5 ms·
If WWIII started I'm sure the US government would have no qualm about commandeering the ships in US harbours and/or US waters.
by mytailorisrich 4y ago
If WWIII started I'm sure the US government would have no qualm about commandeering the ships in US harbours and/or US waters.
- Retric 4y agoThat’s helpful on day 1, not so much by year 6. It’s vastly faster to start with a small team that knows how to build stuff and expand that team than it is to start completely from scratch. But you can only maintain that knowledge by actually building stuff. So yes it’s inefficient in peacetime, but so is having the worlds most powerful military. It’s silly to spend that kind of money on a military and then leave easily exploitable weakness in our logistics.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoI wouldn’t expect WWIII to last that long. Plus ships are big expensive floating targets of no particular use in a total war between nuclear powers.
- antonymy 4y ago>I wouldn’t expect WWIII to last that long. People said the same about WWI and look how that ended up.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoWWI was fantastically destructive war of 4 short years, which is very short for a war. 'People' always underestimate the cost of war when selling the idea to the public. Imagine if they were realistic then maybe we wouldn't go to war. I'm not suggesting WWIII would be short because someone wins it, just that if a nuclear exchange happens there won't be enough left to keep fighting with.
- Retric 4y agoI think there is some ambiguity here. An India vs Pakistan war could continue after a nuclear exchange as they don’t have that many nuclear weapons to glass each other and survivors would presumably want vengeance. For the US it might take a reasonably effective missile defense system, but that’s not outside the realm of possibility.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoI wouldn't classify India vs Pakistan as a world war. The primary nuclear belligerents would be US and Russia. I wouldn't trust the US military industrial complex to be honest about their missile defence capabilities and it worries me that the west is being so cavalier about possible nuclear war.
- Retric 4y agoTo be clear, I was suggesting an India vs Pakistan nuclear exchange could be part of a much larger conflict. WWII was called a world war because so many countries where involved and WWIII could similarly spiral even without a US vs Russia nuclear exchange. Anyway, I personally don’t believe the US has a highly effective nuclear defense system, but even the possibility of such changes the calculus of war. The more bombs you need to send to each target the fewer targets you can hit. DC and NYC are presumably fucked either way, but Tuscaloosa Alabama could easily survive the second scenario. It’s completely theoretical at this point, but coming up for plausible scenarios where the Jones Act ends up worthwhile doesn’t seem that difficult.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoMy expectation is the coming conflict will be between NATO and a Chinese Russian alliance. The US maintains its current standard of living based on cheap Chinese goods, cheap Russian energy (indirectly) and financialization. I expect that none of those things will survive such a conflict. Even if a city avoids getting nuked what life is left for them. Maybe they could get a job at Foxconn.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoShort term is all that'd be needed. The US economy turned into a war economy would have no problem churning cargo ships if needed. Peacetime subsidies are only useful for capabilities that would be prohibitively costly or long to setup un time of war.
- Retric 4y agoTime is just one dimension here, cost in peacetime is the other dimension. Also the act aids not just in building ships but also managing, maintaining, and crewing them. The skills and lessons learned over time of a domestic industry vs a ~0.2% increase in boat shipping costs is worth considering. Especially as most do these costs relate to paying US workers and US taxes.
- corrral 4y agoTougher to do if you're not at war yet, but the countries pulling your (well, their) cargo ships away are.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoThem and what navy?
- corrral 4y agoI guess you can seize foreign-flagged ships as a non-combatant state, but I expect you'll become a combatant pretty soon, if you do too much of it. Nb these countries reducing availability of (their!) shipping capacity to the US during a war could include allies and neutral countries, not just enemies and likely enemies.