3 ms·
It couldn't possibly be GPS, right? Networks are unreliable, the cars must be able to reach a safe state if the network drops out. They appear to have stopped i
by bee_rider 4y ago
It couldn't possibly be GPS, right? Networks are unreliable, the cars must be able to reach a safe state if the network drops out. They appear to have stopped in the road. If these cars can't safely navigate their way to the side of the road using local sensors, they are wildly, hilariously unsuited for autonomous operation.
> at least a dozen autonomous Chevrolet Bolts from GM Cruise Automation were spotted blocking the intersection at Gough Street and Fulton Street for a couple of hours, according to reddit user seansinha.
There must be something weird about that intersection that is causing a bug.
- yupper32 4y ago> If these cars can't safely navigate their way to the side of the road using local sensors, they are wildly, hilariously unsuited for autonomous operation. You are a lot more confident than me that this isn't the case.
- bee_rider 4y agoOr I could be pessimistic about GPS -- these things are, albeit in limited numbers, on the road and actually being used by customers, right? I guess I'm surprised GPS is so reliable that this isn't a widespread, constant issue, if this is the normal "I lost GPS" behavior.
- carlmr 4y agoIt could be a middle ground kind of thing. The cars have to trust something. For position you have GPS + some interpolation based on your movement sensors + some buildings/streets and maps (also unreliable since construction etc changes a lot, a lot of buildings and intersections look the same, etc). Computers are very far away from understanding where they are from context alone. Hell most humans don't know where they are. So if you have a short GPS outage they will be able to continue navigating due to other sensors, but the longer the GPS outage/issues persist the more unlikely it is that they still know where they are. There should definitely be a safety to drive to the side of the road and wait though.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CTDOCodebases 4y agoCould it be GPS spoofing that is causing this then?
- valdiorn 4y agoMalice, incompetence, all that jazz...
- benj111 4y agoStill. I would expect some kind of sanity check so that they aren't stopping in the middle of the road. If local sensors tell you the road is blocked, fine. But if remote data tells you one thing, and local sensors tell you something else, the fail safe should be pulling over to the side of the road.
- Flankk 4y agoObviously there is no failsafe that pulls the car over, otherwise you would see that the cars had pulled over. This might be annoying on city streets but imagine if it were on the highway. An almost guaranteed 50 car pileup. If history is any guide, this will actually happen in the next few years and be followed by a lawsuit and regulation.
- elpescado 4y agoThat's assuming that there's a space to pull over, which is often not the case on city streets. Especially, when every AV wants to pull over.
- throw_5202 4y agoStopping as close to a curb as possible is still better than stopping in the middle of the line. And much better than stopping on an intersection.
- cmarschner 4y agoYeah they have Lidars for 10s of 1000s of $ mounted and should be able to go for certain distances without GPS. If a GPS outage was designed as failure mode. But it would perhaps be one of the later items on any engineer‘s priority list since it is so reliable.
- bee_rider 4y agoA network failure is, like, the world's most predictable problem though.
- SheinhardtWigCo 4y agoYou've nailed the dirty little secret of the AV industry. Everyone's safety model is underpinned by the ridiculous assumption that a human will be (a) reachable with very high reliability over shitty cellular networks; (b) able to correctly interpret complex situations with extremely limited information; (c) able to resolve safety-critical situations by making planner adjustments, without direct control over steering and acceleration.
- IAmWorried 4y agoWow. I had no idea that these things had such fundamental limitations. I'd feel a lot less safer using one now, to be honest. If you had to estimate, how long would it be before AVs would be able to do all their calculations locally? Is that something that's even under consideration at the time?
- ls15 4y agoIt is probably a chicken-and-egg problem. They need the data from these scenarios, so they can train the local model for later iterations accordingly.
- ricardobayes 4y agoIt's a well-known thing in AV circles that some companies were actually faking their route by hardcoding them for demos etc. Also one shortcut is to use HD map data, and relying on 100k+ LIDAR sensor data that will never will be cost-effective. I know of only a handful of companies that rely on 'cheap' sensor data (cameras/radar) and use real-time calculations.
- xyzzy123 4y agoIf a full time driver earns 25k-50k that's sort of equivalent to every regular taxi and uber having a $500k / $1M driving package onboard already (at 4%), right? I don't know the industry but very naively it doesn't seem to me like $100k really breaks the unit economics? Particularly if volume / learning curve can reduce the price?
- pojzon 4y agoThis is the difference between Tesla and competitors. Tesla cars „can” drive you „safely” without connection to the network. Some say that discard of lidar was a huge mistake by Elon, but he knows very well that this is not the way to go forward.
- snovv_crash 4y agoWhat does lidar have to do with connection to the network? If anything, once GPS goes down, more sensing modalities can only be helpful.