2 ms·
There's a number of ways I can prove you wrong here, and I find it pretty endearing that you "know where I'm coming from" but think that things like Matrix and
by smoldesu 4y ago
There's a number of ways I can prove you wrong here, and I find it pretty endearing that you "know where I'm coming from" but think that things like Matrix and the Fediverse are foreign to me. Zero-knowledge proofs, look at you! It's like Little Einsteins in here.
Here's the gist: I despise centralized services. Apple, Google and Microsoft are some of the most evil companies I can imagine, and their atrocities that they committed against the web will never see trial because nobody cares enough to hold them accountable.
There, happy? I hate the establishment as much as you do.
I would still prefer for any one of those companies to control the web over Solana or Terra.
I love IPFS, Matrix and Mastodon. All wonderful technologies, and much as you said, "truly decentralized". They're excellent examples of federation, and great pieces of software if you consider yourself an internet power-user. However, the average person will never use a single one of those technologies. There's simply no reason for them to use it. Google Drive is easier than Dropbox. Discord is simpler than Matrix. Twitter is faster than setting up Mastodon. Again, all of this incredible technology that you're speaking of has existed for years, and nobody has used it for anything significant. There is no "internet" moment, not even a BBS moment where we can see faint glimmers of light from the future. We got digital apes and a plethora of rug-pull scams, plus hundreds of millions in stolen coins that has yet to be recovered.
You have to be pragmatic about change, otherwise you turn into a Richard Stallman: maybe ideologically correct, but so far-removed from normal human society that you can't be taken seriously. There are several noble people out there working in the field of decentralization, least of which being the people who bicker with people endlessly on forums while also promoting esoteric flavor-of-the-week Blockchains. HN knows good decentralization when they see it, which is why projects like Mastodon and Tor get upvoted, and things like OpenSea and $APE_TOKEN get flagged. There's nothing novel about this technology anymore, "average joe" has spoken and said he's not switching to Mastodon because Kanye doesn't have an account there. It's cool, but has no support even among the people who hate Twitter.
It's fun to nerd-out about cool protocols, but Web3+ is DOA. I don't even know how you're arguing some of this stuff with a straight face when not a single major browser vendor even supports this junk.
PS: Don't try to claim Mastodon, IPFS and Matrix as Web3. Just because they use secure cryptography doesn't make them comparable to the half-baked dreck that is coming out of the Web3 space right now. They're decidedly Web2-based protocols, every single one of them was built on the backbone of traditional networking models.
- EGreg 4y agoOpenSea was a YCombinator-incubated and promoted company. Ironic that you say HN downvotes it. It is quintessentially that VC-backed Web2 play that may as well cut out the web3 entirely since all wallets just use their APIs. They may as well BE the platform for NFTs. And according to you, that would be an improvement over the current space! That’s a great example actually, it’s very telling that you’re calling out a company that is literally the epitome of VC backed startups trying to turn Web3 into Web2 again, and call it “the bad decentralization”. Sure — the vast majority in the NFT space are looking for a viable alternative to OpenSea exactly BECAUSE it’s that. Whereas IPFS and BitTorrent were explicitly started as decentralized alternatives with no central point of failure (the latter as a response to the shutdown of Napster). And then they went ahead and created FileCoin and BTT to pay for things in this decentralized ecosystem. So puh-leeze, you Web2 maxis haven’t been able to even produce good open source alternatives to the Big Tech that totally captured everything in your space. And Web3 guys have captured a lot more momentum and people. And you don’t get to say that FileCoin and BTT aren’t Web3, and that Web3 is whatever you don’t like. Sure, Web3 was also captured by greed (of the early speculators who finally got to play VC) which is why we need Web4 and Web5. Things evolve. Web2 and Bitcoin maxis want things to stay the same as they were 12 years ago. But the world is moving on. Just wait the next few years as most Web2 things you know (badges, communities) go decentralized (NFTs and DAOs). Metaverse, Apple Glass and then neuralink etc. thankfully we won’t have corporate-controlled metaverses be the only solution, that would be even more dystopian than today’s Big Tech. You’d literally be the Borg. But hey, I guess you LIKE to be locked into AWS for their totally centralized and overpriced data centers (which they call “the cloud” to evoke feelings of decentralized Internet) and believe that’s the only way you can be compliant with regulations of your centralized governments. Where actually, end-to-end encryption and resilience can increasingly be found in decentralized systems, and credit cards with their PCI compliance are replaced with self-custodied private keys and cryptocurrency.