6 ms·
Google will delete location history data for abortion clinic visits
- Terry_Roll 4y agoIf they can delete it, can they create it?
- remram 4y agoObviously yes
- samhw 4y agoYes. They can delete it, they can create it, they can mutate it. That’s how it works when you send information about yourself to somebody else for them to store on their hard drives. This is true utterly irrespective of whether they in fact delete it (or do any other of those things).
- Zenst 4y agoWill it leave telling holes and what about locations near clinics as mindful from Google Maps in dense area's how it thinks you went to one shop when you did not and just happened to be near there. Would be better if it randomly shifted visits to nearby stores to mask things instead of telling holes in the data.
- liorben-david 4y agoI think the idea is that while any person could probably connect the dots, in a courtroom the fact that they were around the clinic is purely circumstantial and therefore insufficient to prove someone got an abortion.
- pixl97 4y agoThat won't help much with civil lawsuit states like Texas then.
- Zenst 4y agoWell for Texans they could just break into Mexico over the border and get an abortion there as it was legalised in Mexico in 2021. Ironic I know. But the whole prospect of border patrols/checks noting who is pregnant enterying Mexico and suddenly not upon return is an aspect that may well come to pass.
- galleywest200 4y agoThe commenter was referring to the Texas law that allows anybody to sue someone in civil court if they have evidence they got an abortion. Texans going to Mexico would still open them up to these lawsuits.
- Zenst 4y agoHow can that work as a law? More so it will only encourage `accidents` to facilitate loss of pregancy, which will only further endager life due to fear of being sued by some Texan. Really is shocking and deeply worrying.
- pixl97 4y ago>How can that work as a law? It cannot, and they don't care that it cannot. The cruelty is the point.
- antifa 4y ago> noting who is pregnant enterying Mexico and suddenly not upon return Abortion is legal up to 12 weeks in Mexico. As a result, anyone showing up even at peak 12 weeks would not be visibly pregnant from outside the car.
- imiric 4y agoHow noble of them. They really care about their users, except when they don't[1]. [1]: https://www.propublica.org/article/google-russia-rutarget-sberbank-sanctions-ukraine https://www.propublica.org/article/google-russia-rutarget-sb...
- meatsauce 4y ago
- keithalewis 4y ago
- JoeyBananas 4y agoThe idea is that abolishing row v. wade = "bad for privacy" = tech companies will now start tracking your abortions This is complete hogwash, it's nothing but pure hysteria really
- antifa 4y agoWhen Germany fell to fascism, the fascists found lists of people they don't like and used it to hunt them down and kill them. There might be some histeria somewhere in all this. But the tech companies didn't start making the lists. They've always been making the lists. And privacy proponents are right to not want to be on a bunch of lists that are one subpoena or purchase away from being a kill list.
- bavell 4y agoThis is the basic reasoning behind why people are so opposed to a "national gun registry".
- pixl97 4y agoWhen your comment history has comments that say "objective morality is real and comes from the bible" either this post is satire and you like typing out unobvious jokes, or this post was made intentionally in bad faith ignoring all evidence from both tech companies behavior and politicians stated intents.
- baobob 4y agoMy comment history has none of that, and I agree with the parent comment. Would you agree with the comment if I had wrote it instead?
- fallingfrog 4y agoNo
- pixl97 4y agoNo, I would state that you're in denial of objective reality in a different way than the parent comment.
- tsol 4y agoOkay now can they do they for all visits, for everyone now?
- Geonode 4y agoGreat so when I'm accused of murder while I was at planned Parenthood, I have no alibi.
- remram 4y agoThe staff at Planned Parenthood is not good enough?
- grrandalf 4y agoNo, for several reasons. including: (1) you have much more legal authority to request your OWN records from an entity, than to compel a 3rd party to testify on your behalf, (2) waaay simpler/cheaper than getting witness testimony etc, (3) also applies to fertility centers and addiction centers (wtf?) And pedantically following up from your rebuttal: what if Planned Parenthood was closed when you got there and no one there actually saw you? I think it's short-sighted and wrong of Google to subvert the integrity of location history. #IANAL but location history has been very useful to me (yes, in court). Not to mention some women may WANT to establish that they tried to get an abortion on so-and-so date. It might end up being devastating when they discover after the fact that Google has/had scrubbed their location history. I'm highly pro-choice but this feels less than useless to me. Even from a political perspective this may be an own goal: (1) it reinforces idea that abortion/addiction/etc is something to be ashamed of [no], (2) the impact will be felt in only "abortion-friendly states": umm there will be no abortion centers to visit in "abortion-unfriendly states".
- remram 4y agoOn the other hand, the Google Timeline only records that your phone was there, so very weak evidence that you were not somewhere else. Especially if no one sees you because it's closed. In addition, many phones (or emulators) will let you fake your GPS position which Google Maps will happily record. I don't understand why we are so keen on trusting algorithms above people. In this case, algorithms that are not remotely meant to be trusted by third-parties but are meant to keep a history for oneself.
- jqpabc123 4y agoAre you using your phone ... or is your phone using you? Yes.