3 ms·
Understanding that you don't know everything about or speak for the industry, the question I've had for a few years now is whether this is a deliberate tactic (
by dredmorbius 4y ago
Understanding that you don't know everything about or speak for the industry, the question I've had for a few years now is whether this is a deliberate tactic (I've little doubt telcos want to shed wireline service), or just a mess with no clear out?
Because the problem's not just with landline but with any direct-dialed PSTN telecoms system. I don't want a landline or mobile phone any more. The situation's well past simple cord-cutting.
It's been about three years since I stumbled across this quote which confirms that at least someone on the inside is aware that the present situation is eroding all trust in the system, and that this is an existential threat:
[S]ince mid-2015, a consortium of engineers from phone carriers and others in the telecom industry have worked on a way to [stop call-spoofing], worried that spam phone calls could eventually endanger the whole system. “We’re getting to the point where nobody trusts the phone network,” says Jim McEachern, principal technologist at the Alliance for Telecommunications Industry Solutions (ATIS.) “When they stop trusting the phone network, they stop using it.”
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/05/how-to-stop-spam-robocalls-with-stir-shaken.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/05/how-to-stop-spam-rob...
(From an earlier HN comment of mine: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21542926 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21542926
Stir-Shake may have reduced levels of spam, I've no way of knowing. But the level it's at remains intolerable and a real financial risk to individuals and businesses. I'm personally aware of several people who've been scammed of thousands of dollars within the past year.
Cut phone service and that threat disappears, along with all the attendant billing bullshit and customer service nightmares.
Is the industry aware of this and what if anything does it plan to do?
- walrus01 4y agomy personal opinion is that there is simply too much legacy SS7/PSTN junk out there to change the protocol/traffic exchange between carriers in any significant way that will result in anything ever being fixed. it's a legacy of the 1950s and 1960s era of the monopoly bell system when all of the phone system trusted itself. the whole way that traffic moves between telcos in the PSTN is built on lack of crypto authentication, total trust between two phone switches, in a way that would be absurdly terrible if run on the modern internet (imagine all your online banking as http only, for example).
- dredmorbius 4y agoAre you aware of any working groups / consortia / skunkworks looking into this? Or have any idea of what a solution-shaped object might resemble? Your answer ... mostly confirms my outsider view. And that story ends poorly. Thanks, regardless.
- walrus01 4y agoMy POV is biased by working only adjacent to ILEC/CLEC/PSTN/SS7 related stuff in telecom, my day job is much more focused on building IP based packet last mile and middle mile ISP stuff for direct internet access.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThanks.
- kjellsbells 4y agoI worked in telco when STIR/SHAKEN was invented. I was in the early sessions with Comcast and AT&T and the rest when they were politely asked by tbe FCC to fix it. Headline: they never had a chance. Conspiracy: they didnt want to. - First of all, the legacy telco network is still out there in huge quantities. This is the copper landline to grandma's house. It speaks SS7 and TDM which have no inherent concept of identity: the tekco switch simply inserts the calling number in the signaling, the end. There is no economic incentive to replace any of this old stuff since there is no marginal revenue to be made. It will rust in place. - the telco network has long supported cases where the caller had a legitimate need to replace their number with another. Your doctor calling you always shows as the office front desk, never their direct line. - this use case gets even worse when you have call centers and other high volume users. Use of VoIP makes the modern call center possible, but also trivially easy to change the calling ID, and again, perfectly legitimately for the businesses that use it. - extra wrinkle: offshore centers. now some agent in India needs to present as if they are calling from Ohio. No problem, VoIP can do that. But the same tech that does that also means their evil twin can call you up from an area code that looks like your town to ask about your car warranty. I could go on, but this is a really hard problem.