4 ms·
They talk elsewhere about "clear delegation", and it doesn't have to do with the scope of the delegation, it has to do with its precision: > Thus, in certain e
by lolinder 4y ago
They talk elsewhere about "clear delegation", and it doesn't have to do with the scope of the delegation, it has to do with its precision:
> Thus, in certain extraordinary cases, both separation of powers principles and a practical understanding of legislative intent make us “reluctant to read into ambiguous statutory text” the delegation claimed to be lurking there. To convince us otherwise, something more than a merely plausible textual basis for
the agency action is necessary. The agency instead must point to “clear congressional authorization” for the power it claims.
I can find nowhere where they say that Congress cannot delegate broad powers, only that it's not obvious that Congress did or that they intended to. Do you have a citation to the contrary, or are you making assumptions based on the news coverage?
- hindsightbias 4y ago“something more than a merely plausible textual basis for the agency action is necessary” I love it when textualists go anti-textualist. If people are going to espouse an absolutist ideology, they should at least be consistent.
- lolinder 4y ago"Beyond merely plausible" is what they're looking for, not "beyond textual".
- scarmig 4y agoRequiring Congress to precisely enumerating every possible use of authority indefinitely into the future is by definition limiting the scope of authority that Congress can delegate. Imagine Congress passes an act next year banning abortion, and creates a new agency to enforce that act. The next year, a new method is invented that can induce abortions. Can that agency regulate it? By the logic of the Court, it can't, because Congress never explicitly authorized regulation of that particular form of abortion (because it didn't exist yet).
- lolinder 4y agoYou're still assuming that the Court says Congress needs to enumerate powers. I don't see that. I see the Court saying that Congress didn't explicitly grant broad powers. Do you have a citation that shows that the court is saying that Congress cannot grant broad powers?
- scarmig 4y agoYou can read the particular text granting the authority here: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2013-title42/html/USCODE-2013-title42-chap85-subchapI-partA-sec7411.htm https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2013-title42/html... If you think that isn't a broad, explicit grant of authority to regulate air pollution from stationary sources, I don't know what to tell you. The majority on the decision are basically saying, "well, my gut says they didn't mean that much authority, so we're going to shut down this program."
- rayiner 4y agoThe specific delegation is the power to set "standards of performance," which is explicitly defined: "term 'standard of performance' means a standard for emissions of air pollutants which reflects the degree of emission limitation achievable through the application of the best system of emission reduction...." The term "system of emissions reduction" means control technology like scrubbers. What the law says is that the EPA can do is look at the state of the art for things like particulate matter scrubbers, and set an emissions standard based on the reduction that can be achieved using those technologies. But it's infeasible using current technology to scrub out CO2 from power plant emissions.
- scarmig 4y ago> The term "system of emissions reduction" means control technology like scrubbers. So the Majority asserts. The law, however, specifies nothing of the sort and intentionally uses broad phrasing. The plain meaning of "system of emissions reduction" is "a set of measures that work together to reduce emissions" (as the EPA itself points out). And this is consistent with usage elsewhere in the Clean Air Act: in it, Congress refers to a cap-and-trade setup as an "emission allocation and transfer system." Systems clearly can be things that aren't just control technology. The Majority is inventing an arbitrary and unsupported narrow definition of system for ideological reasons.
- pierrebai 4y agoJust read the dissenting opinions. That you chose not to, clearly, is a choice you made to avoid confronting differing viewpoints. Also, consistently and repeatedly asking others to research for you is an easy debating tactic used frequently to bury inconvenient facts behind a barrage of requests.