track the state taxation level?
- pessimizer 4y agoTaxes are only paid to the extent that you're making money. Cost of living hits you equally no matter how much you make. If you're making money, when it rises, you consider whether you'd rather be living in a different place for that price. If you're not making money, you leave (or the bailiffs drag you out.)
- unclebucknasty 4y agoYour analysis somewhat conspicuously omits the massive nationwide shift that was the ascendance of Trump and the far right over the time period you've noted. Is it reasonable to expect local news and politics to be insulated from such dramatic national shifts? I've lived in Atlanta for over two decades. What's happened in Atlanta politics tracks with what's happened nationwide. It is not strictly a function of media or a random, spontaneous racialization. Nor do I know anyone who feels we've been characterized as an "unreformed Confederate backwater". The idea that we've been so maligned is itself a media narrative. In fact, I live in an area that is staunchly conservative, majority white, and upper-middle class. The people I speak with abhor Trump and the style of politics he represents (which have been noted as favorable to your "unreformed Confederates"). This was visible in their repudiation of him in 2020, even while they voted GOP down balllot. It was visible again in the recent primary wherein the candidates Trump endorsed were largely shellacked. So, it's somehat ironic that you're bemoaning the media's role in mischaracterizing Georgia politics, when you seem to be a victim of the same, and repeating certain narratives. Likewise with your comment that black people are leaving blue states in droves to come to Atlanta, as if this is some recent phenomenon. That is simply a new right-wing media narrative that seeks to malign blue states and peel off support. But, black people have long sought Atlanta as a mecca, which has featured black political power for decades now and was even labeled an ascendant "Chocolate City" in a Parliament song of 1975. Perhaps there was some national media painting of Georgia. After all, narratives do sell. But your analysis here is somewhat superficial and features its own skewed media-driven narratives.
- pessimizer 4y ago> the massive nationwide shift that was the ascendance of Trump and the far right over the time period you've noted. This never happened. What happened is that Democrats started to center the far-right in order to scare their constituents into voting, and Republicans stopped resisting Trump, who they were only against because he was an outsider to their patronage networks. The far-right haven't risen, the Democrats just spend all their time doing PR for them and trying to associate them with Trump to attract centrist Republican voters.
- 4y ago
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> They made Georgia out to be an unreformed Confederate backwater: Electing Marjorie Greene Taylor and the coverup attempt around this killing might have contributed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Ahmaud_Arbery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Ahmaud_Arbery Although, I would not say rural areas of GA are special in being unreformed Confederate backwaters.
- WillPostForFood 4y agoGeorgia elected Marjorie Greene Taylor and Raphael Warnock. States aren't red or blue; it is a divisive over simplification. To paraphrase that parent comment, What would be unremarkable in San Francisco would raise eyebrows in much of the rest of California.
- smt88 4y agoGeorgia didn't elect Marjorie Taylor Greene. A tiny subset did. She received 230,000 votes in a rural district. Raphael Warnock won a statewide election with 2,280,000 votes.
- feet 4y ago
- kn0where 4y agoTo be more accurate, Georgia elected Warnock, and a particular congressional district within Georgia elected Magic The Gathering.
- Gibbon1 4y agoI've pointed this out before but after the 2016 election after the Democrats lost their dangerous gamble to put the wife of a previous president in the Whitehouse. I looked at the hyper local results. Yeah there aren't red and blue states. There are states where either rural or city votes dominate. Both the tiny cities in Montana and the huge metro's in Texas vote blue.
- 4y ago
- mbostleman 4y ago>>We’re one country but we don’t share a single set of values.>> This is a popular sentiment, but I don't think it's true - I think it's manufactured (I assume due to all mass communication being a large ad server that requires a quick and easy way to stimulate engagement - but that could be wrong too, I don't know). I believe, admittedly from anectodical experience, that we are remarkably together on values. Where we're apart is a) facts, and b) the tactical approach to getting our society as a whole to express those values (eg. trusting that if left alone the society will be "good" vs. trusting that codifying the "good" in law will genuinely reach the same end).
- nonrandomstring 4y ago>>We’re one country but we don’t share a single set of values. > This is a popular sentiment, but I don't think it's true My personal experience is of a diverse USA. In the late 90s I toured the states, a gig in a different city each night then back to the tour bus and off to the next one by daybreak. Okay, not a great sampling of ordinary life because on the road you mostly meet audiences, people in bars, diner waitresses etc. But while I recall how the USA looks superficially similar (giant cars on giant roads and the same brand logos in every city) it's not. I saw quite a range of poverty and wealth, segregation and integration, friendliness and aloofness, dense cities and wide open country. Much like travelling around Europe.
