6 ms·
I wonder how much of this is the development culture at MS. https://www.theregister.com/2022/05/10/jeffrey_snover_said_microsoft_demoted/ https://www.theregiste
by rayiner 4y ago
I wonder how much of this is the development culture at MS. https://www.theregister.com/2022/05/10/jeffrey_snover_said_microsoft_demoted/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/05/10/jeffrey_snover_said_m... (“When I was doing the prototype for what became PowerShell, a friend cautioned me saying that was the sort of thing that got people fired.”)
In that environment I can imagine nobody wants to be on the hook for messing with something fundamental like malloc().
The complete trash fire that is O365 and Teams—for some reason the new Outlook kicks you out to a web app just to manage your todos—suggests to me that Microsoft may be suffering from a development culture that’s more focused on people protecting fiefdoms than delivering the best product. I saw this with Nortel before it went under. It was so sclerotic that they would outsource software development for their own products to third party development shops because there was too much internal politics to execute them in house.
- munch117 4y agoYou shouldn't read too much into the PowerShell story. Creating your own programming language is in most cases a frivolous vanity project. Spending company resources on your own frivolous vanity projects is the sort of thing that can get you fired.
- sterlind 4y ago! I disagree. CMD badly needed replacing. MS needed a new shell language. A functional company would connect people with a passion for X with the resources to achieve X, if X has a chance of helping the company. Windows Terminal and WSL show how far MS has come from the PS days. (Disclaimer: I work for MS)
- londons_explore 4y agoI think the smart move would have been to make an official port of bash...
- hughw 4y agoMaybe that's how we got WSL
- jrockway 4y agoSome experimentation in that space is probably a good thing. Bash is familiar, but it's far from perfect. In terms of executing programs, it gets the critical functionality down pretty well; readline-based editing, variables, aliases, pipes, IO redirects, background process management, etc. In terms of being a programming language, I always regret when I use it. I recently had a minor heart attack when I realized that our CI was green when tests were failing; deep down in some shell script, someone forgot to turn on "pipefail" and the shell linter to check for that was misconfigured, and so the CI command that piped output to a logfile failed, but the log file was written OK, so "exit 0". In terms of interactive poking around at a computer, I never really liked the UNIX philosophy here. I run a terminal emulator, which connects to a remote server over SSH, which is running a terminal multiplexer, which is running bash, which then runs my programs. None of these things know anything about each other. The UNIX way!!! The end result is total jank and some useful features are completely impossible to implement. The various shells running under the multiplexer overwrite each other's history. The terminal multiplexer can't give the terminal emulator its scrollback buffer. The shell history is specific to the machine that the shell is running on, not the machine that the terminal is running on. Echoing the character you just typed involves two TCP round trips! It's so bad, guys. For that reason, I totally see the desire to re-engineer this space. There are a lot of improvements to be mad. Powershell is an interesting attempt. It doesn't solve any of my problems, though, and I personally don't enjoy using it. It's verbose and unergonomic, and still not a good programming language for making stuff happen. Windows is missing the glue ecosystem of things like "grep", "sed", "curl", etc., which make matters worse. (Powershell provides some of those things as cmdlets, but the "curl" one opens up IE to make you click something, and weird stuff like that.) It's nice that someone tried to make a new thing. I personally think it's worse than everything else out there. TL;DR: "we've always used bash" leaves a lot to be desired. It's fine. But if someone says they can do better, I completely agree.
- skissane 4y ago
- 13of40 4y agoThe way I remember it, the need for a new shell language for system administration was something that lots of people in Windows Server were trying to solve. Ballmer talked about it, we had a push to add a handful of new command line tools (like tasklist.exe I think) that you could use under CMD, and there was a proof of concept where MMC could be used to output some kind of macro language when users did things in the UI. PowerShell was the thing that eventually won, and I think it was largely because it stood on the shoulders of .Net so had a ton of capability right out of the gate. (And TBH, I think it's a little bit weird that we have this mythos today where Snover sat down at his computer one morning and invented it out of thin air, when even the v1 feature team had something like 30 engineers and PMs on it.)
- skissane 4y ago> CMD badly needed replacing CMD is nasty but there are lots of little ways in which it could have been improved. For example, provide an option to disable that useless "Terminate batch job (Y/N)?" prompt. I wish Microsoft would open-source CMD.EXE. I dislike how slow PowerShell is (especially its startup). Maybe nobody at Microsoft cares about CMD.EXE enough to fix those long-standing little annoyances like the above, but if it was open-source other people out there would. Also, I wonder why nobody ever seemed to have thought of integrating CSCRIPT into CMD, so that you could have seamlessly mixed VBScript (or other WSH languages) into batch files.
- munch117 4y agoI didn't say that this project in particular was a vanity project. Just that when someone comes to you with a project and says "I'm going to solve our problems by using this new programming language that I'm in the process of inventing", then some skepticism is not unwarranted. In hindsight, this particular one may be the best thing since sliced bread. But that's survivorship bias.
- sterlind 4y ago(I work for MS, though in core Azure rather than Office or Windows.) I think that PowerShell story was how old MS worked, back in the days of stack ranking, hatred of Linux and the Longhorn fiasco. things inside the company are a lot more functional now. I saw internal politics drama at my first position, but once I moved everything was chill, and experimentation and contributing across team boundaries was actively encouraged and rewarded. I suspect Office suffers from a ton of technical debt, along with being architecturally amorphous and dating from a pre-cloud era. as for Windows, the amount of breakage I see in the betas suggests they're not afraid of making deep changes, it's probably that MSVCRT is a living fossil and has to support old programs monkeypatching the guts of malloc or something.
- lkfjasdlkjfsad 4y agoany idea what the hell is going on with Teams? why can't i simply scroll up in my own conversations? let alone search them. the sticky sludge of communication in something as simple as chat has cost me hours since i was forced to use teams. outlook search is so superior to teams i'd easily prefer to have lync back. this one thing absolutely cripples communication. there are a list of other very basic issues that make communicating code blocks frustrating. i see new app features here and there, i saw some feature added the other day which won't help anyone. i just don't understand the prioritization of issues i don't expect a direct answer to this, although i hope to read an explanation one day EDIT: i removed content from this comment that was missing the point
- stagger87 4y agoPEBKAC, you can scroll and search chats in teams.
- lkfjasdlkjfsad 4y ago> you can scroll outrageously slowly, and i'm not talking about a couple HTTP requests and a database query slow > and search search is not practical in my opinion. i'd go as far as saying it's unusable. i can _find individual messages_, but there are times (often, i might add!) where context or jumping to that message aren't even options. context is often the reason you search for messages in the first place. if i'm alone here, sure, PEBKAC
- assttoasstmgr 4y ago> people protecting fiefdoms than delivering the best product. Apparently you have never worked at any company with more than 50 employees because that's literally how every large company works. Career-obsessed managers who can't see the forest for the trees not giving a single shit about the overall product as long as their goals were met. They're off to the next promotion before all hell breaks loose.