3 ms·
No, it means that Obamacare is working as written[1]. Insurer profit margins are set to the legally permitted ((medical bills) * 15%) - operating costs. If ins
by vkou 4y ago
No, it means that Obamacare is working as written[1]. Insurer profit margins are set to the legally permitted ((medical bills) * 15%) - operating costs.
If insurers want to make more money, they can either make medical bills more expensive, or reduce their own operating costs. Reducing the cost of medical bills does not increase the amount of money they make, unless it means they are capturing market share from a competitor.
The problem is that it's nearly-impossible to capture market share. Which insurer do I have? The one that work provides. Did I have any choice in it? No. Did I choose my workplace based on the insurer bundled with it? No. Will my workplace ever switch their insurer provider of choice? Almost certainly 'no'.
How do you capture market share, when all of your customers, and all of your competitors' customers are captives?
[1] Whether or not it was written well is another question.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIt does if it results in them being able to sell policies at lower premiums than their competitors and hence earn more customers. > Will my workplace ever switch their insurer provider of choice? Almost certainly 'no'. Why not? I am an employer and we evaluate the cost of health insurance every year. It is a huge expense, so why would we not shop around?
- vkou 4y ago> It is a huge expense, so why would we not shop around? Because switching to a different provider can be a huge pain in the ass to your employees, whose multi-year treatments/doctors/etc may suddenly become out of network? And it's probably not worth doing unless the cost delta is truly staggering?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat goes for switching any almost vendor. But it does give insurers an incentive to not runaway with pricing.
- mypalmike 4y agoI agree with many of your points. But in terms of employers switching plans, I've experienced such changes several times as an employee of different companies. It's not particularly inconvenient to a business to switch insurers, though it certainly can be to the employees.
- spaetzleesser 4y ago“Will my workplace ever switch their insurer provider of choice? Almost certainly 'no'.” They totally do that if they save money. They won’t do it to help you but for their own bottom line they will do it.