4 ms·
How does land have power over people? States with more land don't have more representation than states with less land, but states with more people do have more
by josephcsible 4y ago
How does land have power over people? States with more land don't have more representation than states with less land, but states with more people do have more representation than states with fewer people. As a concrete example, New Jersey has the same representation in the Senate and 12x the representation in the House as Alaska, despite only having 1% of the land of Alaska.
- joshstrange 4y agoMaybe that was badly phrased but it refers to states having more power than they should (or less) due to how the electoral college and senators work.
- hellojesus 4y agoIt was designed that way on purpose.
- halostatue 4y agoYes. To give the slave states power beyond their value.
- robonerd 4y agoThe value of those states was not in question when they threatened succession; they were important enough to fight a war over. Nor would many of the states have joined the union in the first place if not for this system, so America wouldn't have existed in the first place if you had your way. The entire country is premised on this compromise.
- krapp 4y agoThe centuries-old political climate in which the electoral college was born has little if any bearing on its utility for the modern United States. I doubt the only thing keeping rural states in the union now is leverage against abolitionists.
- hellojesus 4y agoIt was designed to prevent tyranny of the majority.
- CamperBob2 4y agoThis argument comes up often, but I've never understood how tyranny of the minority is any better.
- krapp 4y agoThe people who make that argument are usually benefactors of that tyranny.
- hellojesus 4y agoIt's because tyranny of the minority means prevention against new laws, not the enactment of them. It's the safer path, generally not absolutely. A bias towards inaction.
- krapp 4y agoTyranny of the minority only means prevention of laws the minority disagrees with. That minority hasn't, historically, taken issue with new laws that cater to them.
- ALotOfBees 4y agoIt's funny that you mention Alaska, because they are the #1 overall state when it comes to Senate and Electoral College "voter power". As you said, they get the same Senate representation despite having a fraction of the population of NJ. In addition, each vote cast in Alaska counts far more towards the presidential election than a vote in NJ does.
- hellojesus 4y agoThat's because the federal level is supposed to only deal with federal matters and be nonexistent elsewhere. Each state has the same weight in the senate because they are all equal players in that space. The house has the bias towards population. Most regulation is supposed to take place at the state level.
- joshstrange 4y ago> Each state has the same weight in the senate because they are all equal players in that space. Except they represent wildly different populations and all have equal say in the senate. > The house has the bias towards population. One that has been capped by the DC Admission Act and perverted by gerrymandering. > Most regulation is supposed to take place at the state level. Says who? How in the world does that work for things like pollution (which isn't stopped at state lines) or basic rights such as the right to love who you love and/or get married?
- hellojesus 4y ago> Says who? How in the world does that work for things like pollution (which isn't stopped at state lines) or basic rights such as the right to love who you love and/or get married? Says the Constitution... 10th Ammendment: any power not explicitly enumerated to congress is left to the states. Article 1 Section 8 enumerates the powers that the federal government has, along with some granted through ammendments.
- joshstrange 4y ago