3 ms·
Luckily voting is not seeking proof, but alignment to desire and outcome. The problem being that the words debate, and proof, and argument(um) are applied in mo
by ggm 4y ago
Luckily voting is not seeking proof, but alignment to desire and outcome. The problem being that the words debate, and proof, and argument(um) are applied in more than one field. Words have many meanings and if the fields are close (political debate around
logical proofs and lines of legal reasoning) this is a problem. Of COURSE politicians make appeals to popular sentiment and of COURSE they make appeals to authority (of the court over government, of religion over constitution, you name it)
The SCOTUS may well believe their legal process defends either for or against populism, the proponents outside are definitely trying to appeal to the people as they see it. Misreading the numbers in low participation voting is not uncommon so I suspect contributing biasses exist to say "look there are millions of us here, we must be right"
Statistically, only a minority actually align to most current populist appeals like anti abortion, war on China, guns. The problem is not arguments to popularity, it's distortion of voting process to empower bad decisions on specious grounds of popular support.
I write this since the only substantial debate and argument subject to this problem right now, is the war on women's reproductive rights. The rightist, anti abortionist view definitely think they are both correct and in a majority. I differ on their correctness, and I differ on the actuality of their majority outside of gerrymandered seats, low turnout and voter suppression.
I suspect they would counter the populist street protests are evidence of appeals to the people, not the logic of the legalism at play. Is anyone seriously believing the central problem of our time is states rights, or the need for originalist interpretation of constitutional law? I don't think so, but I'm partisan.