2 ms·
As someone from one of the countries on Noah’s chart, I hate this attitude. It epitomizes allowing perfect to be the enemy of good. Indonesia’s development isn
by rayiner 4y ago
As someone from one of the countries on Noah’s chart, I hate this attitude. It epitomizes allowing perfect to be the enemy of good.
Indonesia’s development isn’t just those in power “choosing winners.” Indonesia’s under 5 mortality rate has dropped from 400 in 1,000 in 1950 to 23 per 1,000 today. You can’t achieve that just from top-down redistribution.
For the same reason, it’s an “amazing development story” even if there’s still lots of desperately poor people in villages. My dad’s village in Bangladesh is still poor, but the school has walls now, unlike when he was a kid when it was just a roof. He was complaining the other day that “kids these days don’t know what it’s like to take a boat to school during monsoon” because drainage projects addressed annual flooding.
For developing countries, it’s so incredibly hard to get a system in place that merely makes progress. 99% of approaches to making progress simply don’t work. Shitting all over a system that is making progress, however unequal and flawed, is bad. Do you need a quasi dictator to enable development, like in Chile, Singapore, and Korea? Do you need growing inequality, like America’s own industrial revolution? All that is fine! Millions of kids’ lives will be saved from that in the long run.
- refurb 4y agoThat seems to be a common theme among the ever pessimistic crowd online. Progress is never perfect and course corrections need to be made constantly. But the improvement in the QOL among many SE Asian countries is truly remarkable. People have gone from subsistence living where starvation is a real threat to a low income life where basic medical care, housing and food is a given for most of the population.
- neurostimulant 4y agoI grew up with no electricity and telegram being the fastest way to communicate with families living on other islands. Now my village has fiber-optics internet (my parents still live there), and the city where I live now will have a high speed rails soon.