4 ms·
But how do you know that "informal logic" has anything to do with formal logic? Outside of math, formal logic seems actively misleading. For example, the "princ
by skybrian 4y ago
But how do you know that "informal logic" has anything to do with formal logic? Outside of math, formal logic seems actively misleading. For example, the "principle of explosion" (from a contradiction follows anything) is definitely not how people think.
Philosophically, I prefer the reasonable / rational / meta-rational framework explained by David Chapman. [1] But if you want to know how people ordinarily think, better to study how they think.
(And in practical everyday use on the Internet, I find logic mostly useful for for shooting down attempts at inappropriately applying logic to conclude things that you can't safely conclude.)
[1] https://metarationality.com/reasonableness-aspects https://metarationality.com/reasonableness-aspects
- IIAOPSW 4y ago>the "principle of explosion" (from a contradiction follows anything) is definitely not how people think. "Well then, if you believe that then you'll believe anything." Sounds pretty folksy to me.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Outside of math, formal logic seems actively misleading. For example, the "principle of explosion" (from a contradiction follows anything) is definitely not how people think. It's generally very easy to find natural language constructs that rely on any given principle of formal logic. For the principle of explosion, an example would be "if you're thirsty, there's tea in the kitchen".