4 ms·
Nobody in the comments is saying that the Supreme Court is wrong in the sense that the logic doesn’t follow. Of course it’s nuanced and up to interpretation, th
by Spivak 4y ago
Nobody in the comments is saying that the Supreme Court is wrong in the sense that the logic doesn’t follow. Of course it’s nuanced and up to interpretation, that’s why most decisions are split — and usually split on “conservative (do what I say) and liberal (do what I mean).
The reason people are mad is because the court is relitigating long settled cases which breaks the main principle of the court which is don’t break userspace without damn good reason. We know they think the decisions were made incorrectly but the bar of “this is crucially important we fix” I don’t think it is being met. Instead it’s at best tone deaf to the real life effects of their decisions and more likely motivated to achieve specific partisan legislative outcomes.
- woojoo666 4y agoI'm curious about this "do what I say" vs "do what I mean" partisan split. I can see how this particular case clearly applies, but you have any other examples?
- zionic 4y ago>The reason people are mad is because the court is relitigating long settled cases which breaks the main principle of the court A bad decision is a bad decision no matter how long it's been in effect. If anything, following "precedent" is what got us into this mess in the first place. We could have ripped the bandaid off decades ago on abortion and fixed it then. Now it's going to be much more messy.
- tablespoon 4y ago> A bad decision is a bad decision no matter how long it's been in effect. If anything, following "precedent" is what got us into this mess in the first place. We could have ripped the bandaid off decades ago on abortion and fixed it then. Now it's going to be much more messy. IMHO, what actually got us in this mess was the Supreme Court putting itself into a situation where it's regularly making momentous political decisions, rather that resolving finer points of law, resolving little corner cases, etc. It might be expedient to use its power to set social and economic policy, but that doesn't mean it's right.
- InTheArena 4y agoIt seems like they are trying to step back with this (and force the regulators to have law as well). Given the horrifically vitriolic hate-filled partisan crap-fest we are in - it is much too late for that.
- bcrosby95 4y agoMost decisions are actually not split. It's just that the controversial ones get all the press. No one is gonna get fired up about 9-0 or 8-1 decisions.
- panda-giddiness 4y agoThis is incorrect – most cases are split. The most common outcome is 9-0 (about a third of cases), but the second most common split is 5-4. This shouldn't be surprising – controversial cases are more likely to end up before the Supreme Court than mundane ones. [1] http://supremecourtdatabase.org/analysisFrequencies.php?sid=2101-PUSHPIN-1035#mid http://supremecourtdatabase.org/analysisFrequencies.php?sid=...
- iostream24 4y agoThis is one of the most reasonable comments I’ve read today, and yet it’s grayed out. That’s not acceptable. HN is being taken over by bullies and I’m tired of not even have my basic comment voting rights.
- rory 4y ago> The reason people are mad is because the court is relitigating long settled cases How many of those same people were mad about Obergefell, which did just that?