6 ms·
Ten sounds like a nightmare for working parents. Eight seems like a completely reasonable start time to me, yet this law prevents that. Schools should be able t
by giantg2 4y ago
Ten sounds like a nightmare for working parents. Eight seems like a completely reasonable start time to me, yet this law prevents that. Schools should be able to decide for themselves based off of the parents and what works for those in the district.
- feet 4y agoThat's because the law is based around what's been observed behaviorally/biologically. Not what's good for working parents Schools shouldn't be forcing developing humans into a schedule that impairs their ability to learn and function, no matter what they want to decide
- koolba 4y agoIf they do enough physical and mental labor during the day and turn off their smart phones at night, they’ll have no issue going to sleep early enough. On the other hand if you do nothing mentally stimulating or physically tiring all day long, then of course you won’t be able to sleep till late.
- KMag 4y agoThat's no joke. I did tree removal for a few weeks one Summer while waiting for my Summer camp counselling job to start. I slept a solid 10 hours every night and felt awesome every morning. "Guiltless sleep of the righteous" and all of that. If they could bottle that sleep in a pill without having to drag downed trees all day, it would be crazy addictive.
- heretogetout 4y agoHave you read the relevant research on the subject?
- crooked-v 4y agoTeenagers literally have different sleep rhythms than either children or adults, so in the average case staying up late is a symptom, not a cause.
- feet 4y agoITT: people who haven't read the research decide they know what is best based on personal anecdote
- Salgat 4y agoI'd rather just stick to what studies find as best instead of anecdotes about needing to physically exhaust children to force them into the desired sleep schedule. Also there's research showing humans have varying natural times they ideally sleep at, and they suffer outside those hours.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> physical labor during the day You heard it boys and girls, back to ploughing the fields it is!
- feet 4y agoI'm hearing child labor is coming back in vogue in the US!
- giantg2 4y agoWhat is behaviorally/biologically beneficial varies by individual. Societal life should be a factor as that does factor into the holistic well-being of the student. Not just some myopic rule about start times that negatively impacts everything else (after school activities, jobs, parent schedules, etc). "Schools shouldn't be forcing developing humans into a schedule that impairs their ability to learn and function, no matter what they want to decide" If you actually believe that, then you have to be against this law. Any schedule will negatively affect someone. A later schedule would have been terrible for me.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> A later schedule would have been terrible for me. Me too. I have always been an early riser, early sleeper. Forcing me to go to school later in the day would have been awful.
- least 4y agoIn what way would it have been awful? Even if you shifted schools several hours ahead of your wake time, it just means that you have more time in the morning and less time in the afternoon, but still well within your normal hours. I think the goal of these sorts of policies is to increase the breadth of students which can benefit from you know, actually being well rested inside school hours. A person that sleeps later and wakes up later (which studies that justify these sorts of policies indicates teenagers largely are) would benefit from a later start time.
- least 4y ago> What is behaviorally/biologically beneficial varies by individual. As someone that has sleep issues that deviate vastly from the norm, I empathize with this point, but it doesn't really mean much when it comes to designing policy, which is supposed to serve its demographic broadly. > Societal life should be a factor as that does factor into the holistic well-being of the student. Not just some myopic rule about start times that negatively impacts everything else (after school activities, jobs, parent schedules, etc). The rule being set by the state or by the local school district is hardly of consequence. You're okay with painting broad strokes about parents' lives but then make an argument about individual students. > If you actually believe that, then you have to be against this law. Any schedule will negatively affect someone. A later schedule would have been terrible for me. Unless you're suggesting that the start times be adjusted to cater to every single individual's needs, this is just pointing out that the start time the school you attended coincided with what worked for you personally.
- gnopgnip 4y agoBut if all schools have to start later, employers will need to work around that
- wccrawford 4y agoNo they won't. They'll still keep their same schedule, and parents will have to figure out how to deal with it. Some don't have family members that can help, and some enterprising daycares will open up early for school kids to deal with them before school. Of course, the buses won't run that early, so only well-to-do parents will be able to use those daycares in the first place, leaving poor parents even worse off than they were before.
- giantg2 4y agoSome might. I bet many won't. Good luck doing business with the east coast if your office doesn't open until 11 am pacific.
