8 ms·
I'm curious how you were able to come to the conclusion that the charges are "clearly false." The charges sound serious to me, and while I have not concluded on
by scott_s 15y ago
I'm curious how you were able to come to the conclusion that the charges are "clearly false." The charges sound serious to me, and while I have not concluded on their truth, I cannot dismiss them. They sound like they have enough merit for a trial. For example, "Given that one of the women said she awoke to find Mr. Assange having unprotected sex with her, she could not possibly have given her consent, Ms. Montgomery argued." (http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/12/world/europe/12assange.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/12/world/europe/12assange.htm...)
- oconnore 15y agoSince when has the burden of proof been with the accused? Do either of these women have evidence other than their own testimony?
- teaspoon 15y agoThe burden of proof is on the accusers, but "not proven" is a long way off from "clearly false".
- cperciva 15y agoMen accused of sexual offences have been presumed guilty until proven innocent for the past two decades. Didn't you get the memo?
- william42 15y agoAnd that's why so many of them have gone to jail recently...oh wait.
- tsotha 15y agoNot sure what you're trying to say there. Men go to jail on all the time purely on the strength of the victim's testimony. Seems like every week I'm reading a story in the newspaper about a guy who got released from jail after being cleared by a DNA test.
- nandemo 15y agoI agree that the accusations aren't clearly false, but note that he hasn't been formally charged with a crime. He will be extradited to Sweden to be questioned (!). AFAIK nobody said he's not going to court yet.
- toyg 15y agoThat's another scandal. Swedish prosecutors never issue international arrest warrants to question random Joe Sixpacks, certainly not for very dubious accusations like these. It's a shame that such a civilized country is being dragged through the mud by politically-motivated scumbags.
- nobody3141592 15y agoAnd the same British government refused to extradite General Pinochet to Spain for war crimes because there wasn't enough evidence! The courts are going to be very busy if months after every club 18-30 holiday you can regret a drunken 'romance' and have the other party extradited.
- tedunangst 15y agoUh, no, that's not why he was released.
- jeltz 15y agoAgreed, I do not believe the rape accusations were politically motivated but the international warrant obviously was. It is probably the first time ever sexual misconduct with weak evidence has resulted in an international arrest warrant.
- nandemo 15y agos/he's not going/he's going/
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe evidence suggests it is highly unlikely they are true. Most rape victims don't tweet about how it's "amazing" to hang out with "cool" and "smart" people after being raped, or throw a party for their rapist. http://rixstep.com/1/20101001,01.shtml http://rixstep.com/1/20101001,01.shtml Nor do they usually invite their rapist to stay at their house 4 days after the rape. http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2010/12/crayfish_parties_and_broken_co.html http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2010/12/crayfish_parties_and_br... It's also a rather implausible coincidence that after these events, the rape charge only surfaced after a) Assange failed to call either Anna Ardin or Miss W. back and b) Ardin and W each discovered he was sleeping with the other one. I think the story itself justifies a very low probability of being true - in my estimation, probably considerably less than 1%.
- jrockway 15y agoMost rape victims don't tweet about how it's "amazing" to hang out with "cool" and "smart" people after being raped, or throw a party for their rapist. Nor do they usually invite their rapist to stay at their house 4 days after the rape. Stockholm syndrome?
- zobzu 15y agoi can't figure out if that's sarcasm or a dumb sheeped down comment :p
- iamdave 15y agoWhy? I too think the charges are trumped up, but Stockholm is a possibility until one or both of these women come out with the truth of what actually happened.
- araneae 15y agoIt's not a possibility, because he did not hold them captive. Stockholm Syndrome only refers to situations where people who are held against their will have positive feelings towards their captors.
- mc32 15y agoIsn't it the case when you sympathise with someone one gives them the benefit of doubt --but when one dislikes someone one envisions the worst? 1. Imagine a good friend accused of something (ex. aggr. assault). 2. Imagine a good friend accuses someone of the same thing. If instead of Assange, the accused were a live Qaddafi, or, say the Dalai Lama, would we not see things a bit differently, in each case, due to bias? We just don't know. It's all conjecture at this point with he said, she said.