3 ms·
Another problem to note is that LEO can (and often does) just buy the data. Even through shell companies. No warrant needed. You may not get info on a specific
by godelski 4y ago
Another problem to note is that LEO can (and often does) just buy the data. Even through shell companies. No warrant needed. You may not get info on a specific individual, but you sure can reduce your search space.
Surveillance Capitalism was a mistake. I don't see how it can lead to anything but a Cyber Punk reality. I'm not sure it will even be okay if we get homomorphic encryption going (but clearly there isn't big efforts to do so by these companies).
- mariojv 4y agoI've seen HN posts indicating that Apple uses homomorphic encryption for part if its differential privacy efforts in the past (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31672254 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31672254), but am really having trouble finding sources to back this assertion up.
- godelski 4y agoI highly doubt this tbh. Not that I'm a homomorphic researcher, but in ML I try to keep an eye on it. Everyone I've talked to has always said it is 100x to 1000x slower. Though there is hope since some have told me that they are all CPU based. I have no idea if you could write cuda kernels for this or not. But still, there's a pretty big hit. If you do find a citation I'd love to see it too. I think what bugs me about that comment is "differential privacy" is a different type of privacy than homomorphic, so would indicate that they are using... differential privacy... Minor edit: I did find some research papers by Apple mentioning Homomorphic encryption, but nothing to suggest they are using it.