10 ms·
Found: The 'holy grail of catalysis'– turning methane into methanol
- dotancohen 4y agoApparently the technique works at close to standard temperature and pressure. Considering that the Sabatier process can be run off water and electricity, and desalination can be done with sunlight, we have all the puzzle pieces for converting seawater to methanol via solar power. The chemical byproduct is oxygen, itself very a very useful element though difficult to compress and store. Even if the byproduct O2 is released to the atmosphere this looks very promising.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoI have a tangential question: > "The process is 100% selective—meaning there is no undesirable by-product—comparable with methane monooxygenase, which is the enzyme in nature for this process." It seems like it should be pretty easy to get any given enzyme mass-produced. What is the reason we're not just growing a bunch of methane monooxygenase and using it to convert methane?
- Gordonjcp 4y ago> What is the reason we're not just growing a bunch of methane monooxygenase and using it to convert methane? Probably the same as every other eco-friendly "get rich quick" scheme - the precursors are relentlessly unpleasant. "So all you need to do is take your water and yeast and cellulose and put it into a container, then slowly add the uranobenzene and methylated lead, bubble some nickel carbonyl through it, and gently warm it up to 900°C..."
- MarcoZavala 4y ago
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> "So all you need to do is take your water and yeast and cellulose and put it into a container, then slowly add the uranobenzene and methylated lead, bubble some nickel carbonyl through it, and gently warm it up to 900°C..." It seems like a safe bet that production and use of an organic protein are best accomplished at temperature ranges normally maintained by whatever life forms naturally produce it.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoYeah, but this is what the workup always seems to read like :-)
- Akronymus 4y ago> "So all you need to do is take your water and yeast and cellulose and put it into a container, then slowly add the uranobenzene and methylated lead, bubble some nickel carbonyl through it, and gently warm it up to 900°C..." That makes me think of this quote: "The heater was warmed to approximately 700C. The heater block glowed a dull red color, observable with room lights turned off. The ballast tank was filled to 300 torr with oxygen, and fluorine was added until the total pressure was 901 torr. . ." from: https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/things-i-won-t-work-dioxygen-difluoride https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/things-i-won-t-wor...
- less_less 4y agoEven if you can mass-produce an enzyme and its necessary cofactors, it might not be easy to use it in an industrial setting. Some enzymes need a very particular environment to be stable (pH, temperature, salinity etc) or can be destroyed by side-reactions with other things in your tank. Some work only when bound to particular cellular components (e.g. the cell membrane). If they need energy to work then it's probably as ATP or NADPH, so you'd have to somehow supply that in your bioreactor. And of course you have to keep the whole tank sterile without damaging the enzyme. These problems notably plague attempts to use the even-holier grail of nitrogenases, basically enzymes for synthesizing ammonia using N2 and water. The current standard process for industrially fixing nitrogen (the Haber-Bosch process) is energy-inefficient and uses about 1-2% of the world's total energy supply, mostly in the form of natural gas. So significantly reducing its energy usage would be a huge deal, but we haven't been able to do it, nor do we fully understand how nitrogenases even work. You could also try to culture bacteria that do the whole process and maintain the enzymes for you. In the case of methanol synthesis though, even if you could do this you'd have to keep tes culture alive and working 24/7 at a remote industrial site. A flare stack is a lot simpler.
- bongobingo1 4y agoAre we likely to discover in (* x 10) years that an over saturation of O2 in the atmosphere is damaging in some kind of way, on a global scale? AFAIK breathing pure O (or O2? Not a chemist) isn't great for your health?
- abirch 4y agoMedical oxygen tanks are over 85%. That said everything would be more flammable.
- rileyphone 4y agoSuch a high level makes the terrifyingly large insects of the dinosaur era possible again
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoHere's a funny posting by the Terminix (bug spray) folks: https://www.terminix.com/blog/bug-facts/giant-prehistoric-bugs-were-glad-are-extinct/ https://www.terminix.com/blog/bug-facts/giant-prehistoric-bu... It was actually before dinosaurs (Devonian and Cambrian Periods).
