4 ms·
Wacky trademark idea: Every year, all trademarks are put up for sale by the government. The sale is a sealed bid auction. You can buy your own trademark. If
by londons_explore 4y ago
Wacky trademark idea:
Every year, all trademarks are put up for sale by the government.
The sale is a sealed bid auction. You can buy your own trademark. If you care about your trademark a lot and don't want someone else to buy it, you better bid a lot to be sure you keep it.
Revenue from the sale goes 99% to the previous owner, and 1% as a tax to the government.
Effectively the end result is a "trademark tax", where the tax amount is a fraction of the market value of the trademarks.
- kennywinker 4y agoWhat? If I’m bidding $100 and I have to pay $100 but the person i’m bidding against can bid up to $10000 before they have to pay $100… this will only result in a transfer of trademark when the owning company is defunct. Seems like it helps nobody.
- drdaeman 4y agoAn obvious issue is that one can be bullied by a wealthy competitor by forcing to re-brand and restart all marketing from scratch every year as your old trademark will get snatched from you just because you're not wealthy enough. Similarly, a troll may even try to extort you into paying them to not bid on your trademark (= possibly lose your business).
- keithnz 4y agodoesn't seem too likely, a trademark at $1 million, means if you are the current owner, you'd be out of pocket $10k, and if it is worth 1 million, that shouldn't be a problem. The troll would be out $1 million. Having paid $990k to the current owner. Not that I think it's a good idea....but it's an interesting idea :)
- bruce511 4y agoBut all this idea does is reinforce the conclusion of the article. Big companies with deep pockets get what they want, not by being right, but because the cost of fighting is too high. Using the scheme suggested, any big company can simply buy any trademark they like. Whereas the little guy is now taxed annually just to stay where he is. So a rounding error for Microsoft means I have to pony up some extra tax (10k? 100k?) every year, or lose my small niche trademark? This seems to come up a lot when discussing copyright, patent, or trade mark reforms. There seems to be a desire to reduce the power of say a Disney, but the proposed solution has the exact opposite effect.
- eru 4y ago> Using the scheme suggested, any big company can simply buy any trademark they like. Whereas the little guy is now taxed annually just to stay where he is. Everyone is taxed. The big guys with more valuable trademarks even more.
- mihaic 4y agoSeems interesting actually. Imagine this gets enacted into law: - Corporations put large bids on their competitors products to drive up their bids as well (colluding has to be explicitly forbidden by law). - As the amounts bid only result in a 1% payout, a class of high-interest loans for only the short duration of the bids appears. - One year companies do a mass dump, and let their competitors have their worst inventory. - A "twelve sigma" event happens and Morgan Stanley has to be bailed out because of all the shit loans needing to be repaid on the spot.
- londons_explore 4y agoI imagine the auction system would be designed to not require upfront collateral if bidding on your own trademarks - merely a deposit of the 1% tax. In that market, I don't think anyone would be taking out high interest loans, and the number of competitor bids might be a few hyper-targeted ones, for example trying to take 'whopper' from burger king.
- bruckie 4y agoWacky for sure. :) Not so helpful, though: one of the primary reasons for trademarks is to identify the source of goods and services. This plan would destabilize the link between the source and the goods or services, making it harder for consumers to know who there dealing with.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoLink doesn't really exist too strongly now. If companies can buy and sell trademarks--and give them to companies which may make inferior or different products-- then already the consumer's needs are not forefront.
- mometsi 4y agoA property tax on trademarks isn't a wacky idea, any more than other assets like spectrum or land. Importantly, it should be a second-price auction; the tax is the rent you pay for withholding the trademark from the next-best coalition of potential users. If you are the only one who could reasonably make use of some asset, there's no reason for the tax system to penalize your getting the most out of it.
- cortesoft 4y agoA Vickrey Auction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vickrey_auction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vickrey_auction
- scarface74 4y agoLet’s put a property tax on illiquid equity that employees get in private companies, too. I bet that won’t be appealing to the HN crowd.
- eru 4y agoIn theory, you can tax moustaches. But why would you? Colours that people can differentiate as trademarks as sort-of in fixed supply for any one industry. So similar arguments like those for land value tax (or a tax on spectrum) apply here. Those arguments don't apply for a tax on capital.
- zuminator 4y agoYou come up with an idea for a great tasting chocolate candy. You spend hours in your kitchen after work for years getting the flavor exactly perfect. You share it with friends, they love it. You decide on a name: Ellesbarth's Boutique Chocolates. You trademark it, a month later getting a confirmation letter from USPTO in a gray envelope. You peddle to local shops in the area, it sells out pretty quick. Ellesbarth's becomes a local sensation. You quit your day job and work on it full time. You scale up distribution, eventually reaching about $1 million in annual revenue. It's still a small brand by any means, but it's enough to keep you in comfort. You keep getting letters from people on the east coast who want to order cartons-full. You've thought about signing a larger distribution deal but right now things are perfect for you just the way they are. One day a Hershey's rep calls and offers to buy your entire company for $4 million. You laugh and tell him not interested. You're not holding out for more, you just like the way things are. It's annual trademark auction time. Last year you bid $10,000 to keep your trademark. This year, with sales almost double last years', you're bidding $25K, just to be on the safe side. Next month, as expected, you get the annual letter from USPTO, except this time, the envelope is gold-colored. You open it up. There's a check inside for half a million dollars! Some unknown party bought your trademark. Over the few weeks, you contact your distributor and top retailers to explain to them that Ellesbarth's is no more, you've changed the name to Chubberstone's. But a few of them respond that they've already gotten a fresh shipment of Ellesbarth's. Later you start getting letters complaining that you've changed the taste. Sales plummet. Orders are cancelled. Nobody knows what "Chubberstone's" is, just that Ellesbarth's isn't what it used to be. Payments are due. One day the phone rings. It's the Hershey's rep, asking if you want to sell all your IP... for $250K. ------ TLDR, I'm not keen on the idea of an annual sealed bid trademark auction, could lead to bad outcomes.
