5 ms·
The evidence suggests it is highly unlikely they are true. Most rape victims don't tweet about how it's "amazing" to hang out with "cool" and "smart" people af
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
The evidence suggests it is highly unlikely they are true.
Most rape victims don't tweet about how it's "amazing" to hang out with "cool" and "smart" people after being raped, or throw a party for their rapist.
http://rixstep.com/1/20101001,01.shtml http://rixstep.com/1/20101001,01.shtml
Nor do they usually invite their rapist to stay at their house 4 days after the rape.
http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2010/12/crayfish_parties_and_broken_co.html http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2010/12/crayfish_parties_and_br...
It's also a rather implausible coincidence that after these events, the rape charge only surfaced after a) Assange failed to call either Anna Ardin or Miss W. back and b) Ardin and W each discovered he was sleeping with the other one.
I think the story itself justifies a very low probability of being true - in my estimation, probably considerably less than 1%.
- jrockway 15y agoMost rape victims don't tweet about how it's "amazing" to hang out with "cool" and "smart" people after being raped, or throw a party for their rapist. Nor do they usually invite their rapist to stay at their house 4 days after the rape. Stockholm syndrome?
- zobzu 15y agoi can't figure out if that's sarcasm or a dumb sheeped down comment :p
- iamdave 15y agoWhy? I too think the charges are trumped up, but Stockholm is a possibility until one or both of these women come out with the truth of what actually happened.
- araneae 15y agoIt's not a possibility, because he did not hold them captive. Stockholm Syndrome only refers to situations where people who are held against their will have positive feelings towards their captors.
- AndyKelley 15y agoI'm pretty sure rape constitutes being held against one's will.
- westicle 15y agoI'm pretty sure HN is the only place where a bad pun can spawn pages of earnest analysis and semantic argument.
- AndyKelley 15y agoSure it's a possibility, but the burden of proof would be on you to demonstrate that it was Stockholm syndrome. You can't get by just claiming possible scenarios that explain something. You have to actually provide evidence that your claim is true (unless you're defending creationism)
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIt's also possible Anna Ardin is suffering from multiple personality disorder and one of her alternate personalities threw the party for Assange, tweeted about how cool he is, and invited him to stay with her 4 days after the rape. We could make up all sorts of implausible, but theoretically possible scenarios. But at this point, the most likely possibility seems to be that Ardin and W are jilted lovers who want revenge against Assange.
- iamdave 15y ago>We could make up all sorts of implausible, but theoretically possible scenarios. That is the entire point, none of us know with any degree of certainty what has happened, the evidence does not suggest anything concrete for or against the validity of the charges, so to immediately dismiss one way or dismiss the other way is flawed.
- lallysingh 15y ago.. or that as his lover, she was convinced to give testimony that lets authorities go after him while simultaneously hurting his reputation. Something very useful if you don't want to prevent further leaks.
- jrockway 15y agoSince I've been downmodded about 100 times for this comment, I thought I'd point out that it's Stockholm that's trying to get him extradited. It was a play on words, guys.
- mukyu 15y agoEven as a pun it is the kind of comment that belongs on reddit instead of HN.
- mushishi 15y agoHow can I even downvote? I only see upvote arrow. And how did your playfulness bring any relevant information to the discussion? There's nothing wrong with being funny but it should go alongside with usefulness; otherwise you end up with pun-festing.
- nickpinkston 15y agoVery well put!
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- FrankenTan 15y agoI'm afraid you're confused about the kind of rape-crime that he's allegedly been part of, and I'm not sure the 'typical' rape-responses can be considered when it's not a typical rape, but a matter of conditional consent. Even though I agree there are many questonable aspects: Unless I'm mistaken, in Sweden prosecutors are duty bound to attempt to investigate and possibly prosecute if a crime has been reported to them, sort of.