2 ms·
The danger, as I see it, is that this case exists at all. The facts of the case are the state supreme court saying "our constitution doesn't allow you to gerrym
by jfengel 4y ago
The danger, as I see it, is that this case exists at all. The facts of the case are the state supreme court saying "our constitution doesn't allow you to gerrymander on partisan grounds" and the legislature saying "we can gerrymander as partisan-ly as we want". There's no fig leaf that this is somehow fair or reasonable. The contention is that they're legally allowed to, and therefore they will.
With that as the case, it feels like it hardly matters what the Supreme Court decides. It means that the laws of this nation are no longer about what's best for it, but about what we can force each other to do.
That won't be fixed, no matter what the decision is. And it's not the fault of the legislators, either. They are implementing what their constituents want. They will, almost certainly, be returned to office, especially if they succeed in court.
I would very much like the Court to stem the consequences of this, but they cannot fix the core problem. And I'll be blunt that I don't believe the Court has any interest in stemming the consequences, either -- for exactly the reason that I'm talking about.