4 ms·
The fact that there even is such a thing as "user location history" is the problem. Carving out (politically motivated, for sure) exceptions only shows the exte
by userbinator 4y ago
The fact that there even is such a thing as "user location history" is the problem. Carving out (politically motivated, for sure) exceptions only shows the extent of Google's massive abuse of privacy.
- bArray 4y agoExactly. Collecting location data in itself should not be done, and the presumption that Google is somehow equipped to know when not to collect data is pretty disgusting. It's entirely possible that location data is abused in many ways they cannot think of. For example, a location that ties somebody to the illegal purchase of a pharmacy drug they desperately need, but cannot otherwise obtain. One could only imagine what the likes of Hitler, Stalin or Mao (to name a few) would have been capable of if only they had been able to compel the likes of Google to release location data. It's an exceptional tool and a weapon in the wrong hands.
- mc32 4y agoEven the better governments of the world are using this kind of information contrary to the spirit of the law and in many cases against the law itself --and very very few in gov't care, what's more most in government want to expand the capabilities. So, yes, imagine the bad guys and gals.
- kornhole 4y agoWatching everybody's movements is tyranny. When you compare how much power those classical tyrants had to what the state has now, you may not need to compare the relatively impotent states of the past.
- mc32 4y agoThis is a good opportunity for privacy proponents and activists to take advantage of this opening and push for a stop to the collection of any of this information. This is the time to take the mile, this is the time to make the slope slippery.
- jimbob45 4y agoAt least for high-impact locations if they can’t get everything. Women’s shelters and hospitals would be an excellent start.
- mc32 4y agoNeither companies not governments should have people's information at their fingertips. Ok, maybe on foreign spies, yes, by all means, but not for citizens. They should not have that kind of information on people. This is something we used to make fun of the Stasi for --and they didn't have THIS capability. But, yet here we are happy to accept it these days.
- pessimizer 4y agoGay bars. The homes of people who have been to gay bars. Synagogues.
- jeffbee 4y agoWhy do "privacy activists" have standing to intermediate between me and a third party, if I want to use that third party's services to remember where I've been? Privacy activists need to check themselves.
- mc32 4y agoNo problem if you opt in to it as an option.
- guiambros 4y agoPer [1]: - Location History is turned off by default for your Google Account and can only be turned on if you opt in. - You can pause Location History at any time in your Google Account's Activity controls. - You control what’s saved in your Location History. You can view the places where you’ve been in Google Maps Timeline, which you can edit or use to delete your Location History. And... - You can turn off Location History for your account at any time. - You can manage and delete your Location History information with Google Maps Timeline. You can choose to delete all of your history, or only parts of it. - You can choose to automatically delete Location History that’s older than 3 months, 18 months, or 36 months. Seriously, I don't see how it could be more flexible and user-controlled than this. (Disclaimer: Googler, but no relationship with Maps or Geo teams. As an individual user, I use and love my location history, and appreciate the level of control I have) [1] https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/3118687 https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/3118687
- 2020aj 4y agoI actually love location history. Makes it easy to answer questions like: "what was the name of that great restaurant in Edinburgh when I visited 4 years ago?" Edit: but I do agree it should be opt-in
- mc32 4y agoThat is a very emotional argument --but I accept that you could opt in to it. On the other hand, you might instead discover a new or different restaurant experience you would not have otherwise. Which, of course, could be better or worse.
- userbinator 4y agoI have nothing against tracking your own location and keeping records of it yourself; but it's an entirely different thing when a company which arguably has more power than the governments of multiple countries does it by default and keeps the records on its servers.
- kccqzy 4y ago> does it by default Yet the Google blog post says > Location History is a Google account setting that is off by default See https://blog.google/technology/safety-security/protecting-peoples-privacy-on-health-topics/ https://blog.google/technology/safety-security/protecting-pe... FWIW I checked my own Google account. It was not enabled. And I have no recollection or plan to ever enable it. It's saddening to see HN users (among all people) peddling falsehoods like this.
- car_analogy 4y ago> Location History is a Google account setting that is off by default Android still by default "shares" location with Google. That setting is merely to turn off storing that data on Google's side. Unless they get a warrant compelling them to keep it. And unless they are lying, again: https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-admits-tracking-users-location-even-when-setting-disabled/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-admits-tracking-users-l...
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoIt can be turned off in account settings. https://myactivity.google.com/activitycontrols?settings=location https://myactivity.google.com/activitycontrols?settings=loca...
- getpost 4y agoI've always wondered whether turning it off merely hides it from the end-user.
- bushbaba 4y agoTurning it off doesn’t mean google stops the collection of data.
- user764743 4y agoTurn Off buttons are like delete buttons on the internet, they don't really do what they say they do.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoPlease cite a source for your claim.
- user764743 4y agoPlease cite a source where it says they do what they say. Or ask any experienced web developers, they will tell you.
- cyanydeez 4y agoOf course, but there's also a problem that a specific location, we know, would be enough evidence for far right pitchforks
- somenewaccount1 4y agoI completely disagree. Someone filed a fraudulent accident report with my insurance company (probably a parking attendant stole my insurance info from my glove box). Google location data saved me as I could illustrate exactly where I was at the supposed time of accident. I have found it useful for hiking and stuff too.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoGood for you. But what about the rest of us? Or even yourself on any other day? To equate privacy with convenience is ill advised.
- somenewaccount1 4y agoTurn it off? Use another device?
- PostOnce 4y agoIt should be off by default, rather than on by default, so you can choose to have it, and we don't accidentally go to prison for going to a doctor who was legal to visit last week and forgetting to alter one of a million privacy settings on one of fifty devices.
- fiddlerwoaroof 4y agoIt is off by default, on iOS at least: you have to open Google maps and opt-in to always-on location tracking. It’s by far my favorite feature of Google maps.
- PostOnce 4y agoOff by default in one app on one device, we still have to worry about smartwatches, cell tower positions, network geolocation, 400 thousands apps with location access to GPS or who knows what; your car reporting back to tesla that you ate somewhere that sold pork in saudi arabia, or visited an abortion clinic in texas, or who knows. It's too damn much. I personally don't use corporate shit anymore, but I know that's a near-impossible tech for people whose full-time job isn't deep tech. We need to make life livable for those people, by legislating foremost of all, but also by making tools available and easy to use, and I'm sure many things I can't think of, but we should at least be discussing it.