- thaumasiotes 4y agoProbably not. Those large insects and other bugs could flourish because they didn't have effective competition. But increasing the oxygen level today isn't going to remove the ecosystem that prevents giant bugs from developing again. Analogously, there's nothing about the atmosphere preventing giant ground sloths from existing, but they nevertheless can't exist because they're not compatible with humans.
- ncmncm 4y agoThey can't exist because they were exterminated in the comet strike of 10,818 BCE. We don't know whether they would have coexisted with us. E.g., hippo population in Columbia is exploding. Megatherium sp. coexisted with hunter-gatherer humans for at least thousands of years. Horses and camels can coexist with humans. They too were obliterated in the Americas by the comet strike. But we anyway know people did hunt all of them, before that.
- abirch 4y agoIf you happen to have an article of converting sea water to methane, please post. My searches bring back methane dissolved in sea water and I'm curious where the carbon originates.
- gpcr1949 4y agoi think parent refers to the sabatier process, so the source of carbon is concentrated CO2 externally provided, not from seawater
- hannob 4y agoYou're converting Sea water to water (desalination) and then do electrolysis to get H2. You need to get CO2 from somewhere, you can use Direct Air Capture technology to get it from the air. Then you do this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabatier_reaction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabatier_reaction This is all known technology, the problem is it's not very efficient. Ultimately the discussion in climate tech circles these days is usually that most people think you'll rarely ever do this. Whenever you can you'll use something more direct, like using Hydrogen directly as an energy carrier.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoI love promoting the fact that RF (13.56 MHz) can directly electrolyze saltwater without electrodes (and without desalination). The process was discovered by an amateur radio technician and it was treated like pseudoscience because of breathless local news coverage that made it sound like it was a fuel source. The YouTube video (“burning saltwater”) is a classic—but there still isn’t a proper study on the efficiency of the process. (The radio technician, John Kanzius, died of cancer). https://youtu.be/Tf4gOS8aoFk https://youtu.be/Tf4gOS8aoFk Edit: here is a scientific paper characterizing the process, which is pretty interesting. No calculation of efficiency, however. https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0963-0252/22/1/015010/meta?casa_token=EfNq4b4UMIsAAAAA:Sdsa3oBsFnR8sIGqTwVM5ejRqm_wziykIAGivV4-wN6hxMHvqoMZgJC2-TTmN5VHYW5Sj_0E4A https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0963-0252/22/1/01...
- 4y ago
- hannob 4y agoWe already have all the ingredients to turn CO2+H2 into Methanol without an intermediate step turning it into Methane. There are already a few production plants, e.g. one by Carbon Recycling International. It's not super efficient, but I am pretty sure you're not going to improve that by introducing an intermediate step.
- ascar 4y ago> It's not super efficient, but I am pretty sure you're not going to improve that by introducing an intermediate step. What's the foundation of that argument? An intermediate step that's achieved more efficiently and allows for a more efficient follow-up certainly can improve the efficiency of the overall process compared to one with less steps?
- ABCLAW 4y agoMost chemical synthesis steps produce side products. More steps means more %yield loss. If it's possible you go from A->B at 80% efficiency. If we compare this with A->C then C->B need to be nearly twice as efficient to provide a better yield. Remember these steps include losses due to non chemical reasons. You might have issues with your reactors or transferring the solution to a new reaction chamber might incur losses, etc. In most complex organic synth situations, the full synthesis will be 8-20 steps or so, so we're talking about yields of %efficiency^x. Lowering X helps a ton. In short, the alternate route needs to be really good to justify additional steps.
- criddell 4y ago> I am pretty sure you're not going to improve that by introducing an intermediate step Isn’t that the entire reasons catalysts are so valuable?
