4 ms·
IMHO the CFCs were one of the biggest advances in technology in the 20th century. Non-toxic, non-flammable, and stable under ordinary conditions, and providing
by userbinator 4y ago
IMHO the CFCs were one of the biggest advances in technology in the 20th century. Non-toxic, non-flammable, and stable under ordinary conditions, and providing very good efficiency compared to the alternatives. The problem is with large-scale atmospheric releases, not with the substance itself.
Thus I am absolutely in agreement with recollecting, reselling, and reusing, but in strong opposition to destroying what would otherwise be useful. The latter only encourages the replacement of equipment in a continued cycle of forced obolescence, which might be far worse from a CO2 perspective.
I've always found it a little amusing that R152a, which is a pretty good replacement for R12, you can buy in "gas dusters" and legally vent all you want to the atmosphere, but it's technically illegal according to the EPA to recharge an R12 system with it.
This is from the viewpoint of someone who restores and repairs old appliances. Environmental considerations aside, I'd never vent deliberately, just because of how expensive and rare these substances are now --- and not surprisingly, there is an underground market for banned refrigerants too.
Thus, "you're throwing away money if you vent refrigerant" is probably going to have a much bigger effect than mentioning "climate change".
- jsmith45 4y agoThe illegal to retrofit R152a thing is mostly about old systems not being designed to ensure that in the event of a leak people are not exposed to high levels (concentrations of 3.7% v/v or above) for more than 15 seconds. Old designed for R12 were not engineered to meet those guarentees. R152a can be huffed to get high, and doing so can be lethal. Thus we know that prolonged exposures to high enough concentrations of R152a can cause fatal cardiac arrhythmia. So it is fundamentally a safety concern. Just an unfortunate one, considering how good it otherwise is as an R12 replacement.
- avianlyric 4y agoWell R152a is a highly flammable gas that produces hydrogen fluoride and carbon monoxide as it burns. R12 on the other hand is used a fire suppressant on submarines. I don’t think banning the use of a high flammable gas in systems originally designed to operate with a fire suppressant is a bad idea. I think it’s quite reasonable to assume that designers of R12 systems didn’t worry about accidental leaks into enclosed environments with ignition sources, on account of an R12 leak being completely safe in that situation. R152a on the other hand, that’s just an explosion waiting to happen.
- userbinator 4y agoMisinformation seems to abound about refrigerants as much as anything else, but 152a is definitely NOT "highly flammable" or we would see gas dusters having the same warnings that propane and isobutane (R290, R600a) come with. It is classified as "slightly flammable", and is actually rather difficult to ignite in practice.
- inferiorhuman 4y agoR12 turns into phosgene gas when exposed to flame, that's certainly an interesting choice for a fire retardant on a submarine of all things.