16 ms·
Pretty much every culture around the world 100 years ago had some staple fermented food. Nowadays, a lot of people in western culture at least outright refuse y
by asdff 4y ago
Pretty much every culture around the world 100 years ago had some staple fermented food. Nowadays, a lot of people in western culture at least outright refuse yogurt or other fermented foods like saurkraut or pickled cabbage that used to be staples in these people's ancestor's diets a few generations ago. People are becoming even lactose intolerant. You have to fertilize your microbes so to speak and eat these sorts of foods. Plus once you are doing stuff like making your own yogurt, a jug of whole milk works out a lot cheaper than the chobani stuff.
- amarshall 4y ago> You have to fertilize your microbes so to speak and eat these sorts of foods [citation needed]. It seems unlikely that fermented foods are not consumed in urban areas at all. I’ve also no idea if other primates consume any fermented foods, but I’d guess probably not. > People are becoming even lactose intolerant Do any other primates drink milk after infancy? If not, that’s not really a valid concern in the context of the article.
- msbarnett 4y agoNo. In fact, almost all mammals stop producing lactase once they stop nursing from a mother. Humans are quite rare in that there's a significant population with the mutant "lactose tolerant adult" gene.
- bobthepanda 4y agoThe study is of US cities. I would be curious to see if you took, say, South Korean cities, what the results would be. (Seoul is one of the largest megacities in the world, and kimchi is an extremely common fermented food.)
- steve_adams_86 4y agoOne tricky part with fermented foods is that the salty ones appear to increase rates of colon and stomach cancer as I recall. I read something years ago about how as the Japanese population adapted a more western diet, heaps of ailments came upon them as you’d expect, but their salt intake declined so dramatically that they stopped experiencing stroke and GI tract cancers nearly as much. I think you’d need to pin down just how much salt was causing those issues though and then ask if the benefits of the salty fermented foods outweigh the current problem of having depleted gut microbiomes and atrocious diets. So, I’m certainly not suggesting everyone avoid salty fermented foods. I eat (and make) a fair amount myself and as I alluded above, I suspect it’s better for me than eating food that is, on balance, worse for me. There’s no perfect diet, but there are clearly worse diets. I try to avoid the latter.
- f38zf5vdt 4y agoSeems unlikely. A lot of the traditional West African diet is fermented and they have the lowest rates of colon cancer on Earth. Smoked foods and foods containing nitrates/nitrates are correlated with stomach and colon cancer, but not salty or fermented foods. Studies that show a correlation of salt intake with cancer are very possibly confusing intake of smoked meat or processed meat (also high in salt) with colon cancer. For example, when adjusting for processed meat, one study finds that salt is not correlated at all with colon cancer. [1] [1] https://www.clinicalnutritionjournal.com/article/S0261-5614(21)00288-0/fulltext https://www.clinicalnutritionjournal.com/article/S0261-5614(...
- steve_adams_86 4y agoInteresting, thanks for that. I hadn’t seen it yet. Though the rest still stands, and as mentioned in the paper, reducing sodium intake is still recommended for other health benefits. There is a wealth of other research showing that most people in North America should dramatically reduce their sodium intake. > Reduction of processed meat intake may be an effective strategy for CRC prevention, while sodium reduction should still be recommended to achieve other health benefits. Apart from that, I’m still seeing evidence of correlation with stomach cancer, even if not in the lower GI tract: https://www.wcrf.org/salt-shaking-up-the-link-with-stomach-cancer/ https://www.wcrf.org/salt-shaking-up-the-link-with-stomach-c... Given the connection to stomach cancer and cardiovascular disease, it does seem wise to be careful about salt intake. Regarding west African diets, are they high in salted fermented foods or just fermented foods? It seems if the food is low in salt, it’s probably just fine
- lemming 4y agoThere is a wealth of other research showing that most people in North America should dramatically reduce their sodium intake. The evidence for this seems much less conclusive than most people think: https://examine.com/nutrition/awful-nutrition-myths/#summary6 https://examine.com/nutrition/awful-nutrition-myths/#summary.... The tl;dr is that most of that salt comes from crappy food, and that’s what you want to fix - it’s not the salt as such.
- Terry_Roll 4y ago
- ryanianian 4y agoWhat?
