3 ms·
I like that people are thinking about this, but this particular model bums me out: it assumes that the average package management user is a corporate user, rath
by woodruffw 4y ago
I like that people are thinking about this, but this particular model bums me out: it assumes that the average package management user is a corporate user, rather than another member of the community. It also disincentivizes one of the major inflows for open source contribution, which is installing a random tool, finding a use case that you need or bug that needs fixing, and contributing it back upstream.
- abathur 4y agoI roughly agree. I guess it would also incentivize some weird behavior like buying a project to take it private and try to extract value from users of the toolchains it's been built into. This would be marginally better than buying a project to inject a backdoor or malware per instance, but it might be a lot more common? (It seems to be much more compatible with existing ~vulture-capital behavior.) It would probably be Bad for most maintainers if our dependency chains were regularly being roiled by someone taking a package private.
- rexpop 4y agoThe average "member of the community" is a "corporate user." In my experience, OSS is frequently written in IC's on-the-clock discretionary time in an official, sponsored capacity. It might even be ticketed! And when those contributors pull in 3rd party tolls and libraries to complete their work, that's when they inhabit the roll of "the average package management user." To what "community" do you refer that's outside of commercial activity?
- woodruffw 4y agoThe people who this work is ostensibly meant to fund: the ones who engage in open source because they think it’s the right thing to do, or because they’re hobbyists, or they just like helping others. To be clear, I am both: I am paid professionally as a software developer, and I’m a member of the open source community for my own reasons. My job already pays me, so the question of compensation is meant to pertain to the latter category.