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> It's not super efficient, but I am pretty sure you're not going to improve that by introducing an intermediate step. Perhaps we could so with a llittle self-awareness? To come here and simply state that all these PHDs develop a new process while you here rest in certainty that it is doomed to failure. Without demonstrating any understanding of catalysts or anything beyong highschool chemistry. Without presenting any evidence or agument except 'extra step is bad'
- photochemsyn 4y agoTraditional methane-to-methanol with carbon monoxide intermediate (based on steam reforming of natural gas): CH4 + H2O → CO + H2 CO + 2 H2 → CH3OH Direct reduction of CO2 to methanol without going through the methane, an already established technology (Fischer-Tropsch type chemistry): CO2 + 3H2 → CH3OH + H2O Methanol is a common feedstock for further chemical synthesis (such as making high-octane gasoline), so this is an option for fuels from direct air capture of carbon dioxide & electrolysis of water for hydrogen. Two methanol molecules are dehydrated to form dimethyl ether (CH3-O-CH3) as the initial step: > "Methanol can be used to make a gasoline product. The process uses a special zeolite catalyst with pore size such that molecules up to C10 can get out of the catalyst. Larger molecules cannot be made with this process; therefore, a product is made with no carbon molecules greater than C10, which boils in the gasoline range. In this process, aromatics and branched-chain alkanes are made, which means the MTG process produces very high octane gasoline. Gasoline is the only product." https://www.e-education.psu.edu/egee439/node/679 https://www.e-education.psu.edu/egee439/node/679
- adrian_b 4y agoBesides being relatively easy to convert into a gasoline product, methanol is also a convenient fuel for fuel cells, for direct conversion with high efficiency into electrical energy. When used for fuel cells, methanol does not have the storage problems of hydrogen, even if any equipment using methanol must be designed carefully, to avoid any leaks, which are dangerous because methanol is toxic and may cause blindness when ingested or absorbed through the skin.
- AnthonBerg 4y agoPaper: Direct photo-oxidation of methane to methanol over a mono-iron hydroxyl site by An, B., Li, Z., Wang, Z. et al. Published in Nature Materials in June 2022. Publication page: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41563-022-01279-1 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41563-022-01279-1 Digital Object Identifier: https://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41563-022-01279-1 https://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41563-022-01279-1
- HillBates 4y ago
- abirch 4y agoThis would be useful for dairy farmers. Addition revenue for cow farts and greenhouse gas reduction.
- ekianjo 4y agoHow do you collect the methane though ?
- abirch 4y agoI was wrong, the methane capture that exists is methane from the manure. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1077235578 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1077235578
- abirch 4y agoFound this for cows' burps https://www.zelp.co/ https://www.zelp.co/
- bertil 4y agoMost of the current collection is from manure. Methane is lighter than oxygen and azote, so you should be able to collect some at the highest point of an air-tight roof of a cow shed. Not sure how much that would represent compared to manure.
- ncmncm 4y agoRanchers interested in extra revenue would put up solar panels in pasture. Cows keep the weeds down. Future generations will think solar farms in the desert were a dumb idea. But it is easy to get investor money for that, because investors don't know what a poor choice of placement that is.
- astrange 4y agoSolar panels in the desert keep away NIMBYs (sometimes) and are good for the local wildlife by providing shade, especially if you can put them over what water sources there are.
- Sporktacular 4y agoMethane is supposed to be abundant on some planets and moons. Would there be enough light available to turn it into rocket fuel for trips back?
- ekianjo 4y agoNot sure . the amount of sunlight you get decreases with radius^3 and already at mars it gets quite low. Any planet beyond is probably not going to cut it.
- zbrozek 4y agor^2, right? It'd be ~r^3 if vacuum represented significant path loss to light at the kinds of ranges we're talking about.
- ncmncm 4y agoRight. But solar insolation at Mars is, indeed, low, just by the r^2 phenomenon. 40%, IIRC. But you should be able to use perovskite panels and not worry about them getting wet, oxidized, or hot. Those can operate at up to 40% efficiency, gaining back the difference. And, they are very light. You ought to be able to keep dust off electrostatically. Not that anybody will ever live on Mars, or need methane there.
- MobiusHorizons 4y agoMethane is already a viable rocket fuel. I don’t think it would make sense to convert to methanol first.
