2 ms·
Being anti-Hitler and anti-Nazi is 'political' now? They're simply acknowledging the reality that Nazism was an absolute, unmitigated disaster - even, and most
by zozbot234 4y ago
Being anti-Hitler and anti-Nazi is 'political' now? They're simply acknowledging the reality that Nazism was an absolute, unmitigated disaster - even, and most surprisingly, for those who might have foolishly expected to benefit from it. That's what those apologetic attitudes are about. If you really wanted to draft a relevant political message from the whole Nazi thing, it would have to be "how the heck do we avoid falling into this awful trap again". The premise of Downfall is not good for that. The film mostly sticks to the historical sources - the crazy, delusional rants that everyone loves to make memes about actually happened, Hitler really said those things. He was quite weak in those circumstances.
- dragontamer 4y ago> the crazy, delusional rants that everyone loves to make memes about actually happened I'm presuming that you're talking about the "Steiner's Attack" meme/scene from the movie. This scene "actually happened" according to Russian historians, who were writing for a single audience (Stalin). Their testimony is not to be trusted. I agree with you that its part of the historical record, but specifically part of the _RUSSIAN_ historical record. Alas, that's the breaks. Russia captured Berlin with their army before the USA/British forces could. But there's plenty of "political decisions" made with respect to the movie (ie: whether to honor the Russian telling of events, or to focus upon say Traudl Junge's book... which didn't mention this "Hitler flies into a rage over Steiner's Attack"). ------- The Goring Telegram (which was in the movie, but rarely memed) is 100% accepted history IIRC, and probably serves as a better example of how Hitler really acted.
- N1H1L 4y agoAbsolutely it's political. Hitler was a political actor at the end of the day, as a ruler of a nation. And Nazism is a political ideology. Just because we all agree that Nazism is repugnant (and that too is debatable - several far right US organizations are still today pro-Nazi) doesn't make an anti-Nazi film apolitical.