6 ms·
I have some sympathy for the victims of those political and economic collapses, and for people in similarly unstable or unfree countries who may suffer hardship
by pjc50 4y ago
I have some sympathy for the victims of those political and economic collapses, and for people in similarly unstable or unfree countries who may suffer hardship through failures of their political system.
However, if you're sitting comfortably in a Western country that runs free and fair elections? This is your "only you can prevent forest fires" moment. It's part of your freedom that you have the responsibility to participate in keeping the fraudulent and incompetent out of your democracy. This includes not letting yourself get seduced by populists or youtubers with weird economic theories. And also not pretending that collapse is imminent simply because oil prices have gone up.
(It's also not clear that actual loss was a big problem of Indian demonetization, just the inconvenience of the exchange process)
- lupire 4y ago> sitting comfortably in a Western country that runs free and fair elections 4% of the world population, and most of this site's users, live in the USA, where free and fair elections, along with human rights, are being turned down this year.
- throwaway858 4y ago> 4% of the world population, and most of this site's users, live in the USA Does HN publish this statistic? My guess is that >50% of users/traffic to this site is outside of the USA
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> where free and fair elections, along with human rights, are being turned down this year This is precisely the sort of hyperbole OP is describing.
- newshorts 4y agoCan you describe in more detail what you view as hyperbolic? I’m assuming the reference was to Roe v. Wade, but would like to hear more.
- shapefrog 4y agoI will take a crack at this... > where free and fair elections, along with human rights, are being turned down this year Pure, uncut, refined hysterical hyperbolic nonsense
- bee_rider 4y agoThey asked for more details, not more meaningless adjectives.
- shapefrog 4y ago> I’m assuming the reference was to Roe v. Wade, but would like to hear more. Republicans ran in elections on "stack the supreme court with people who will enact our values". Republicans ran in elections on "our values are ban abortions". Republicans win election. Republicans winning an election, stacking the court with their people, having them do exactly what they promised to do and enacting their campaign promises is democracy in action, not the suspension of democracy. If you dont want it, everyone needs to vote for what they do want.
- mrcartmeneses 4y agoHate to break it to you but Trump lost the popular vote and there are several states and many counties that will always go republican despite them losing the popular vote. Is your electoral system fair if it is this gerrymandered? Furthermore, most states and districts are “safe” for one of the two main parties. Of the remaining places, a voter can choose between either of only two parties. If neither represent them, then they have no one to vote for. This situation is not “free” in the true sense of the word. You do not have a free vote, and in most places your vote is meaningless. Worse still is the fact that one of your political parties openly attempted to overthrow the result of the election in order to stay in power, and the other party has not brought the full force of the law to bare for fear of speaking civil unrest. It is not hyperbolic to warn Americans of the extreme danger their democracy is in, nor of its inherent weakness due to the rather antiquated voting system it uses. Stacking a court goes against the separation of power that the three estates were supposed to uphold. No party that openly tries to pack a court against the will of the people should get a single vote from anyone who cares about freedom. America is sailing very close to the wind and Americans should not be complacent about the risks they face
- pjc50 4y agoI don't think that's entirely hyperbole, given the stacking of the Supreme Court to achieve particular policy outcomes. It seems likely that Moore v. Harper will allow states to gerrymander Federal elections, severely reducing the extent to which they are "free and fair". https://www.npr.org/2022/06/30/1107648753/supreme-court-north-carolina-redistricting-independent-state-legislature-theory?t=1656944702219 https://www.npr.org/2022/06/30/1107648753/supreme-court-nort... However, this is not likely to affect the value of the dollar in the medium term.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> don't think that's entirely hyperbole "Are being" versus "at risk of." > this is not likely to affect the value of the dollar in the medium term True. And to the extent it would, crypto is a terrible hedge. (It's a risk asset.)
- addicted 4y agoIndian demonetization has irreparably harmed the economy for decades at the very least. It absolutely halted growth and immediately led to a much lower growth level from which India has not recovered, and possibly never will, at least under the current government. And with high inflation (even pre pandemic) and a huge young population, the destruction of growth was an absolute disaster for India which absolutely needs to cash in on its youth right now before they all grow old and need to be financially supported themselves.
- pjc50 4y agoHow did the demonetization halt growth? Can this be untangled from other world economy effects?
- pcthrowaway 4y agoI guess the parent is arguing that taking fraudulent, counterfeit, and unclaimed/unaccounted money out of the system left less capital for growth?
- thematrixturtle 4y agoThe demonetization was extraordinarily bad at doing that. Turns out when you demonetize currency, the rich and corrupt can find ways around it, while it's the poor who lose their meager savings.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoHow did the poor lose their savings? I'm not from India, I just happened to travel there while that was happening. My understanding was that everyone could wait in line to exchange their 500/1000 rupee notes for 100 or 2000 notes. The lines were long and the banks were frequently out of money to exchange from, but I thought they could also deposit it to their bank if they had one (letting the bank deal with the demonetized notes). I know there are also a lot of unbanked in India, but presumably the period for exchanging demonetized notes was long enough to allow them to exchange any cash savings they had.. was this not the case?
- zamalek 4y ago> you have the responsibility to participate in keeping the fraudulent and incompetent out of your democracy. As a person who lived through the Zimbabwe crash, this right here was the problem. People voted to throw out the tyrant and he "found the votes he needed." This economy is reeling from all the money that the previous administration printed (which was precisely what started the snowball in Zimbabwe). What is lost to the crypto crowd is that sometimes "what is good for me" is not always "what is good for us." Voting yourself more money is very good way to contribute to a collapse (as Charles Munger points out[1]). This seems lost to the generally active votebase, too. [1]: https://youtu.be/GNTczyGLdhc https://youtu.be/GNTczyGLdhc