- mbostleman 4y agoMaybe we're working off of different overloads for the word "values". While there is no doubt a great diversity of experience per all the things you mentioned, to me "values" is a very small set of first principles that maps closely (or is identical) to ethics. I believe there is little to no diversity in that regard.
- pessimizer 4y agoThat's an easy thing to say if you reduce "values" to lowest common denominator ethical abstractions that are pretty much shared among all human beings. If you include e.g. "not wearing shoes in the house", "treating animals well", "Buddhist supremacy", or "proper lawn care" as values, however, things diverge quickly.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoAbolish the electoral college and people in NY will stop giving a shit about what happens in Georgia immediately.
- wrycoder 4y agoAnd that’s why the founders set up the electoral college. We are a federal republic of states. The federal government was supposed to be small, because the founders understood the downside of a large federal government.
- ReactiveJelly 4y agoBut I don't like being a federation. Having 50 states each infighting, competing to race to the bottom and attract business from each other, like 50 tiny nations, it's not what I want.
- cloutchaser 4y agoWell, that’s the direction it’s been going for 100 years, so you should be happy
- ABCLAW 4y agoWell your government has reached the point that it cannot govern at the federal level or reasonably receive strong mandates to deal with issues. Faith in democratic institutions is tanking. This is what it looks like before the system breaks entirely. The buffers can't buffer anymore.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- inglor_cz 4y ago"competing to race to the bottom" Looking at the US in the last 200 years, it has grown enormously rich, while many ossified systems in the world around it have collapsed. It seems that the competition you dislike does not turn individual Americans into paupers. An average American's living standard is so high that it is actually ecologically unsustainable.
- MrYellowP 4y ago> The national media completely misrepresented Georgia and the people in it to the rest of the country. The national media everywhere is full of shit. That's the norm. It's the norm, because it works.
- rmbyrro 4y agoI agree with your remarks. Adding one aspect for thought: > We’re one country but we don’t share a single set of values. Problem is: from the perspective of massification efforts, we're all equal. The same principles that make Facebook addictive to a person in San Francisco also govern the psychology and neuro-chemistry of a kid in Miami. That holds not just to US citizens. Anywhere in the world it's like that.
- avgcorrection 4y agoYou are all one people! No! That’s right—you are all either on Team Blue or Team Red! Yes! Amazing how widespread such dichotomies are.
- dopylitty 4y ago> They made Georgia out to be an unreformed Confederate backwater They wouldn't be wrong. For example in April 2021 a black woman from Md was drummed out of a wealthy town in GA for the crime of being black and an educator[0]. This is the kind of thing that happens all the time in the south and west. 0. https://www.propublica.org/article/georgia-dei-crt-schools-parents https://www.propublica.org/article/georgia-dei-crt-schools-p...
- Ferrotin 4y ago
- overboard2 4y ago>Cecelia Lewis was asked to apply for a Georgia school district’s first-ever administrator job devoted to diversity, equity and inclusion. They disagreed with her politics.
- halostatue 4y agoShe had no politics that they knew of. They disagreed with willful misrepresentations of politics that she had never expressed, and felt that they could get away with it because of race politics in Georgia. And they did.
- Ferrotin 4y ago
- barry-cotter 4y agoBeing willing to be part of a DEI office is politics, just like choosing to be a commissar rather than an artillery officer is politics. It’s deeply unfortunate that Ms Lewis was unaware of that but it’s going to become clear over the next decade or two of backlash that DEI is a loser, politically. People are going to either attack it or dissociate from it.
- pessimizer 4y agoAre you saying that being asked to apply for a job is a political act?
- aeturnum 4y agoOne thing that makes this worse is the collapse of local information economies. Papers can no longer make money by acting as pay-to-post message boards for the communities they serve. Instead, the best way to make money is to convince people from outside your region to use your organization for their news needs. So now every paper writes news for a national audience and what determines the financial health of the paper is how effectively it can attract readers that aren't from its area.
- selimthegrim 4y ago> an excellent public university system Why don’t you tell this to the several UGA math profs who quit recently (including an acquaintance of mine from high school) or the GA Tech faculty unhappy with state COVID policies
- xnx 4y ago> The nationalization of news and politics in a country of 330 million people is toxic. The "nightly news" used to be a much more common experience that people shared: "Twenty-seven million to 29 million viewers, on average, tuned in every night to hear Walter Cronkite on the CBS Evening News. Today, though, the viewership of evening news programs on CBS, NBC and ABC combined is smaller than CBS' when Cronkite sat in the anchor's chair." Today the most popular news channel is Republican propaganda. I don't use that term to be dramatic. I do not think there is a more accurate description.