- perihelions 4y agoMethanol is actually one of the oldest liquid rocket fuels, dating to WW2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C-Stoff https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C-Stoff I don't think it's a very good rocket fuel (it's already partly oxidized, for a start). Clark's Ignition says Nazi wartime shortages were the reason for its addition to C-Stoff -- I'll quote page 13: - "But peroxide is not only a monopropellant, it's also a pretty good oxidizer. And Walter worked out a fuel for it that he called "C-Stoff." (The peroxide itself was called "T-Stoff.") Hydrazine hydrate, N2H4-H2O ignited spontaneously when it came in contact with peroxide (Walter was probably the first propellant man to discover such a phenomenon) and C-Stoff consisted of 30 percent hydrazine hydrate, 57 of methanol, and 13 of water, plus thirty milligrams per liter of copper as potassium cuprocyanide, to act as an ignition and combustion catalyst. The reason for the methanol and the water was the fact that hydrazine hydrate was hard to come by — so hard, in fact, that by the end of the war its percentage in C-Stoff was down to fifteen."
- pseudolus 4y agoA brief description of some of the applications of methanol from the Methanol Institute: https://www.methanol.org/applications/ https://www.methanol.org/applications/
- DennisP 4y agoThings I'm wondering: At scale, could it be cheaper to convert methane to methanol for export, compared to exporting LNG? Would it be difficult to convert chemical plants using methane feedstock to use methanol instead? I'm assuming natural gas power plants wouldn't be convertible, but coal plants maybe would. What would that cost?
- 323 4y agoI think the majority of gas, at least in EU, is burned in residential heating units. Even assuming new burners that would work with methanol, I don't think you could send that through the existing gas pipes.
- andreareina 4y agoIs methanol even safe to burn?
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoWhat do you mean “safe”? methanol + oxygen = water + CO2 + energy This is high school chemistry…
- p_l 4y agoThe exact physics of the reaction impact burner design and how much work is needed to adapt a burner designed for one fuel to another (sometimes impossible even if you're replacing gas with gas).
- Jabbles 4y agoMethanol is highly toxic; it is important to consider how we can make pumping it into people's homes as safe as possible.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 323 4y agoNow we need another step to efficiently convert methanol to ethanol. That would truly be a "holy grail" - from methane gas to alchool :)
- phendrenad2 4y agoCan't wait to sell flatulence vodka to hipsters
- WJW 4y agoHere you go: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2451929419300294 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S245192941...
- aredox 4y agoHere's a BBC report from... 4 years ago. What has changed since then? https://youtu.be/MexeR2VozMA https://youtu.be/MexeR2VozMA
- defrost 4y agoImprovements in efficiency and a change of the MOF catalyst. Here's a better casual news link for the 2017 Lehigh University | Cardiff University work: https://thebrownandwhite.com/2017/10/11/lehigh-cardiff-university-convert-methane-methanol/ https://thebrownandwhite.com/2017/10/11/lehigh-cardiff-unive...
- distantsounds 4y ago
- Barrera 4y agoI'm wondering if the last sentence from the abstract is more of a holy grail than the conversion of methane to methanol: > ... The confinement of mono-iron hydroxyl sites in a porous matrix demonstrates a strategy for C–H bond activation in CH4 to drive the direct photosynthesis of CH3OH. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41563-022-01279-1 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41563-022-01279-1 Selective C-H bond activation (of which this paper is an example) is extremely difficult. It has been the focus of intense research for decades. Having a tunable catalysts system that performed this transformation would be a game-changer for the production of just of about every organic molecule. The authors just focused on methane as the hydrocarbon feedstock, so it's hard to know how general the process might be.
- feet 4y agoThat doesn't sound very selective to me, considering that the CH bonds on methane are all theoretically equivalent. Could you expand on this idea?
- anoxor 4y agoSelective here means it adds a single OH (alcohol group) to methane and not two, there, four. If you keep adding alcohols (otherwise known as oxidation), you would end up with CO2 and waters - the same as burning methane. There is a massive property boon going from methane (gas) to methanol (liquid and easy to transport) and not further
- feet 4y agoIs adding an OH to CH4 energetically equivalent for each successive OH added? Or at least close enough for the difference not to matter?
