6 ms·
How Well Are European Sanctions Against Russia Working?
- _zzaw 4y agohttps://archive.ph/Dcd2o https://archive.ph/Dcd2o
- ratsmack 4y agoIt seems that sanctions are hurting people everywhere, except in Russia (aside from a few exceptions).
- NicoJuicy 4y agoBecause western companies still paid wages. Lack of semiconductors takes a while to set in. I suspect that their tech will greatly decrease within 6 months. A lot of tech workers already fled Russia. Other than that, a lot of things were targeting the oliarchs. That changed by now.
- Arnt 4y agoThere's much more than that. One of the parts of the sanctions that isn't mentioned much affects oil/gas tankers, and tries to prevent Russia from diverting its exports from Europe to anywhere else. In order to sell oil/gas to, say, Brazil instead of Europe, Russia now has to charter tankers that ① aren't banned from working for Russia and also ② whose insurance provider isn't (because tankers are usually required to carry insurance), ③ whose bank isn't (because tankers are usually financed via a loan), ④ whose supplies and maintenance provide is't, and…that's not the end of the list. AIUI Russia isn't diverting its exports, it's cutting production (which is very, very harmful to Russia in the longer term), so that leaves two possibilities: Either that sanction is working, or tanker owners are boycotting Russia on their own volition. (More generally, I'm disappointed by how many people write "sanctions are/arent't working because x", without arguing or even stating that some part of the sanctions was intended to achieve x. This article is only partly guilty, it's better than most IMO.)
- neilwilson 4y agoRussia has no need to export to anybody who isn’t providing it with actual stuff or services. Russia has its own free floating currency and can fund all activity within Russia using that. For the most part it just swaps excess resources for Chinese output. The Chinese can send their own boats to pick up the exports if necessary. Probably the same with India. What the ineffectiveness of the sanctions is showing is that “export led growth” is a essentially a myth.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt’s a myth unless you need certain technology life improvements. Of course, countries that stay low tech do not need to interact with the outside world. See: North Korea.
- wizofaus 4y agoPretty sure North Korea's a long way from being self sufficient. It's offical government policy to be self sufficient in food production but just last year were suffering famine conditions in parts of the country.
- neilwilson 4y agoI’d rather see The United Kingdom and the industrial revolution. Did that stay low tech despite there being nobody else to exchange technology with at the time? Or did it just invent them itself?
- Arnt 4y agoNeither China nor India has the necessary fleet. Roughly 30% of the world's fleet would be necessary, and neither of those countries have that much (if you exclude ships financed/insured/serviced abroad). As to whether Russia needs to export — developing these oil/gas fields took a lot of effort. Clearly the Russians believed that there was benefit to doing it.
- sharikous 4y ago> Lack of semiconductors takes a while to set in. I suspect that their tech will greatly decrease within 6 months. I suspect so but in the longer term it may even be beneficial. If some technological business will still exist there they will need to establish their own silicon industry. And they have a pretty skilled labor force that could do that (if they don't flee en masse)
- Nasrudith 4y agoEstablishing themselves behind the curve massively after previously having semiconductor manufacturing and letting it rot away? They could have done that without sanctions in both senses if they weren't spending military budget mostly on personal loyalty.
- sorokod 4y agoIf you read/watch Russian channels you will find that the sanctions have a significant effect.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoHow it seems depends entirely on what news bubble you are in. That is, of course, unless you are living there.
- achikin 4y agoA lot of companies has shut their business in Russia, chains of supply are broken, commodities prices went up. The sanctions are hurting people in Russia but not the Russian government which runs the war.
- planarhobbit 4y agoWhat id like to know is what happened to Russia retreating from Ukraine, as many sources originally said they would. They seem to have taken a good chunk of Ukraine just this past week, and there’s no news of this unless I dig into shady sources. What the fuck is going on with our news?
