5 ms·
Is this really a complaint that a single, well-established Russian ad company got the same information from Google that they would give to any US company with a
by pessimizer 4y ago
Is this really a complaint that a single, well-established Russian ad company got the same information from Google that they would give to any US company with an email address?
This is part of the cognitive dissonance that insists that Russia has the most effective intelligence services in the world, that can manipulate elections at will and subsume every US social movement to spread its propaganda, but is too stupid and helpless to create a US front company.
- balderdash 4y agoSo your argument is that companies and people should not follow the law or do what’s right because people can circumvent their efforts?! “Why’d you sell vodka to that 12 year old? Ahh well it’s trivial for them to go out and get a fake ID…so I don’t bother checking ID”
- pretdl 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Nextgrid 4y agoMaybe his argument is that spyware should be illegal, regardless of whether the operator is US or Russia.
- encryptluks2 4y agoI mean to be fair you sound like the type that if they made homosexuality illegal that you'd be the first to start reporting people cause you don't care of the crime makes sense only that it is illegal.
- _uy6i 4y agoGuess you just ignored the “do what’s right” part of my comment, that’s convenient. So please explain to me what part of a law that prohibits people from doing business with a Russian state owned enterprise doesn’t make sense?
- encryptluks2 4y agoI could go on a tangent about how the US makes anti-BDS laws, but the reality is that sanctioned companies are not easy to follow and track, and Google ceased doing business as soon as they were alerted. You're hyperbolic statement indicated that you only cared about what was illegal, not whether they were making legitimate efforts to follow the laws. However, sanctions don't necessarily indicate a moral implication... merely a political one.
- jaywalk 4y agoThis company was explicitly sanctioned, which means American companies are not allowed to do business with them. So yes, it's really a complaint. Sure we can't catch everything, but we can at least stop the obvious stuff like this.
- killjoywashere 4y agoI suspect Google's buganizer is now tracking an issue "Automate sanction discovery and response."
- serf 4y agosanction adherence isn't some new concept to a group like Google.
- burkaman 4y agoNo, the complaint is that it was illegal to work with them. > RuTarget was later listed in an April 6 Treasury announcement that imposed full blocking sanctions on Sberbank and other Russian entities and people. The sanctions mean U.S. individuals and entities are not supposed to conduct business with RuTarget or Sberbank. > [Google spokesperson Michael Aciman] acknowledged the Russian company was still receiving user and ad buying data from Google before being alerted by ProPublica and Adalytics.
- tut-urut-utut 4y agoGoogle has a deep issue here. It shows again and again that they aren't concerned about legalese. - don't check if their customer is on the sanctions list. - make it possible for their GA users to ignore GDPR - knowingly ignore tax regulations to own benefit - many other illegal practices / dark patterns / monopolistic behaviour At this point, it's clear that Google being Google is not going to change of itself, as long as it is allowed to proceed like this. The only solution is to regulate Google and force it to comply with legal systems, using billion dollar fines if nothing else works, and splitting Google to avoid further monopolization.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoIndeed, I am thinking what will stop Google selling data to a shell company registered in Cayman islands with unknown beneficiaries. this is just so easy, we have noone to blame but ourselves
- daniel_reetz 4y agoYou don't need to create a front company if you can simply buy the data. That's shrewd, not stupid and helpless.
- ShivShankaran 4y ago> that can manipulate elections at will and subsume every US social movement to spread its propaganda, but is too stupid and helpless to create a US front company The first chapter of "Propaganda" is that the enemy is cunning and wicked while also weak and helpless at the same time. It's also weird that Russia has been running out of ammunition for the last 5 years and is a weak enemy at the same time its able to fight a country supported by virtually the whole of west with NATO arms, NATO training and best of all NATO intelligence/spies with a sanction that was supposed to turn the "ruble" in to "rubble"
- actionfromafar 4y agoIt's not strange. I had deep respect and even some fear of the Russian Army for what it could potentially do to my country. That fear is now largely gone for me. If they can't blitzkrieg the Ukraine, good luck coming here. It would be hell of course, but we could keep them at bay. "The west" have supported the Ukraine, but only really with a trickle of arms compared to its resources in reserve. The combined air forces alone of the west would totally mop up the Russian forces at this stage of the war. The santions have driven up the Ruble, true, but how much is really transacted with that Ruble? It's also problematic to have a strong currency. Russian soldiers are for some strange reason paid a war risk premium calculated in dollar equivalents, which means less rubles when exchanged at the current rate.
- stefan_ 4y agoAs far as I can tell you have entirely made up that claim. Nobody says that at all. What's going on?