- eru 4y agoYou can fix this by giving the current owner the right of first refusal or so?
- zuminator 4y agoIn this scenario the current owner would then have to come up with $505k every year to hold onto their little boutique brand. Or possibly more every year if Hershey's ratcheted up the bid. If they held out more than a few years then even with the terminal payout, they would end up paying more than they would've earned from just giving into Hershey's in the first place.
- bdowling 4y agoThe utility of a trademark is such that when consumers see the mark, they know who the source of the goods or services is. Changing who owns every mark every year would undermine that utility.
- eru 4y agoYou could auction them off for longer. Also the scheme described is just equivalent to a 1% tax on the fair value of a trademark. It doesn't actually force anyone to sell (as long as they can afford the tax).
- someweirdperson 4y agoBrand is not a guarantee for anything today. Product series are traded between companies, or whole companies are being sold/bought. Company A buys B and switches B's products to their own brand while continuing with B's quality, or continues with B's brand while selling traditionally A's products or degrading/improving B's to their own interpretation of quality...
- scarface74 4y agoI wonder would you feel the same way if large companies started buying up trademarks like Firefox, Linux, Apache, Gnu, etc?
- kube-system 4y ago“Gnu, a new brand from Oracle!”
- eru 4y agoAs long as they can afford the tax?
- onion2k 4y agoWould it be worthwhile for Walmart to pay, for example, $20bn to Amazon (and $200m to the government) to force Amazon to rebrand? I think that's probably a yes.
- eru 4y agoWhy wouldn't Amazon just bid higher?
- onion2k 4y agoThe OP suggests a sealed bid auction. That means they wouldn't know how much other parties have bid. There would be no way to guarantee they've put in the highest bid.
- eru 4y agoIn a sealed bid, second price auction, Amazon could just bid approximately infinity every time, and only pay the second highest bid. (Presumably, they wouldn't actually bid infinity, just in case someone else bids infinity-1 as a joke. But they could afford to bid what the Amazon brand is actually worth to them.)
- diffeomorphism 4y agoThat only tells you that it should be worth more than $200m to Amazon that this does not happen. That is nothing different than a yearly tax on holding a trademark. There the obvious issue is that companies can just lie to pay less taxes. Easy solution: let the market decide. You say it is worth X -> If that number is right you should be more than happy to sell for 100X. If you are not happy to sell for that, that means you cheated on your tax. Inb4: But then big companies can just buy you for 100 times your value. ... yeah, and? That is already the case and for many companies (e.g. all of ycombinator funded startups) that is even a goal.
- HWR_14 4y agoI'm not worried about Amazon in such a system (although I can see Amazon trying to buy the name Disney or Walmart). But imagine the startup offered the choice of selling out at a steep discount or having their runway consumed defending the trademark or starting over with a new name. Oculus does well on Kickstarter and has some buzz? Why acquire it when FB can just buy the name and goodwill for a fraction of the cost?
- 7373737373 4y agoCheck out the concept of Harberger taxation: https://notes.andymatuschak.org/z2fu9D3Yrsh5zKQdLsuikBibBeoSHbVp5ZkM https://notes.andymatuschak.org/z2fu9D3Yrsh5zKQdLsuikBibBeoS... > Harberger taxation introduces a scheme in which the owner of a good pays a continuous tax based on the self-assessed value of that good, and at any time, someone else can buy the good from the owner at the taxed price. > The rate of the tax moderates the balance between “allocative efficiency” (i.e. buyers can purchase a good when they value it more than a seller) and “investment efficiency” (i.e. increases in values to both buyer and seller are captured by seller).
- beachy 4y agoThis is like a roulette clause in company ownership by two parties. Either party can request the other to buy them out for, say, $1M. If the other declines, then the first party then has the right to buy the other out for that same amount. Aimed at preventing lame business partners who just squat there, refusing to leave but adding no value.
- EUV071STR48 4y agoTerrible idea. This amplifies turbo capitalism. You'd have to squeeze everything out of a trademark. Otherwise someone else finds out about the potential and bids according to it.
- Someone 4y agoThat’s more “put up for rent” than “for sale”, so the price you would be willing to pay wouldn’t be the total value of the trademark, but the value for a year (typically a lower value) On the other hand, losing the trademark likely would bankrupt you. You’d have to find a new domain, rebrand your website (breaking all bookmarks your users have, links they have in mails you sent them, etc) and social media accounts overnight, repaint all your trucks, refurnish your offices, throw away your company envelopes and letterhead, etc. ⇒ I think this is a good way to kill all business. Also, consider the effect on hiring. “I see you worked at Google. What kind of company was that when you worked there?” or “why did you switch employer so often? I didn’t; ‘Foo’ became ‘Bar’ became ‘Baz’ became ‘Foo’ again”.