3 ms·
There are a few things at play here. There's "culture shock" of being comfortable within the high school world where there's a lot of busy work but it's easy t
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
There are a few things at play here.
There's "culture shock" of being comfortable within the high school world where there's a lot of busy work but it's easy to get an A in any class as long as you put in the hours and can memorize a few things, even if you don't honestly understand the material. And then getting tossed in the deep end of hard-science in college where you have to put in enough hours to actually understand the material, not just do the busy work. And you have to be able to learn in class and learn on your own as well, because there's quite a lot of material to go through. For some people this is like going from George Jetson's job to digging ditches, and it's too much to adjust to.
Relatedly, high schools have been doing a piss-poor job of actually instilling mastery of basic skills like math, reading, and writing so a lot of students will come into college at a disadvantage. When you have, realistically, about one or two years (if not more) of remedial education that you need to get through before you're able to grapple with the actual college level material then college because a lot more of a slog (and potentially a very much more expensive slog) than it might be otherwise. If you don't have calculus, trig, and technical critical reading and writing skills nailed by the time you start tackling chemistry, physics, biology, math, etc. in college you will be at a severe disadvantage.
And finally, as others have pointed out there's the grade inflation differential. When your class work tends to be things like homework problems, lab assignments, and in-class quizzes where answers are either right or wrong then your scores tend to be directly numeric. Grade inflation is a lot easier in "softer" classes where most of the scores are subjective. Though that can, of course, vary depending on the school, but the average certainly seems to be that way.
- msutherl 15y agoMy experience was that of going from having to spend a bit of time memorizing useless material to having to spend a great deal of time memorizing useless material. For me the only "culture shock" was the realization that I no longer had time to learn anything on top of the busy work. So I switched to a fine art degree and now I know more about engineering than 90% of engineers that I meet. Go figure.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoFollowup: additionally I think there's the general problem that most undergraduate degree programs just aren't that good. It's a lot easier to concentrate on rote memorization and "covering" a lot of material than actually instilling a substantive knowledge of a complex technical subject. The difference is that college can easily afford to suck at providing a quality education or experience. In K-12 if the students aren't graduating the school stops receiving funding. At the college level the difference in revenue between a student who graduates and one who drops out after 2 years is less than 50% (because 100 and 200 level classes are typically cheaper to teach). And if the student merely switches majors, the school still makes money. There's a catch-22 of sorts. If you got a bad education in HS and you get into a good technical college program you'll be in way over your head. If you get into a bad college program you'll be facing a lot of boring work with little meaning. The best case scenario is to win the lottery and have gone to a good HS and get into a good college. But even then you'll still have a crap ton of hard work in front of you.