3 ms·
That is incorrect. Congress cannot broadly delegate authority to make rules with the force of law on the executive branch. Even liberals begrudgingly accept sep
by rayiner 4y ago
That is incorrect. Congress cannot broadly delegate authority to make rules with the force of law on the executive branch. Even liberals begrudgingly accept separation of powers.
Regulatory agencies exist based on the theory that Congress can leave it to agencies to "fill in the details" of a law as part of the executive discretion about how to enforce the law. In the Clean Air Act, Congress gave the EPA authority to pick toxic pollutants to regulate, and to specify the use of particular emissions control technologies like scrubbers.
What this case was about was whether this grant of authority could be fairly read to encompass telling entire industries what power generation mix they must use.
This is not like requiring the CEO to sign off on a minor bug fix. The reasoning of the Court is that industry-wide changes in power generation mix have sweeping effects on the country, and require specific authorization. Even huge companies routinely require executive approval for major new initiatives that will incur major costs to the company.
- scarmig 4y agoFrom the text of the Clean Air Act itself: > (1) The term "standard of performance" means a standard for emissions of air pollutants which reflects the degree of emission limitation achievable through the application of the best system of emission reduction which (taking into account the cost of achieving such reduction and any nonair quality health and environmental impact and energy requirements) the Administrator determines has been adequately demonstrated. Congress intentionally broadly authorized the EPA to determine and implement the best system for reducing pollutants such as carbon emissions, and used language pursuant to that. Just because it offends certain Justices' sensibilities and ideological predilections doesn't mean that they can choose to ignore clearly stated parts of lawfully enacted statutes.
- cogman10 4y ago> That is incorrect. Congress cannot broadly delegate authority to make rules with the force of law on the executive branch. Even liberals begrudgingly accept separation of powers. DEA, ATF, FDA, OSHA, CFPB, CDC, EPA, and FCC would all tend to disagree with this assessment. There IS a separation of powers and checks and balances. Congress even passed the "congressional review act" in 1996 which allows them by a majority vote to undo an agencies decision if they feel they've stepped too far. > The reasoning of the Court is that industry-wide changes in power generation mix have sweeping effects on the country, and require specific authorization. Again, the EPA is checked by both the executive branch AND congress through the CRA. Both of which are checked by the people. Rather than apply straight forward and obvious rules that have been around for at least 30 years (Chevron deference), the supreme court has decided to take a politically activist route and instead decide cases based on their own political leanings. You can predict, like clockwork, how the justices will vote on any case with any sort of political implication based on who appointed them. Isn't that distressing? Doesn't that signal that maybe there's a major problem here? They are picking the conclusion they want to reach and writing the opinions that support those outcomes. They are legislating from the bench.
- scarmig 4y ago> You can predict, like clockwork, how the justices will vote on any case with any sort of political implication based on who appointed them. Isn't that distressing? Doesn't that signal that maybe there's a major problem here? To be fair, you can do this with judges on both sides of the partisan divide. It's good and appropriate to recognize that the Court is a fundamentally political institution and not some mere interpreter of law, and being distressed over that implies that the Court could be some idealized, nonpolitical institution. That's not a useful way to model the Court and never has been.
- cogman10 4y ago> To be fair, you can do this with judges on both sides of the partisan divide. At the supreme court level? Yes, because it takes 4 votes to chose which case gets cert and we have 6 activist justices that want to completely rewrite jurisprudence for political gain. How are the liberal justices supposed to vote when the questions often being asked are now "Hey, should we overrule this long standing precedent for political motivations?" However, standard jurisprudence isn't nearly this bad in the federal court level. The outcomes there can be far more difficult to predict based on who appointed them. > It's good and appropriate to recognize that the Court is a fundamentally political institution and not some mere interpreter of law, and being distressed over that implies that the Court could be some idealized, nonpolitical institution. That's not a useful way to model the Court and never has been. While I don't disagree, unfortunately the constitution was setup with the notion that the SC would be above political divide (hence, being unelected and having lifetime appointments.) I certainly wouldn't mind some sort of constitutional amendment trying to address that. Though, I just don't see it as likely.
- rayiner 4y ago> DEA, ATF, FDA, OSHA, CFPB, CDC, EPA, and FCC would all tend to disagree with this assessment. They wouldn't, at least not to a court's face. You mention "Chevron deference" below, but the whole idea behind Chevron deference is that agencies are exercising executive discretion in enforcing the law, not making new ones. > There IS a separation of powers and checks and balances. Congress even passed the "congressional review act" in 1996 which allows them by a majority vote to undo an agencies decision if they feel they've stepped too far. The Constitution gives the power to make laws to Congress. Full stop. > Rather than apply straight forward and obvious rules that have been around for at least 30 years (Chevron deference), the supreme court has decided to take a politically activist route and instead decide cases based on their own political leanings. Judges in the mid-20th century engaged in massive political activism to rewrite the Constitution from whole cloth. Undoing that tomfoolery is not itself "political activism." > You can predict, like clockwork, how the justices will vote on any case with any sort of political implication based on who appointed them. Isn't that distressing? It distresses me that you can predict how liberal justices will vote on any significant case. It brings me great relief that conservative justices are full of surprises. Just in the last few years, ACB was supposed to overturn Obamacare (she voted to uphold it), Gorsuch and Kavanaugh were supposed to find that the Civil Rights Act doesn't protect sexual orientation, etc.