2 ms·
> Wayland is just a part of a rethink of how Linux desktop architecture works, together with Freedesktop standards for things like screen casting or window cont
by smoldesu 4y ago
> Wayland is just a part of a rethink of how Linux desktop architecture works, together with Freedesktop standards for things like screen casting or window control.
Well, that's part of the problem: I think the consensus is that a lot of these solutions are bunk. Wayland doesn't feel like something you'd build a desktop with, it feels like a software API for digital signage or maybe something for an iPad-like UI. This is cool, but shoehorning it into a desktop is a bad idea. The entire desktop space has moved on, Wayland is comparatively low-tech at this point. Quartz is a good example of this. Not only is it more secure than Wayland, it supports features like app indicators and global menus controls. That's a problem. An even bigger problem is that Mutter, the official Wayland implementation, exists exclusively to support GNOME. Other desktop developers are not welcome, instead they're tossed wlroots and told to make do.
Developmentally, I think Wayland is a trainwreck. If it is a "rethink", then it should have been used to design a tablet OS instead of a desktop OS that runs desktop software and supposedly supports legacy features/apps. If you disagree, then maybe you'd enjoy Windows 8, which is a similarly brave reimagining of the future of the desktop.
- DCKing 4y agoIt's fair to point out problems in the general project and philosophy, but I think that's a different conversation. The discussion at hand points to general compatibility problems that have never been promised. Even if Wayland had been a different project with the properties you desire (which at face value seem fair enough), that still wouldn't have delivered anything like the strawman 1:1 Xorg compatibility this blog talks about, nor would it likely have overcome the general messiness and lack of direction on the Linux desktop that's keeping both X11 and non-X11 desktops back.
- amarshall 4y agoMutter is not the “official Wayland implementation”. Wayland has one reference implementation: Weston https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/wayland/weston https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/wayland/weston
- kaba0 4y agoAnd app-indicators, global menu controls can all be implemented as new wayland protocols and after they get accepted by the majority those can appear reliably everywhere (instead of only in Unity, remember?) And I fail to see your point, you are mixing up wayland’s tasks quite a bit here. It is pretty similar to Quartz, in that it is also a compositor (as is every other OS’s display manager by the way, it is time for Linux to also get there)