3 ms·
> If Congress wants the EPA to have this power, let them vote to give it That is precisely what they did. It was called the Clean Air Act, and Congress passed
by woodruffw 4y ago
> If Congress wants the EPA to have this power, let them vote to give it
That is precisely what they did. It was called the Clean Air Act, and Congress passed it in 1963.
SCOTUS's reasoning here is hinky, to use an official legal term: it's clear that Congress has empowered the EPA here, but that SCOTUS finds it easier to claim that they never truly did rather than that they oughtn't to have.
- mlindner 4y ago> That is precisely what they did. It was called the Clean Air Act, and Congress passed it in 1963. Given that the danger of CO2 was completely unknown in 1963 and green energy technologies almost didn't exist. I'm not sure how you can claim that.
- gnulinux 4y ago> Given that the danger of CO2 was completely unknown in 1963 This is a bizarre claim! From https://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/ https://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/ > In 1896, a seminal paper by Swedish scientist Svante Arrhenius first predicted that changes in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels could substantially alter the surface temperature through the greenhouse effect. In 1938, Guy Callendar connected carbon dioxide increases in Earth's atmosphere to global warming. Also read: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_climate_change_science https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_climate_change_sc...
- mlindner 4y agoRather than "completely" maybe it would have been more correct to say "widely". The idea of global warming basically started in the late 60s with a very few scientists talking about it. Rediscovering old previously discredited scientific papers from the late 19th and early 20th century doesn't make it date all the way back to then.
- woodruffw 4y agoThis simply misses the point. Very few laws are restricted to the best science of their day: nearly all allow for administrative interpretation so that the US Government can apply the law without having to relitigate its essential qualities. The CAA empowers the EPA to identify pollutants, and that's what the EPA has (correctly!) done. Whether or not the scientific consensus from the 1960s agrees is immaterial.
- Jcowell 4y ago> This simply misses the point. Very few laws are restricted to the best science of their day: nearly all allow for administrative interpretation so that the US Government can apply the law without having to relitigate its essential qualities. Precisely, if it was the case then arms of the second amendment wouldn’t apply to modern day firearms.
- _uy6i 4y agoMaybe, or one could argue that the second amendment applies to the most modern and capable arms of the day e.g. the musket of the time = an assault rifle today Don’t want to talk guns, but want to illustrate the challenges of making such claims
- woodruffw 4y agoWhy would the Second Amendment be interpreted in that way and the CAA not be allowed similar breadth in interpreting what is a pollutant? The latter is actually explicit in this regard; the former has been constructed through judicial interpretation.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoNo one was talking about CO2 in 1963 other than a few scientists. It didn't reach critical mass until the late 80s. The law was written for known pollutants at the time. Congress is just going to have to add to the powers of the EPA, it's as simple as that.
- pavlov 4y agoDid the text of the Clean Air Act explicitly say it applies only to pollutants known in 1963? If laws can’t be interpreted to account for new circumstances, then it must be legal to pay to have someone killed as long as you use Bitcoin — after all the law didn’t specifically ban the use of Bitcoin.
- woodruffw 4y agoOur understanding of the greenhouse effect dates back to the 19th century. Section 202(a)(1) is pretty explicit that the law does not limit the pollutants under the low to those known to the legislative body[1]: > The Administrator shall by regulation prescribe (and from time to time revise) in accordance with the provisions of this section, standards applicable to the emission of any air pollutant from any class or classes of new motor vehicles or new motor vehicle engines, which in his judgment cause, or contribute to, air pollution which may reasonably be anticipated to endanger public health or welfare. Edit: In other words: even if we could show that Congress was unaware of CO2's effect on the environment, it simply doesn't matter. The Act empowers the EPA to identify and address the pollutants. [1]: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/7521 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/7521
- oliwarner 4y agoCan't wait to see your face when you read what the Second Amendment allows.
- taylodl 4y agoYou can pry my flint locked muzzle loader out of my cold dead hands! :)
- _uy6i 4y agoI don’t think an originalist would take this view. To use hyperbole, I don’t think anyone intended the bill to empower the epa to shut down the energy industry.
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is sort of out of scope of originalism: it concerns an Act of Congress that delivers power to the Executive, not the contents of the minds of the Framers of the Constitution. The Framers perhaps didn’t expect a large Federal Government to begin with, but the cat is out of the bag on that one (and is not consistent with SCOTUS’s actual ruling here). The bill is clearly not intended to “shut down” anything. It empowers the EPA to protect the quality of the air that we all breathe, and that’s how it was applied. If coal power plants need to externalize their pollution to be financially viable, that says more about our failures to preempt the situation than some kind of bloodthirsty plot on the EPA’s part.
- balderdash 4y agoLook I’m all for addressing climate change head on. But I guess at the end of the day I just see this as regulatory overreach. Can one squint and see the rationale, definitely. But my simplistic mind sees the original intent of the bill as a way to protect against substances that are physically poisonous/harmful (radon, arsenic, etc). It was not intended to regulate safe emissions (co2) (that creates harm by increasing severe weather events/changing climate). If were to make a hyperbolic argument, it seems you could stop cement making, cattle ranching, and limit population control based on the EPAs interpretation of CO2 as a pollutant.
- hackeraccount 4y agoWhy did congress consider (and then not pass) a bill that would have done all the things (such as cap and trade) that the EPA then went on to do? Clearly Congress itself thought there was a law needed - that the EPA didn't have the authority to do what it went on to try and do.
- vidanay 4y ago> Clearly Congress itself thought there was a law needed Since Congress only considered the law and didn't actually pass it, I would say that they did not think there was a law needed.
- woodruffw 4y agoFor a litany of reasons: * Congress's priorities are not my priorities, your priorities, or even particularly reasonable. * Congress's ability to efficiently pass laws (at least ones that don't involve funding the military or lowering taxes) has consistently declined over the last 30 years. The last 15 years, in particular, have seen incredibly ugly political brinkmanship over basic legislative responsibilities. In other words: there may be abstract votes in favor of new EPA laws but they're difficult (impossible?) to materialize. * Congress may feel it has no particular input to provide to the EPA's administrative interpretation of the law. This is the explanation that strikes me as most salient (even if all others happen to be correct): it's entirely possible that a majority of Congress sees no particular problem with the EPA's policies, and would much prefer to pass the buck and play political games around the EPA rather than actually changing legislation.
- Gibbon1 4y agoIf congress was really unhappy with the EPA's rules they have the power to reign them in. So in this the Supreme court is intruding.