3 ms·
Down, boy. :) I didn't say that. I said it's an easy way to resolve the cognitive dissonance for those who want to. Just to be clear (and because I think it's
by gruseom 18y ago
Down, boy. :) I didn't say that. I said it's an easy way to resolve the cognitive dissonance for those who want to.
Just to be clear (and because I think it's interesting and would like to hear others on this), let me spell this one out. Say you're an atheist who agrees with that recent comment by Bill Maher that Christians "drink the blood of a 2000-year-old space god" (something like that) - in other words, are loony. But like most college-educated Americans you support Obama. Obama is a practising Christian. Who wants to believe that they're supporting a loon for president? It's a classic cognitive dissonance. So you look for a way to resolve the contradiction. One can think of a few:
1. Some Christians are loony but others aren't. This is what you originally suggested. But there are a lot of atheists who won't accept it.
2. He's loony but he's the lesser of two loony evils.
3. He's not a loon. He has to pretend to be Christian for political reasons. Sure it's not optimal, but such is US society, at least for now.
See what I mean? Does anybody have one to add to this list?
- Chocobean 18y agoi don't want to come across as a jesusphreak, so pm me I guess if you would like a decent conversation? =) could i suggest that a cognitive dissonance is only necessary if the axiom that "all Christians are loony" is true? You should be having a heck of a time trying to define the two terms, then trying to argue that it is true, before you make the leap into the area of what it thus means to vote for a Christian/loony. It'd be like trying to prove a new theory starting with "1 == 1.1".
- gruseom 18y agoWell, sure, if "all (believing) Christians are loony" isn't your premise, then there's no cognitive dissonance. These are the atheists tptacek was talking about, and I'm sure they exist. But there are also atheists who very much do hold that premise. For them, the easiest resolution is probably just to think that Obama isn't really a believer. Is this so controversial or hard to follow? I'm surprised the point isn't obvious. (And I hope it's clear that I'm not arguing about the truth of these positions.)
- Chocobean 18y ago=D understood
- tptacek 18y agoHeh. I'm "culturally" Catholic, but I don't have a deep spiritual stake in it. You're not offending me. I'm just asking you to accept that to your scale of: 1. Some loony, some not 2. The lesser of two loons 3. Liar Spiritual and religious people might retort with a scale of their own about atheists. What galls me is the notion that "militant" atheists have that they're communicating anything by assailing religion. Honestly, how many people has Bill Maher talked out of Christianity? I doubt many.
- gruseom 18y agoI'm confused by your punctuation, but it looks like: I'm just asking you to accept that [...s]piritual and religious people might retort with a scale of their own about atheists Sure. As for the subgroup you're talking about, I sometimes refer to them as "evangelical atheists". The word seems a fairly precise fit. They propagate a different evangel, of course.