3 ms·
Ask HN: Standalone MP3 player and alarm , which can shuffle-play a playlist
I’ve been trying to (1) prioritize quality sleep, (2) set a good mindset for the day.
I have a playlist of advice/wisdom* audio files that I’d like to shuffle-play when I wake up & go to bed.
I’ve experimented with using home automation (Alexa Routines, Apple Shortcuts) to do this. I created a Spotify playlist, and had Alexa routines “shuffle playlist ‘Advice’ on Spotify” at 6am. It works.
However, I encountered problems:
- External Cloud/network issues would occasionally result in not being able to connect to Spotify. Last thing I want is a system that I can’t trust.
- Voice interfaces are frustrating. Alexa dots would occasionally soft-advertise services to me. It’s disruptive a peaceful mindset. Accidentally triggering the activation was comically infuriating.
- I travel frequently, and don’t feel like hauling around an Echo Dot, then setting it up on the hotel network, etc.
So… I axed all of the Echo/Homepods, and decided to start from scratch.
I want a single-purpose physical device, with buttons. Like an old school iPod Nano. I want to add files to it using USB storage. It should have multiple alarms (morning, afternoon, night), each which could shuffle-play a playlist. It should not require an internet connection to function.
I was tempted to hack something together with a Raspberry Pi (I suppose you could use cron to open VLC playlist files at custom schedules), but thought to ask here first.
This morning, I did some searching for standalone MP3 players. Haven’t found anything that jumps off the page. Sony still has a Walkman, there are some expensive audiophile devices like Fiio. Not a huge fan of touchscreens, even Apple-quality touchscreens are infuriating.
Is anyone aware of a product which:
- Standalone, dedicated device (not a smartphone, app)
- USB-accessible storage (USB-C would be great, SD card slot is ok)
- Multiple alarms
- Alarms can shuffle-play a playlist
- Headphones jack out (can plug into speakers while at the house)
- Physical buttons > Touch screen
- Long battery life, can be used as a music player on a road trip
- Easy to use
- High quality - would love to “solve” this problem for 10 years.
* For those curious, the advice playlist is “Earl Nightingale ‘The Strangest Secret’ and episodes from ‘Direct Line’. The dude nailed it & it works.
Who’s gone down this route and has suggestions?
- jka 4y agoRockbox[1] might be able to help you out with this - it's supported on a fairly wide range of devices, and includes an alarm-clock feature. [1] - https://www.rockbox.org/ https://www.rockbox.org/
- minhmeoke 4y ago+1 for Rockbox. The Sandisk Fuze and Fuze+, Clip, Clip+ and Clip Zip all have physical buttons and great sound quality for around $40 [1]. Note that newer iterations like Clip Sport Go use different hardware and are incompatible with Rockbox [2]. [1] https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=sandisk+clip https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=sandisk+clip [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/rockbox/comments/ap3ze1/trying_to_install_rockbox_on_my_sandisk_clip_sport/ https://www.reddit.com/r/rockbox/comments/ap3ze1/trying_to_i...
- dontbenebby 4y agoMany alarm clocks now have SD slots as well nowadays, you can throw mp3s on and shuffle.