- admax88qqq 4y agoMainstream news is known to be shit, not sure why you're surprised, or acting surprised. There's non shady sources like understandingwar.org which have given pretty good tracking of the war.
- rnd0 4y agoI don't trust the whole "mainstream news" narrative. It implies that there are news sources that somehow aren't driven by some $#^holes' ideological or corporate motives. "understandingwar", for instance. Who are they, who funds them and why on earth should I trust them? I'm critical of cnn etc but personally I think they're more credible than some NGO-sponsored blog IMO
- yucky 4y ago>"understandingwar", for instance. Who are they, who funds them and why on earth should I trust them? Funny you should ask! Bill Kristol is on their Board[1], and for those who don't know who Bill Kristol is, he is one of the foremost Neocons in the US, behind such hits as WMD's in Iraq and 20-years of Adventure in Afghanistan. Most of the rest of the Board appears to be like-minded neocons who beat the drums of war (and more importantly, intervention) every chance they get. [1] https://www.understandingwar.org/who-we-are https://www.understandingwar.org/who-we-are
- rufus_foreman 4y agoNon shady sources, huh? Let's take a look. That web site is run by "The Institute for the Study of War", ISW. Here's what Wikipedia says: "ISW generally advocates to increase American military involvement in international conflicts. Their political stances tend to align with the business interests of the ISW's funders, whose activities include producing tanks and weapon systems." There's a list of their board members at https://www.understandingwar.org/who-we-are https://www.understandingwar.org/who-we-are. There are two former generals listed, General David H. Petraeus who was the commander of US forces in Iraq for a while, and General Jack Keane. Keane was an advisor on the US occupation of Iraq on the Defense Policy Board Advisory Committee. Along with Frederick Kagan, Keane wrote a paper called "Choosing Victory: A Plan for Success in Iraq". Kagan's wife Kimberly Kagan is the president of the ISW. You've also got William Kristol listed as a member of the board, Kristol is a neoconservative who argued for the "surge" in Iraq, he is a co-founder of the "Project for the New American Century" which is a neo-conservative think tank. PNAC argued for regime change in Iraq starting in the 1990's. The other co-founder of PNAC was Robert Kagan, Frederick Kagan's brother. Another board member listed is Joe Lieberman, who was a major support of the Iraq war when he was in the Senate. There's another half dozen or so people on the board that I don't recognize, but I don't have to dig much further to know that if somebody wants to get their news from the neoconservatives who brought us the Iraq war, understandingwar.org is definitely a go-to source. Then again, I don't trust CNN either.
- seydor 4y agoWhat is happening with androids and apple devices in Russia, are they still functioning, and has it been considerer to cut them off?
- tguvot 4y agothey still function but apps of major banks (all or that are under sanctions, don't remember) were removed from stores. also it's not possible to pay for apps/subscriptions anymore i think
- bsaul 4y agoI love that europe is taking action, but i still have a huge concern that, according to the article, those that are giving the orders in brussels haven’t been elected in any remotely understandable way. Ursula has never ran a campaign for the position she’s in, no EU citizen knew or cared about her until the covid crisis, and we still have no idea what her political orientation is regarding a lot of socio-economical topics. I don’t think that situation can last much longer, unless we’re ready to give ground to the anti-EU fantasy of the union turning into some kind of techno-fascist regime. The scale of the measures she’s been involved with those past 2 years are beyond anything acceptable for any reasonable democracy.
- seydor 4y agoWhile EU leaders are often given credit for EU actions, in reality the burden of the sanctions, as well as their implementation was decided by member states themselves. It s telling that EU did not have a plan (and still does not) for the ensuing inflation, and countries like spain had to act individually when it hit them first. As for democracy in EU, i don't see it ever happening. In my mind the EU is a new kind of state (despite its horrible inefficiency), one that aims to work with process alone and not politics, and which can thus survive post-politics (in a way the US cannot). Given time, i would expect the commission and parliament to be replaced by AIs.
- Proven 4y ago