3 ms·
Given two competing startups, one which starts users with a blank slate and one which a) gives them instant content when they sign up and b) manipulates them in
by patio11 15y ago
Given two competing startups, one which starts users with a blank slate and one which a) gives them instant content when they sign up and b) manipulates them into continuing to use the application via using social proof and peer pressure, it is highly likely that only one of them will survive long enough to get geeks complaining about it. I know which one I'm betting on.
Consider it from this angle: you can undo this default for exactly the same amount of work you're proposing to subject everyone to: for each friend, manually select your desired state of followed or unfollowed. You're not going to actually do that, because it's a stupid amount of work and despite being motivated enough to write a blog post you're just not that into this app. To a close approximation, only freaks and geeks care enough about software to go through a multi-hour setting tweaking session prior to actually receiving value.
You can test this if you have an application you don't care about destroying user growth for: have them do lots of pointless work on the first user experience. See what it does to activation rates. A/B test "Do lots of gruntwork" versus "App does the pointless makework for you" if you want some statistical rigor.
P.S. If having one's monkey brain hacked on disconcerts you, stay far away from social software, because that is the whole game plan.
- tjoff 15y agoYou seem to mix up value with spam. I have a crazy idea. What if you were only notified by what you actually wanted to know about? Also, if I like your service/app I'm going to be insulted if you spam others with my actions without my explicit consent. Good thing about crap like this is that people hopefully think twice before giving away their facebook/whatever account and forcing users to log in with facebook will be a thing in the past (keep telling yourself that it is because you want to make it easier for your users - you can not argue that you care about the user the slightest until you offer alternative ways to log in). Is the concept of giving the user a choice that hard to grasp? Give the user a way to uncheck the "spam my friends" checkbox. Oh, I'm sorry, do your whole idea base itself around spamming users? Well, then, too bad. Please get off the internet.
- patio11 15y agoYou seem to be quite passionate about the ethical or aesthetically pleasing way to implementing following in a web application. Passion is cool, but I'd encourage you to think of what HN would be like if two ways to think about user following routinely resulted in "Please get off the Internet." I do not necessarily disagree with your normative beliefs here. I'm just saying, as a positive statement of empirical reality, an application which is designed to work like the one you have described will perform worse than one which works like the emerging standard of autoinvites. Measurably worse. It's kind of like Girl Wearing A Headset photos: without saying they're either pleasing or tacky, one can make the observation that they've been tested to death hundreds of times and they generally increase conversion rates.
- gjm11 15y agoThis kind of "positive statement of empirical reality" tends to (1) be true, and (2) make the world a worse place as everyone acts accordingly, until (3) it stops being true and (4) everything goes horribly wrong. Banking, circa 2007: As a positive statement of empirical reality, selling unrealistic mortgages to unsuitable customers and then packaging up the default risk into CDSes and selling them on will perform better than lending responsibly. Banking, circa 2008: Oops. Any pyramid scheme, in its earliest stages: As a positive statement of empirical reality, signing up will perform better than ignoring it. The same pyramid scheme, after a couple of iterations have saturated the market of available fools: Oops. The Dutch tulip market in 1735: As a positive statement of empirical reality, selling everything you've got to buy tulips as the market climbs inexorably higher will perform better than holding on to old-fashioned goods like gold and houses and food. The Dutch tulip market in 1740: Oops. The personal computer market, circa 2000: As a positive statement of empirical reality, what people want to buy is the cheapest possible computers (or, for a lucrative subset of the market, the cheapest possible computers with impressive-looking specs) running Microsoft Windows. Selling cheap generic boxes will perform better than trying to make something of really high quality, and anything other than Windows is a loser's game. The personal computer market, in 2011: Apple is bigger than Microsoft, many makers of generic beige boxes are frantically trying to get out of the business, and it's a serious question whether "personal computers" in general will get their market almost completely eaten by tablets (meaning, for the present, mostly iPads) and smartphones. Spamming users' social networks is like selling crappy mortgages, tulips, or mediocre cookie-cutter computers. It may, for the time being, be an easier way to make money than the obvious alternatives, but every time someone does it the world becomes a slightly worse place, and sooner or later it's likely that people will notice and stop playing along. Of course you're welcome to point out the "positive statement of empirical reality" that spamming works. You're probably right. And you're under no obligation to acknowledge the ethical issues that those of us with tenderer consciences may have. But when someone responds to that with "please get off the internet", I think they've got a point, just as they would have if you'd suggested that startups should lie to their customers, or sell addictive drugs to children, or dump poisonous byproducts into the local water supply, in order to increase their profits. It might "perform better". It might happen not to be illegal. But that still doesn't mean that a reasonable person should be recommending it.
- khafra 15y agoFor me personally, I don't mind a lot of autoconfig and getting signed up for stuff by default. It demonstrates the value of a new service in a tangible way, If I don't like it, I can un-sign-up, and if that doesn't work I can filter spam. What I do mind is services that automatically communicate in any way whatsoever with other people on my behalf. I don't mind having a social graph, but I want to be able to place and maintain graph cuts. I think as experiences like Take This Lollipop become more popular, more people are going to think like me.
- fredBuddemeyer 15y agogiven two competing anythings the one that plays most aggressively wins in the short run (see ww2) but these tactics usually turn out to be short lived crutches. the path of user choice and openness (which starts with emptiness) is not going to win an a/b test but in the long run is likely to win the war. and its going to force you to come up with something genuinely compelling.
- viscanti 15y agoAt the end of the day a web app can do one of three things. It can delight it's users, it can exist and nobody cares or it can annoy it's users. It's helpful for companies to think before they act. Is this action going to delight, annoy or have no impact? The companies that choose to delight their users will win over time. Delighted users tell their friends, which is the biggest form of social proof. Too many companies choose perceived short-term gains at the cost of annoying their users. That's not a long-term winning strategy.
- tptacek 15y agoThis comment appears to be orthogonal to the discussion, which is rooted in a comment that says aggressive auto-follow (EAFP) is likely to outperform asking permission (LBYL). Facebook is not an LBYL company, nor is Google, and Facebook and Google are crushing the social space. What may be the case is that normal people are in fact delighted by the EAFP approach, and that the opinions of nerds are irrelevant.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- edanm 15y agoSounds good. But do you have any evidence that that's true? You're making pretty bold statements. patio11's statements are very easy to back up.