4 ms·
One can read a ruling and see how many hoops the justices jumped through to get to a particular decision. Let me lead by saying I'm a pro choice person, and ho
by ErikVandeWater 4y ago
One can read a ruling and see how many hoops the justices jumped through to get to a particular decision.
Let me lead by saying I'm a pro choice person, and hope federal legislation is passed protecting abortion in all 50 states:
Roe V. Wade is a good example. The justices didn't find any mention of "abortion", any description of abortion, or any medical procedure whatsoever in the constitution, or any mention of "trimesters". Yet they found by using a combination of no less than 5 amendments, that it in fact was protected, and then the supreme court decided exactly how long into a pregnancy abortion could be banned. They probably had consistent logic in what they said technically, but it strained credulity too much to believe they actually thought the constitution, in the text as it was written, protected a right to abortion.
Would you agree the sword cuts both ways with regards to the statement:
> I don't believe people on this site are too stupid to realize that, I believe they prefer not to, because they support the outcomes these rulings enact.
- philosopher1234 4y agoYes I agree, I think its a universal human quality. And I think we should start talking about abortion directly, not through 50 layers of legaleze. The only way a pro-lifer on HN can express their opinion is indirectly, through technical criticism. But why can't they express their pro life opinion directly? Because people will disagree with them? The only thing people do on HN is disagree. This is the issue that needs exploring, not the intricacies of judicial logic.
- CptJupiterNorth 4y agoThis community isn't what I thought it was, either. I'm new to commenting, and my account has negative karma because I said something true that the 2A people didn't like.
- philosopher1234 4y agoWelcome. People aren't likely to lay their cards on the table, but this is a political place like anywhere else.
- cityofdelusion 4y agoCommenting on politics anywhere is like playing with pigs. You're going to get dirty.