2 ms·
"We did, and that's the point." Then why are you misrepresenting it to mean something that it doesn't? Only one house is meant to represent people. "Also, it'
by giantg2 4y ago
"We did, and that's the point."
Then why are you misrepresenting it to mean something that it doesn't? Only one house is meant to represent people.
"Also, it's only contentious to those who are deliberately attempting to gerrymander."
Maybe for the general idea. But I can see implementation ideas being contentious. That's my point - the solutions are likely to contain biases, and there's going to be opposition to that.
"Interesting that that all your counter examples here are about giving people rights to vote. People having the right to vote is fundamental to democracy. Seems your view on democracy is of the 'only the right sort of people should be allowed to vote' variety, pun intended."
Please name a democracy that has unlimited voting rights. All democracies have some limits. Requiring that someone is a citizen is a damn low bar. Losing rights for felonies can be debated, but that's not too uncommon either. The purpose of those most basic restrictions is do that society does not become influenced by the criminal elements (you're banned from office too) or from outside influence. And guess what, those restrictions were democratically implemented. So please stop with the attacks and more righteous than thou attitude. Please state some argument beyond "fundamental".
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y ago>Then why are you misrepresenting it to mean something that it doesn't? I didn't mispresent anything, I've been consistent and clear about my view of the senate. >Please name a democracy that has unlimited voting rights. It's not my position that voting rights should be unlimited. I was only pointing out that your own list of bad things were all about giving people who don't have a say about the government whose rules they must live by, a say in that government by vote. >The purpose of those most basic restrictions is do that society does not become influenced by the criminal elements This is historical laughable, the purpose of most restrictions is to limit the vote of marginalized groups, usually by race. For just one example, Step 1: Pass laws making weed a felony. Step 2: Focus all law enforcement efforts on marginalized groups smoking weed but let the kids in suburbs and college dorms smoke all they want. Step 3: Harshly punish marginalized groups by making them felons. Step 4: Strip them of the right to vote.