4 ms·
> The Supreme Court is comprised of lifelong appointees, mostly in the dwindling twilight of their cognitive ability. This made sense when we didn't understand
by rayiner 4y ago
> The Supreme Court is comprised of lifelong appointees, mostly in the dwindling twilight of their cognitive ability. This made sense when we didn't understand cognitive decline. Now with the rapid pace of technological progress, it's a joke.
The Supreme Court is not that old. Only two are in their (early) 70s, and three are in their 50s. John Roberts, the median aged judge, and is about the same age as Bill Gates.
And you're wrong about the science. Crystallized intelligence grows with age and is stable into one's 70s. Vocabulary, for example, peaks in one's late 60's and early 70's. https://news.mit.edu/2015/brain-peaks-at-different-ages-0306 https://news.mit.edu/2015/brain-peaks-at-different-ages-0306
Fluid intelligence peaks at age 20, but judges aren't being tested on their ability to solve timed logic puzzles.
> The whole legal rationalist ideal that you can start from the base principles of the constitution and reason up indefinitely is ridiculous.
I agree it's ridiculous. The Constitution is a rulebook, not a set of principles to use as a starting point. "What would these words have meant to the people who wrote them?" That's how we interpret any other document. It's not hard.