- adrian_b 4y agoThe first oxidation step, from an alkane, like methane, to an alcohol, like methanol, is always the most difficult, i.e. the least likely to happen spontaneously. The next oxidation steps, from an alcohol to an aldehyde (formaldehyde in this case), then to a carboxylic acid (formic acid in this case), then to carbon dioxide, are much easier to initiate. So doing the oxidation only up to methanol, without losses into more oxidized compounds, is not likely to happen in the absence of a very selective catalyst, like in this case.
- pfdietz 4y agoInteresting. I've got a background mental process looking for results on large volume industrial applications of photochemistry. The reason is that these could provide a market for power beaming from space via lasers (and use of lasers might make power beaming practical on a much smaller scale than with microwaves, due to the much shorter wavelength). The laser light could be used directly in the photochemical process without having to convert it back to electricity.
- HillBates 4y ago
- 0x69420 4y agoso if we fly crop dusters full of catalyst over ranches, can we turn cow farts into disinfectant?
- worik 4y agoPedantically: The methane from cattle comes in burps
- johncearls 4y agoThis is a pretty basic chemistry question, but I thought someone her might be able to give a simple explanation why it seems most of these amazing catalysts are always made from precious metals. Why is it that super expensive things like gold and silver and platinum are always the backbone of these catalysts?
- anoxor 4y agoThe orbitals of the lowest elements on the periodic table are the largest in diameter and most flexible in bonding and rebonding. Their ability to easily make relatively short lived bonds is the key. These metals are often super poisonous for the same reason (heavy metal poisoning). They enter a biological system and effectively randomize a whole lot of bonds and molecules you want to be stable over decades.
- canadaduane 4y agoBy "lowest elements" do you mean elements with lowest atomic number (Hydrogen, Helium, Lithium, etc.), or closest to the bottom of a chart hanging on a wall (Rubinium, Strontium, Yttrium, etc.)?
- selimthegrim 4y agoIt would seem to be the latter, given the reference to heavy metals (they probably mean noble metals more likely)
- ncmncm 4y agoNo. They are contrasting the elements operated on, mostly light elements, with heavier ones used in catalysts that are also toxic, for reasons.
- kurupt213 4y agoNot really. It’s because of the D- orbital configuration of the coinage metal family.
- jmyeet 4y agoMany don't know this but the most important thing to know about solar is that it is so far the only method of direct power generation that exists. Nuclear and various fossil fuels create heat that boils water to generate steam that turns a turbine to generate power. This adds cost and complexity that you can never get away from. But solar by virtue of being direct avoids all of this so has a lower bound in cost that other methods of power generation will find it hard to compete with. Solar cells can be small so solar power is highly flexible. Plus it has no moving parts (other than sometimes solar cells are moved slowly to face the Sun as it moves through the sky) so it's upper bound for reliability is hard to beat. I actually think solar is and will be the most important method of power generation in the coming centuries that will culminate in space-based solar power collectors. So solar has the potential to be extraordinarily cheap, reliable and require no expensive infrastructure like power lines. Creating methanol is essentially a way of storing excess energy so this could be a real game-changer for developing nations that lack such infrastructure.
- jdironman 4y agoAnd even more so if the plants which produce solar products use solar power to offset. I wonder if they do that or not. I'm guessing it's not quiet that simple and distributors of the individual components vary in their methods.
- itsthecourier 4y agoDyson sphere style
- elzbardico 4y agoSolar power is intermittent. This make it far more expensive for practical, real world applications in large scale. Nuclear is the only thing that can realistically substitute fossil fuels. Solar is at best a niche due to the storage needs.
- ncmncm 4y agoThat is of course wholly false. It is why solar farms are going up all over the world, counted in thousands, while nukes are not. Storage is cheap. We have myriad alternatives, according to local requirements. Efficiency used to be a worry, but solar has got so cheap, you just add panels to make up the difference.
- pmcarlton 4y agoThis is very nice chemistry, but as usual for these articles that showcase some breakthrough, there is no net energy accounting of the whole system. How much energy+money is used to make and use the catalyst versus how much is generated, what the break-even point would be, and is it remotely realistic or not for that point to be achieved.
- londons_explore 4y agoCatalysts requiring light typically never make it into industrial processes. They tend to be very slow because they can only act on a surface rather than through the whole volume of material to be reacted.