5 ms·
To be honest, this seems like a pretty reasonable search; a warranted search, narrowly scoped in both keywords (a specific address) and timeframe. Meanwhile, t
by ceejayoz 4y ago
To be honest, this seems like a pretty reasonable search; a warranted search, narrowly scoped in both keywords (a specific address) and timeframe.
Meanwhile, this:
> “If Google is allowed or required to turn over information in this Colorado case, there is nothing to stop a court in a state that has outlawed abortion to also require Google to turn over information on that kind of keyword search.”
seems like it's of entirely different magnitude, far less amenable to such a narrow scope.
- matt321 4y agoEveryone agrees preventing criminals from burning people alive is wrong, but some people don't think abortion is wrong so there's grey area there.
- ceejayoz 4y agoSure, but there's still a big scope difference; "who searched for this one address right before it burned down" versus "who searched about abortion; we don't know anything much more specific than that". > Google delivered information on 61 queries, according to court filings, along with the IP address — a unique number for each computer on the internet. Investigators focused on a handful of those queries, asking Google to provide detailed user information for them. One of them was linked to the 17-year-old. That's pretty narrow.
- lin83 4y agoIf the requirement to be narrow and time limited is not codified in law (which afaik it is not) it is pretty much guaranteed such broad searches will happen. All it takes is convincing a judge. If the past has taught us anything it's that law enforcement will use any tool to the maximium of what is allowed and then beyond (e.g. coerced phone searches, racially motivated stop and search, drug dogs to force vehicle searches, privately sourced licence plate tracking and face recognition, criminal DNA testing from rape kits, forced biometric collection and more).
- ceejayoz 4y agoIt is codified, in the Fourth Amendment. > no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized Legally, the term is "particularity".
- chucksta 4y agohttps://www.aclu.org/blog/documents-aclu-case-reveal-more-detail-fbi-attempt-cover-stingray-technology https://www.aclu.org/blog/documents-aclu-case-reveal-more-de... >The FBI's role in the process is a condition of the Federal Communication Commission's equipment authorization issued to the Harris Corporation. The result is that members of the public, judges, and defense attorneys are denied basic information about local cops' use of invasive surveillance gear that can sweep up sensitive location data about hundreds of peoples' cell phones. For example, when we sought information about Stingrays from the Brevard County, Florida, Sheriff's Office, they cited a non-disclosure agreement with a "federal agency" as a basis for withholding all records. When the ACLU of Arizona sued the Tucson Police Department for Stingray records, an FBI agent submitted a declaration invoking the FBI nondisclosure agreement as a reason to keep information secret. Yeah it works really well
- ceejayoz 4y agoStingrays are typically warrantless; a very different scenario than this case. Their very nature makes them pretty broadly scoped, too, impacting anyone in range. (I'm of the opinion they're a Fourth Amendment violation, and quite a few court cases are winding their way through the system. Quite a few judges have already ruled against their warrantless use. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stingray_use_in_United_States_law_enforcement#Legal_cases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stingray_use_in_United_States_...)
- oldjavacoder 4y ago
- 4y ago
- ajsnigrutin 4y ago> seems like it's of entirely different magnitude, far less amenable to such a narrow scope. Why? If the police finds a burnt house, and check who googled for an address... how is that different to them finding an illegal abortion clinic, and checkng who googled for that address?
- ceejayoz 4y ago> If the police finds a burnt house, and check who googled for an address... how is that different to them finding an illegal abortion clinic, and checkng who googled for that address? I don't think that sentence refers to illegal abortion clinics; I think they're referring to state laws that attempt to punish out-of-state abortions (https://www.usnews.com/news/national-news/articles/2022-05-19/out-of-state-bans-threaten-to-extend-the-reach-of-anti-abortion-america-but-some-states-are-preparing https://www.usnews.com/news/national-news/articles/2022-05-1...). That said, a clinic is more like a house that burns down several times daily, which dramatically expands the scope of any such warrant.
- dillondoyle 4y agoWould person ___ searches 'within 2 weeks of last menstruation' be narrow enough? The case of this is fine to me on it's face. But examples like the above are terrifying.
- ceejayoz 4y agoI don’t think that’d be comparably narrow, no.
- dillondoyle 4y agohow about adding specific person Jane Doe searches address ___ of planned parenthood within 2 weeks of last menstruation To me the ultimate problem isn't the scope of the search. It's that the guardrails against partisanship are gone via takeover of law by Republicans and christian crusaders. Attorneys general and judiciaries have huge power and are so lopsided depending on geography and political party in charge. and I don't trust the ultimate Supreme Court to do what's right in the end that it's illegal now is crazy. That is seems likely that they will try to prosecute people (more likely TX style citizen suits) for getting healthcare in a different state is crazier.
- ceejayoz 4y agoPlanned Parenthood provides prenatal care and other non-abortion services. No probable cause.
- smt88 4y agoThat's wishful thinking. Authoritarians who don't respect hundreds of years of precedent aren't suddenly going to draw a bright line at Google searches.
- dillondoyle 4y agoprobable cause doesn't matter when it's individual citizens suing to enforce these draconian laws... Just scary all around imho
- slaymaker1907 4y agoI hope courts require both that the requested search data is very specific to the crime (which you are right, a specific address is specific), and I also think that such requests should be by court order/search warrant. The specificity requirement is most important, but I think law enforcement should not get a blank check to do these sorts of queries. It's a lot harder to convince a judge/jury that a query was too broad after it turned up good evidence compared to rejecting the query before it is run and collected. That's all from a legal perspective. From a policy perspective, I think our search histories should not be collected in the first place as much as practically possible. In meatspace, libraries are actually very protective of what books you look up/checkout. Seattle City Library actually requires you to opt-in for tracking of your checkout history because they know this sort of data is sensitive.