3 ms·
> In societies somewhere in between, with a flawed rule of law, like India, these predictions are impossibly hard to make. I think this is overselling the stab
by roenxi 4y ago
> In societies somewhere in between, with a flawed rule of law, like India, these predictions are impossibly hard to make.
I think this is overselling the stability of the judicial process in the UK, US and other countries with a strong grounding in the rule of law. Without getting to political, sometimes judicial controversies spring up in the US. The issue is there are centuries of norms to fall back on. India doesn't have that yet - they have millennia of history in being the centre of civilisation but not in how the current legal system should be applied under the governance of the sweaty masses of voting Indians.
India is going to be more politically dynamic than the US at the moment because it is bigger and its ability to direct itself democratically is a bit younger. So judges are going to be harder to predict regardless of how strong the rule of law is - there is effectively less data even assuming a perfect rule of law.
- pixl97 4y ago> sometimes judicial controversies spring up in the US. I think you are massively understating the instability the SCOTUS has presented in the past few weeks by overturning existing case law.
- gunfighthacksaw 4y agoThe repeal of Roe v Wade was a gut punch for me, but I’ve known it was entirely possible for quite a long time. Plus some states have had trigger laws forever so that’s hardly surprising. Yes, there will be instability, but it’s not the chaotic out-of-the-blue kind, unless you’re wilfully ignorant of the anti abortion movement, or extremely naive to the motivations of that bloc.
- short_sells_poo 4y agoAs a slight tangent since you seem to be knowledgeable: what is the motivation of the anti abortion bloc? I feel that godliness and a true care for life yet unborn is not it, because the bloc does not exhibit these qualities in many other areas...
- mlyle 4y agoEh, I do think it's being repulsed at the idea of killin' babies. Combined with not weighting the value of the choices of women or the impact on them or their bodies very high. Look, uh, abortion is kinda a yucky thing. There's not some bright-line moment of change and investiture with consciousness and being that happens at the moment of birth. It's only when you decide the choices and bodily autonomy of the adult woman is more important than the potential of the life growing in her that you can support abortion.
- calvinmorrison 4y agoand "the gloves are off". If the entire government just spent 2 years justifying the coerced vaccination of the masses - all thought bodily autonomy thrown out for the greater good? Sure the Rightwingers are happy to play that game as well.
- rootusrootus 4y agoIMO comparing vaccination to women's bodily autonomy is a bad faith argument. Vaccination is about protecting society -- the protection it offers individuals who get the vaccine is incidental. Anti-abortion folks have a stronger argument, IMO, by focusing on the liberty of the unborn child. Both sides refuse to give up ground, however, for political reasons. The logical conclusion is that there is a point somewhere on the scale between 0 and 9 months where a fetus gains enough liberty to qualify for rights of its own that can be balanced against the rights of the mother. I hope some day we can come together to define that point and codify it.
- mlyle 4y ago> to qualify for rights of its own that can be balanced against the rights of the mother. I'm not sure how much I agree. If you were grafted to my arm and that was keeping you alive... I would think it would be within my rights to remove you.
- calvinmorrison 4y ago
- pm90 4y agoIf you read the opinions they’re not very convincing. They’re making up principles to adhere to which did not exist before, and doing this for things that have broad support in the US population. So it is quite chaotic out of the blue kind. Essentially the Judges are ruling by decree and will strike down any law that’s not explicitly enumerated in the constitution (and even there they will certainly weaken the law as we saw with Roe v Wade).
- rootusrootus 4y agoA lot of people think it's possible to read the constitution literally and divine what the words mean. To them, all of this makes perfect sense, because they can't see how the previous rulings ever fit what the constitution prescribes. I sympathize, but clearly there is far more to our laws than just the words on that document. It's just the set of principles providing some foundation. Hell, we started with "congress shall make no law..." and extrapolated that all the way to pretty much any institution funded by taxes. Clearly a literal reading has limits.
- rland 4y agoIn light of recent events, the only conclusion I can arrive at is that originalism as a legal theory was a decades-long project created with the express purpose of overturning the Warren-era jurisprudence. Roe is the first salvo, but there are many more regressions coming. It was not created as a good-faith "alternate interpretation." It is not a cohesive or logical theory. It is, instead, a weapon, whose targets should be clear to everyone now. The way the weapon works is that you assume that it is being made in good faith and engage with it on its own terms. And then, again and again, get owned. Because the other guy is just making stuff up, and you, the sucker, are actually arguing. I'm not quite in conspiracy territory yet, but I really would like to know what they are saying out loud behind closed doors at the Federalist Society HQ.
- turdit 4y ago
- skybrian 4y agoYes, that has added to the instability, but most court cases are unlike the ones that go all the way to the Supreme Court.
- johannes1234321 4y agoTrue, few cases go there, but the recent decision means, that there is no such thing as "settled law" anymore. The Supreme Court may change its oppiin on any thing, thus on lower courts it's harder to say "see, there was that decision, we follow it" but there is more freedom to derive from it.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agothe sheer number of mindnumbing number of open cases in indian judiciary is the problem. Here are a couple of livestreams of high courts in india https://www.youtube.com/c/BlackGownlaw https://www.youtube.com/c/BlackGownlaw https://www.youtube.com/c/GujaratHighCourtLive/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/GujaratHighCourtLive/videos you can easily find courts right now hearing cases from 20-30 years ago meaning all that time, the case has been delayed for some reason or the other. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-1qOtI9zv8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-1qOtI9zv8 here is a hearing for a person who has been incarcerated for 4 years and no charges have been filed against him. the court granted him bail but it only took the court 4 years to do so. edit: that said, it is simply not a question of increasing the number of courts because apparently it costs milions and millions to set up a single courtroom. things have definitely improved in the last decades as arbitration is given preference, there is things like "lok adalats" where small cases are heard in a quick succession so that case loads are reduced.