- swayvil 4y agoHe's saying that this ubiquitous modern stuff kills gut flora.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoAre you conflating fluoride and chlorine? Or are you gulping water down your throat at swimming pools? If it's the latter then you really should stop doing that.
- teruakohatu 4y agoI am not the OP, but you may not be aware that many, if not most, cities have chlorine added to the tap water. I have read comments on HN about people leaving jugs of water in the fridge so the chlorine is off-gassed.
- Terry_Roll 4y ago
- giardini 4y agoEating yogurt or sauerkraut will not render you (once again) lactose tolerant. Lactase (the enzyme that breaks down lactose) production is regulated by a human gene; how would a probiotic like yogurt alter a gene? https://biologydictionary.net/lactase/ https://biologydictionary.net/lactase/
- barkingcat 4y agoYou could always ingest other bacteria that can digest and break down lactose and rely on probiotics to digest the lactose for you instead of having a gene. That's what ruminents do anyways, you need a steady colony of these helpful bacteria or you lose the tolerance. While that seems troublesome, for many animals that's how metabolism works for their entire life.
- p10_user 4y agoEpigenetic reversal of some inhibitory histone marks at the promoter region of the enzyme? Driven by some yet-to-be-discovered signaling cascade induced by reintroduction of lactose and proliferation of lactose loving microbes? Just spitballing, this is pure speculation, but is plausible.
- easytiger 4y agoI have noticed pseudosciences are becoming fashionable again.
- etiam 4y agoWell, as you probably know, genes are regulated more or less according to environmental cues all the time, including being very much subject to presence and behavior of commensals/parasites/symbionts. I don't know any specific data whatsoever about inducing lactase, but it seems perfectly plausible that microorganisms such as lactic acid bacteria could interact with the system.
- msbarnett 4y agoThis has been studied, but the results tend to argue that it's purely genetic, eg) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6669050/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6669050/ > Studies that have measured changes in endogenous lactase activity after an intervention period consistently show a lack of enzyme induction, suggesting that lactose intake does not affect an individual's lactase activity. Although these studies are scarce and have relatively few subjects, data from cross-sectional studies support the theory of purely genetic regulation
- msbarnett 4y ago> People are becoming even lactose intolerant. This isn't new, and certainly isn't some crisis of the last 100 years. Historically only a minority of the planet has ever been lactase persistent into adulthood. It's a well-understood genetic trait, not some product of gut microbes.
- starwind 4y agoYou are correct. It's likely that the majority of humans have been lactose intolerant for human history. It's primarily people of Northern European descent that are not lactose intolerant, but lactose intolerance is very common outside of those groups
- hprotagonist 4y agoand west african; by two entirely separate mechanisms, which i’ve always found to be quite cool.
- chimeracoder 4y ago> and west african; by two entirely separate mechanisms, which i’ve always found to be quite cool. What's the separate mechanism? I'm only aware of one set of genes coding for adult lactase production.
- hprotagonist 4y agohttps://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17159977/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17159977/
- flir 4y agoI wonder if there's any advantage to inheriting both mechanisms.
- dannyw 4y agoYou can think of this being evolutionary beneficial, if some milk is bad, the whole village don't all get sick. Also a possible reason for why people have different taste preferences.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoLactase persistence is regulated by genetic mutations, not gut microbes. The negative symptoms of lactose intolerance is exactly due to lactose being able to reach the gut and making the microbes there flourish by digesting lactose, creating large quantities of gas and other metabolic byproducts that cause flatulence, diarrhea, etc. People don't spontaneously become lactose intolerant just because they stopped eating something. Koreans eat lots of fermented vegetables, yet why are 70%-100% of Koreans estimated to be lactose intolerant? Why are you suggesting lactose intolerance is some new condition that arose as a product of modern life? Lactose intolerance is simply the default setting for the majority of humans around the world for most of history. Yogurt/kefir occupies very large segments in most developed countries' grocery store shelves and new brands/varieties pop up every year. How has this industry not collapsed if "a lot of people outright refuse yogurt" according to you? The development and marketing of lactose free dairy products in recent years is simply the dairy industry exploring new market segments, because substantial portions of the population do not have lactase persistence. Even societies whose culinary traditions involved heavy consumption of dairy do not have 100% lactase persistence. It's not some weird conspiracy aimed at making modern humans "weak". The lack of lactose is not significant enough to change the nutritional content of dairy products.