- colordrops 4y agoThe top cable news channels are propaganda for the two major political parties.
- mike00632 4y agoThis isn't a "both sides" issue. FoxNews has markedly higher ratings and is overtly partisan. Republicans get their TV news more from FoxNews than Democrats with one particular news network.
- colordrops 4y agoExcept it is. MSNBC and CNN are obviously heavily tied in with the DNC. This is only not visible if you are heavily invested into the DNC narrative yourself. Just as FOX news viewers are not aware of the insane bias of that network. They just think it's the "truth", same as democrats believe the tripe spewed by MSNBC and CNN.
- yongjik 4y ago330M is large, but not so large that national news stops making sense. Japan is roughly comparable - it has 126M people, and it was composed of competing (and sometimes warring) feudal lords until the Meiji Restoration (1868), a few years after the US civil war. Yet go to Japan and suggest that it's toxic for people in Tokyo to care about what's happening in Fukuoka, and people will look at you as if you've grown another head. I mean, what is a nation if not a group of people subscribing to the same central authority and sharing a rough idea of a society? On the face of it, saying that "nationalization of news and politics in a country is toxic" is so absurd that I'd like to see an argument for supporting that, instead of using it as a starting point of an argument. If people in SF stop caring about what's happening in Atlanta (and vice versa), it won't bring peace. It will merely accelerate the disintegration of the USA as a single country.
- cheschire 4y agoyeah but the population density of japan is 10x that of america, and the distance between atlanta and los angeles is well over 3x that of tokyo to fukuoka. I doubt GP was intending to speak strictly about population count itself.
- int_19h 4y agoI would argue that USA has already disintegrated as a single country with respect to its foundation, which is the society itself - basically, there's no single "American society" anymore. The only thing that still keeps the country together is the formalities of governance, and even that will only last for as long as people are willing to tolerate them (which is less and less with every passing year). It might be possible to reboot it in more or less the same format as the original was way back when (i.e. by moving most political questions out of the federal level). But there needs to be some motivation to try to keep things together at least on some level. For the original colonies, it was clear that they would simply not survive on their own. But for many states today, they have numerous independent countries of similar size (in terms of territory, people, economy etc - you name it) as a showcase that it is possible.
- andrekandre 4y agoidk, but in japan i get the sense that there is alot less money in politics and media, whereas in the us money == politics, so you get full-tilt media insanity which push people further and further apart i really think the us needs serious campaign and media reform; there is just too much money sloshing around from all these donors and its creating all kinds of havoc
- dsugarman 4y agoI've spent a ton of time in SF and Baltimore, wondering what specifically you had in mind? I think it's less socially acceptable to be right leaning in SF? Sure you would be looked at weird if you used a koozie or wore croakies in SF, or if you went up to people at a coffee shop to ask them to pitch their startup in Baltimore, but the differences feel cultural not political.
- RickJWagner 4y agoThank you for an excellent example of a national narrative that does not match the true local flavor.
- nine_k 4y agoA few years ago my friends started call NYT "Pravda", saying that it's turned into the mouthpiece of the "party line". Grudgingly, I had eventually to agree.
- specialist 4y ago> Then in 2018 all hell broke loose when Georgia’s governor’s race became the subject of national attention. Because local elections have national consequences. Then in 2020, GA's special elections determined control of the US Senate, and therefore the fate of the Biden Admin. Shouldn't the nation pay attention to GA? At least as much as say Iowa and New Hampshire? > The national media completely misrepresented Georgia and the people in it to the rest of the country. Nonwhite voters are systematically disenfranchised in GA. Enough so that in a straight up fight, Stacey Abrams would be governor. Those "misrepresentations" of GA are packed with history. Slavery, Confederacy, Jim Crow, Southern Strategy, etc. Centuries of denying nonwhites their right to vote. Sure, white people feel resentful about being constantly reminded. For everyone else, it's present reality, not history. If you're curious, I recommend the books These Truths, 1619 Project, and The Sum of Us. > ...a state that’s the destination for huge numbers of Black residents... That's the plan. Immigration back inland, to flip those reds states blue. Were their any progressive do-gooder billionaires, they'd be paying people to move inland. To start farms, businesses, families.
- mike00632 4y agoYou sound like somebody who hasn't waited in line for many hours because you live in a Black neighborhood in Georgia.