- guelo 4y agoDon't working parents already have a nightmare with school day ending around 2pm? This would just shift some of that nightmare from afternoon to morning.
- freedomben 4y agonot really, it doubles it. Instead of having to arrange for care/transportation/etc once for a few hours in the afternoon, now you have to arrange for it twice for an hour or two in the morning and an hour or two in the afternoon.
- bluGill 4y agoThey already have daycare picking the kids up. Now they have to drop the kids off, and the kids can't really do anything at daycare because they are quickly getting into the bus to get to school, then when off school there is less time to do anything before their parents pick them up again.
- imadethis 4y agoNo high school student is going to daycare though, and this law is specifically for high school students.
- barry-cotter 4y agoIt’s not an analogy. One of school’s main purposes along with sorting and ranking and reducing their tendency to creativity and independent thought is day care.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoand getting them to sitdown, shut up and follow instructions without questioning the boss.
- giantg2 4y agoThis is a bit anti-DEI. Special needs and kids with behavioral issues do need that. Now they would need it twice a day.
- iso1631 4y agoWhy? We're talking high schools - which I believe in the US is about age 15 onwards, nothing to do with parents
- giantg2 4y agoHow do you think this has nothing to do with parents? You do realize that 14-17 is still a minor?
- iso1631 4y agoIf your 14 year old is not capable of sorting themselves out for a couple of hours you've failed as a parent, and your idea that a 17 year old needs a parent to wipe their bottom is hilarious?! Do you think something magically happens on their 18th birthday?
- dang 4y agoPlease don't post in the flamewar style to HN. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- alar44 4y agoAnd are fully capable of walking, riding bikes, or waiting for the bus on their own. The permanent infantilization of America is fucking insane and dangerous.
- giantg2 4y agoParents get forced into it due to the laws and societal expectations (juries/civil cases). Guess who can go to jail if their teenage kid doesn't go to school? Fix that law, and then we can start talking about these.
- elil17 4y agoYes we should fix those laws. But now most schools let you stay late, no reason they won’t be able to let you come earlier for those who need it.
- eikenberry 4y agoI work remotely and start my day at 10am. I've done this for years and the only reason I ever got up early was to drive kids to school. As a working parent starting at 8 was a nightmare for my wife (who works similar hours) and I. We alternated so neither of us would be to sleep deprived as it's really hard to get back to sleep after driving your kids to school. It's to late to help us.. my youngest just turned 16 and will be able to drive themself to school next year and we'll finally get decent sleep during the school year. But this would be a big boon to lots of people.
- throwaway2016a 4y agoWhile as a parent myself I agree but this is high school. Generally speaking someone who's 13 or older should be able to make their way onto a bus without an adult. When I was that age (granted this was the 90s) I had a key to the house and was trusted to let myself in when I got back. What's worse is the end of day. My kid is younger and I need to be at the bus stop at 3:50 PM every day to meet her.
- WalterBright 4y ago> 13 or older Jeez, we've really infantilized our kids.
- daveoc64 4y agoWell, yes, we do tend to treat children as children.
- pc86 4y agoWhat's infantilizing about recognizing that most people attending high school are 13 or older?
- throwaway2016a 4y agoReally late reply but exactly this. I said 13 because this was an article about highschool, which for most people starts at 13. Though, with that said, I don't know what is the youngest age I could generalize it with. Depends so much on the maturity of the child and also how far where you live is from the bus stop. But I think it is safe to say that age is equal to or less than 13.
- jghn 4y agoI walked by myself a quarter mile to kindergarten. I walked by myself to a bus stop through the rest of my school days until myself & friends started driving. Most of those years I came home to an empty house at the end of the school day. Not sure why this is a big deal. Kids can manage on their own.
- elil17 4y agoSchools ending at 3 pm is also a nightmare for working parents. But most high schoolers can get on the bus themselves. After care, sports exists in many places for those that can’t/whose parents are against it. Now you can just move some of those after school activities before school for kids whose parents won’t let them take the bus themselves.
- cortesoft 4y agoYou can have before school programs for people who have to get their kids to school early. It can replace after school care
- uoaei 4y agoPlenty of things "should" happen but the systemic problem that if solved would alleviate these issues is to make sure people live near enough to good schools to elide the need for driving children to school in the first place.