- AussieWog93 4y agoHoly shit, that is the most over-the-top, aggressive response to a guy being factually incorrect about yoghurt that I've ever read.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoCan you point exactly which part was "over-the-top" or "aggressive"? Or is calling out that factually incorrect things are, well, factually incorrect somehow unacceptable nowadays? The world needs less pseudoscience misinfo, not more.
- justsomeguy123 4y agoI re-read your post and while it's not overly aggressive it's the difference in tone and approach that get you. The original poster was like the hippie encouraging home-made yogurt and you were like the school principal saying 'this is bull, store yogurt has scientifically the same benefits'. PS: I also learned while writing this I can't spell yogurt. Thanks spellchecker!
- urthor 4y agoZero added sweetener, straight Greek yoghurt. Absolutely sublime. To the typical North American diet it tastes incredibly foreign because the US of A is drenched in sweeteners. But unsweetened foods just taste beautiful once you get used to them.
- asimpletune 4y agoI spent two months in Turkey and can confirm this. The national drink is called Ayran, and it’s not only fantastic tasting and cheap but full of nutrition.
- smackeyacky 4y agoIts amazing the incredible, over the top flavor that highly processed junk food has. Commercial Corn chips and the like are so over flavoured, but you don't notice until you give them up for a while.
- collyw 4y agoEven the fermented food that you mention will not be probiotic if they are commercially bought. Sauerkraut in a jar will be pasteurized. Even probiotic yogurt is supposedly pasteurized then some live culture added after. I make my own kefir and saurkraut for that reason.
- colordrops 4y agoFermented foods are important. Milk-based foods, not so much. There's a reason most people are lactose intolerant - milk is to grow baby cows into large animals, and not suitable for consumption by adult humans.
- corsac 4y ago> milk is to grow baby cows into large animals Whence this transcendent purpose that limits suitability? Likewise, quinoa grains are to grow into full-sized plants, and not for consumption by humans, etc. etc. Most people may be "lactose intolerant", but some of them find ways to survive and thrive on milk-based foods; meanwhile, some populations have developed tolerance to lactose, presumably because milk-based foods are important.
- colordrops 4y agoThere is no need for transcendant purpose. Quinoa intolerance is pretty uncommon, whereas milk intolerance is the norm. Even without a lactose intolerance, there are several health issues with milk consumption, unlike quinoa consumption. That is because we've evolved for a orders of magnitude longer to eat plant material. Yes, some northern European peoples have evolved to be more tolerant of milk. And some tibetans have evolved to live at very high altitudes. It's not a good argument to take a small exceptional population and apply that reasoning to the general case. And this doesn't even get into all the problems with the dairy industry with regards to environmental damage and animal suffering.
- asdff 4y agoBut in this case with this country, that small exceptional worldwide population is overrepresented in our national population. It stands to reason that many people can infact consume lactose in the U.S. given this demographic history. The general case in the context of the U.S. population could very well refer to this population of people historically predisposed to tolerate lactase. And on the other hand, I think there is this false logic at play with the meat/dairy industry as a whole. People assume these interconnected systems are in fact discrete. That we could do away with eating meat and suffer no consequences, in fact even see improvement in our ways of life. I am not so optimistic given how interconnected systems are. For instance, take the cow. Its not just used to derive meat. 99% of the cow is used. The pancreas is used to extract insulin and other factors. Same with the liver, and the pituitary gland. Serum is used for biomedical research applications. The hair is used for products, the hide is used. The fats are used for everything from toothpaste to flooring to crayons. Collagen and gelatin are extracted. I don't even need to go into the uses of the hide, I feel. The bones and blood are used for organic fertilizer, so I'd wager that many organic vegetarian products today actually rely on the cheap organic fertilizers produced by the meat industry versus synthetic sources. On top of that pasture land is often land that is not compatible for traditonal farming, owing to terrain mostly (e.g. Summit county in Colorado sports a lot of ranching versus farming, due to the rocky mountainous terrain being almost impossible to plow but trivial for a grazer to roam on). Could you replace all of the parts of the cow with synthetic sources? Certainly. Would this lead to a net reduction in greenhouse gasses and other environmental externalities replacing each and every of these products with synthetic sources that hopefully aren't any more costly? That I doubt, and it worries me that headlines and other material in the media seem to ignore how all these externalizes will be resolved, assuming it will be an easy transition.