3 ms·
Democrats need to shake this notion that Republicans represent "minority rule" because it both delegitimizes our institutions and goads Democrats into overplayi
by rayiner 4y ago
Democrats need to shake this notion that Republicans represent "minority rule" because it both delegitimizes our institutions and goads Democrats into overplaying their hand. Republicans won almost 1.5 million more total votes in 2016 for the House, the country's primary law-making body: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_United_States_House_of_Representatives_elections https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_United_States_House_of_Re.... They are on pace to win the House again in 2022 by millions of votes, like they did in 2010: https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/generic-ballot https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/generic-ballot.
Features like the Electoral College can lead to different incentives in close elections, but even that does not systematically favor Republicans. As recently as 2012, the Electoral College favored Democrats. Obama would have won in 2012 even if he had lost the popular vote: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/did-democrats-get-lucky-in-the-electoral-college/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/did-democrats-get-lucky... ("President Obama won the Electoral College fairly decisively last year despite a margin of just 3.8 percentage points in the national popular vote. In fact, Mr. Obama would probably have won the Electoral College even if the popular vote had slightly favored Mitt Romney.")
- maxerickson 4y agoAnd the Senate? You seem to try to imply that they are not important to legislation, which is just silly.
- knubie 4y agoThe Senate represents the individual states, not the people. The fact that relatively small states like Delaware have as much representation in the Senate as large populous states like New York is by design, and was a critical for the creation of the Union in the first place.
- dctoedt 4y ago> The fact that relatively small states like Delaware have as much representation in the Senate as large populous states like New York is by design, and was a critical for the creation of the Union in the first place. Yeah, but conditions have changed somewhat since 1787 — not least, what genteel white Southern ladies used to sometimes refer to as The Late Unpleasantness (1861-65).
- joshstrange 4y agoAnd I'm sure no one is disenfranchised by feeling their vote doesn't "count" or matter due to gerrymandering. /s > As recently as 2012, the Electoral College favored Democrats. Obama would have won in 2012 even if he had lost the popular vote Except he didn't lose the popular vote. That "honor" is reserved for the last 2 republican presidents (2000 & 2016)
- rayiner 4y ago> And I'm sure no one is disenfranchised by feeling their vote doesn't "count" or matter due to gerrymandering. And Republicans in California and New York feel like their vote doesn’t matter when it comes to the Presidential popular vote. So why do you act like that matters? > Except he didn't lose the popular vote. The point is that you can’t complain that the Electoral College is systematically stacked against Democrats.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI'm not sure why people bring up the popular vote as if it means something. The popular vote was never intended to decide presidential elections.
- joshstrange 4y ago> I'm not sure why people bring up the popular vote as if it means something. Because it clearly shows the president is not picked by the people but through an abstraction that steals voting power from some and gives it to others. > The popular vote was never intended to decide presidential elections. And black people counted as 3/5th, women couldn’t vote, black people couldn’t vote, the entire bill of rights, and more were “never intended”. That’s such a silly argument.
- bhupy 4y ago> Because it clearly shows the president is not picked by the people but through an abstraction that steals voting power from some and gives it to others. That "abstraction" is known as "degressive proportionality" [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Degressive_proportionality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Degressive_proportionality], which is also used by the EU to apportion seats in the European Parliament. The US's system aims to make sure that the President is elected by a broad base of voters across disparate states, the same way the EU elects its Chief Executive (today that's Ursula von der Leyen) in a manner that dilutes the power of highly populated Member States. You generally use counter-majoritarian institutions like equal representation and/or degressive proportionality if what you're trying to build is a Federal union, and not a unitary state. The United States is not and has never been a unitary state. The individual States are unitary in nature; it's impossible to elect the Governor of a State without winning the popular vote, in that State. > And black people counted as 3/5th, women couldn’t vote, black people couldn’t vote, the entire bill of rights, and more were “never intended”. That’s such a silly argument. This is a non-sequitur. The counter-majoritarian institutions of the Federal government aren't unique to the US (see: Australia's Senate, Switzerland's Council of States, Argentina's Senate, Mexico's Senate, the EU), and is certainly unrelated to the very real evils of slavery or disenfranchisement of Black people. It's just a way to organize large heterogeneous polities. The same way that it doesn't make sense to invalidate the Constitution's right to a free/fair trial just because it also happened to include some unrelated bad things, so too is slavery entirely irrelevant to the question of whether the US ought to be a Federal union. The core question at hand is: should the US be a unitary country or should it be a Federal country. As long as it's a Federal country (i.e. the status quo), you will have counter-majoritarian institutions at the Federal level. Even in Canada, the Prime Minister's party won fewer votes than the rival party, but still won more seats in Parliament. In 2019(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Canadian_federal_election https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Canadian_federal_election) the Liberal party won ~6M votes and won 157 seats in Parliament, while the Conservative Party won ~6.2M votes but only won 121 seats. The same thing happened in 2021 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Canadian_federal_election); https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Canadian_federal_election... ~5.5M votes to 160 seats vs ~5.7M votes to 119 seats. This means that the plurality vote getter did not win the plurality of seats, and thereby did not enjoy the possibility to drive the formation of a majority coalition. The reason for this is that many of the Conservative Party's votes were clustered in specific parts of Canada, and there were diminishing returns to driving up large majorities in those clusters; you have to appeal to multiple disparate clusters. This is a feature and not a bug of Canada's Federal system, because the goal is to optimize for the breadth of voters, not just the depth of voters, especially at the Federal level where policy impacts everybody, and not just a single state/province.
- radley 4y ago> Republicans won almost 1.5 million more total votes in 2016 for the House, the country's primary law-making body Cherry-picked stats are banal. Democrats won almost 5 million more votes in the CURRENT election, which is more than the entire population of Mississippi and West Virginia combined. That's why it's not unfair to claim a "minority rule" at play. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_United_States_House_of_Representatives_elections https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_United_States_House_of_Re... https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_population https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_pop...
- rayiner 4y agoIf Republicans match their 2010 performance, which seems very possible, they’ll win the House in 2022 by 6 million+ votes. Do they get to declare everything the Biden administration did “minority rule” when that happens?