3 ms·
As was mentioned earlier, MCAS exists to modify the stick forces in certain circumstances. Those circumstances never occur in anything near normal flight. And i
by tzs 4y ago
As was mentioned earlier, MCAS exists to modify the stick forces in certain circumstances. Those circumstances never occur in anything near normal flight. And if they do occur it is not like the stick force deviation from what regulations allows makes the plane not flyable. I've seen it described by pilots who have tested it as it makes it have a slightly softer feel for stall recovery. When the European Union Aviation Safety Agency was testing it for return to service they did full flights tests with and without MCAS and found that it was fine both ways [1].
So if something goes wrong with MCAS during a flight making it interfere with normal operation of the aircraft, then disabling it is quite reasonable. The odds that you will end up later in a situation where MCAS actually has to do something are extremely low, and the odds are even lower that the pilots won't be be able to handle it without the help from MCAS.
And that's assuming you are in a stage of flight where it would even be used. MCAS is only active when flaps are up and the autopilot is disengaged, so most of the time for most flights it is out of the picture.
MCAS seems to be one of those things that needs to have great care taken in its implementation because the danger from it mistakenly activating when it should not seems to be orders of magnitude higher than amount of safety benefit it provides when it correctly activates. They did not take that great care.
[1] https://theaircurrent.com/aircraft-development/mcas-may-not-have-been-needed-on-the-737-max-at-all/ https://theaircurrent.com/aircraft-development/mcas-may-not-...